Fantastic Gothique, you are unmasked (like unplugged for MTV). Look great with or without makeup I bet.
Kate, if more makeup than lip gloss makes you look more masculine,
its simply because your not adept at using it. It can take
awhile to put the appropriate ammount in the right shade in the right spots.
You don't even like to wear mascara Kate ?
You don't have to wear darkest black, there are less striking shades.
I love mascara, my eyelashes, already long, look incredibly long with it.
I look pretty similar without makeup because my eyes are well defined, I think most of my pictures here are with little or no makeup, in the avatar, I think I'm only wearing liptick. What I wear most is mascara (black brown) and lipstick (I have tons of them, dark reds mixed with chocolate brown is my favorite shade (its L'OREAL, its called cheetah limited edition (I can't find it anymore :-()).
This is "no makeup me", close enough to see tiny brownish spots and pores :-).

This is as heavyly made up as I'd care to be. Light foundation, eyes, lips and blush.

There is an improvement in the second picture, but not as much as for blonds, or someone's who's pale. Most time, wear mascara and that's it, so I'd look more like first picture.