Quote from: MaidofOrleans on August 23, 2013, 07:06:09 PM
I fell in love with Calpernia after watching this video.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjqsB1huDxg&list=TLJ1mHewTBWlA
Oh you sassy girl you 
I guess I'm alone in this, but I don't find Calpernia Addams 'sassy' or cool, or admirable. What I see (and this is just a personal response) is a person - irrespective of gender, race, age, whatever - who comes across as snarky, bitter, intolerant, aggressive, bitter and really not very funny.
I can understand exactly why she would feel angry, given her life experience. And I'm totally not defending any of the people whose words or actions brought her to that point. But heres the thing - there's no point fighting hate with hate.
This isn't some kind of 'turn the other cheek' self-sacrifice. It's just that no one likes being met with anger and hostility. So if we want people to be tolerant and accepting of us, then it helps if we're tolerant and accepting of them. Be assertive. Insist on respect. But do it in such a way that people understand why it's justified. Think of the people who've really changed things - Jesus Christ, Dr King, Mandela, Gandhi. Their passion, their conviction and their fury were never in doubt. But they found a way to bring people with them. They had dreams and visions of a better world that all of us could share.
But when I see Calpernia Addams I don't see a woman with much of an interest in sharing anything. She wants to express her rage by driving away all the people who have hurt her. Again, I understand. But what good does that do?
Many of the questions she objects to might be asked in genuine innocence by people who mean no harm, don't know very much about transgender issues, don't understand what transition involves and certainly haven't been educated to know about what is and is not offensive (always assuming there are cut and dried rules about that, because - as is true for many, many issues - what is profoundly offensive to one person may be a lot less so to someone else).
Now, Calpernia may say, 'Well those people damn well SHOULD know. It's their damn duty to inform themselves.' But how are they going to do that if every question they ask is greeted with an angry, sarcastic sneer?
For example, is it really so unreasonable to ask whether SRS hurts? Plenty of girls on here who've not had the operation ask girls who have whether it hurts, how long it takes to recover, what the process involves, etc. It's natural. So if we don't know, and want to know, why should everyone else be any different?
And when people preface a question by saying, 'I don't want to be offensive, but ...' maybe they're just telling the simple truth. They don't want to be offensive, but they do want to know something about transsexuality and they just don't know how to ask, so they're trying to let you know they mean no harm.
That's not to say that there aren't many, many insensitive, intolerant, transphobic a-holes in the world. And I certainly don't think they should be indulged. Nor do I think we should just roll over and let people treat us like dirt.
But if we want more acceptance from the great mass of the population, sneering at them is one surefire way NOT to get it.
So, I'm sorry, but Calpernia doesn't make my idol/role-model list ...