I'm not stalking you. I swear! Although it is starting to seem that way...

Anyway...
Quote from: Nora Flexion on March 03, 2014, 06:36:58 PM
I'm still waiting to see what HRT will do for my face, if anything at all. I lost about 50lbs a couple years ago, to the point of being just borderline underweight. Still kinda floating around that lower end of "healthy" which feels nice with my relatively active lifestyle. But the weight loss left my face really deflated, and I absolutely hate it because it looks ~soooo odd~ (and masculine) from some angles, unless I carry a big cheesy grin 24x7 to puff up my cheeks...
I have the same exact problem. I dropped ~65 pounds over the past two years. And, it hollowed out my face. And although HRT is causing me to gain back weight (15 pounds in the last three weeks... GRRRR) it's all filling out my gut, strangely, and very irritatingly...
Quote from: Nora Flexion on March 03, 2014, 06:36:58 PM
I know what you guys will probably say if you've seen my pictures, you'll probably say that I already pass and don't need surgery. But keep in mind I'm only showing you the most flattering ones from the best angles. I don't pass as well in 3 dimensions as you might think. Pictures tend to lie. 
I've seen you in person... Soo... Being brutally honest (and, please feel free to reciprocate it. I'm firmly convinced the rest of my friends will NEVER give me constructive criticism because they're afraid I'll think they're insensitive bigoted ->-bleeped-<-s)... Your jaw and chin do emphasize a little bit of masculinity. Not from every angle, mind you, and really only when you're smiling real big. I honestly have the same problem. I solve it by not smiling, ever, which sucks, but, I also have a very british smile and I'm WAAAY more self conscious about that than any facial feature, so for me the lack of a smile is a twofer. A friend of mine pointed out there are makeup tricks to emphasize/create the illusion of fullness in the cheeks. Once I can get her to teach me said tricks I'll pass that along. I've also found that keeping my head slightly angled down deemphasizes my chin, although it's hard to do in any situations other than just looking in the mirror.
Quote from: Nora Flexion on March 03, 2014, 06:36:58 PM
The upper half of my face is much less problematic IMO. I couldn't give less of a ->-bleeped-<- about my nose right now. I honestly don't know if it is masculinizing or not, but I have never really hated it so why fuss over it? The only other things I am seriously considering messing with up there are my noticable brow bone/forehead, and my hairline, with its badly receding corners.
Your brow was only really noticeable to me in total profile. And even then it wasn't that bad. And, how often do we sit there and look at people in total profile anyway? I mean, aside from mug shots? At best it's somebody walking past us, or, as was the case with me, sitting next to us. And, of those, sitting is really the only one where someone will be there long enough to really notice anything. I always keep my head cocked to the side. I don't know if it helps. I hope it does. It probably makes me look stupid to anyone looking head on though. Sight...
Quote from: Nora Flexion on March 03, 2014, 06:36:58 PM
Sometimes when I look in the mirror, I can see my mother or my sister. In fact, sometimes when I walk by a mirror I'm startled because I swear I look just like my sister. The weird thing is that whatever features make me see my sister or my mom, it seems that make-up really brings them out somehow. That's unexplainably strange because I've never know either my mom or my sister to wear much makeup. But makeup works miracles for me, at least in my own eyes, with regards to passing---and eyeliner has been my secret weapon. When I wash it all down the drain my face is completely male again, *and* I lose that connection to my family. It goes straight down the drain with my makeup. I just don't get it. 
I like my face better as a female face, because not only does it feel right, but I feel more connected to my family. And while I can't deny that it's still difficult to be seeing a "new" face staring back from the mirror, the connection I feel to my mom and my sister helps a LOT.
Here's the thing that worries me when it comes to FFS. While I can't put my finger on it exactly, I am pretty sure most of these recognizable features are coming from the upper half of my face, above my jaw. I don't want to cheat myself out of having the best possible FFS, but I also don't want to destroy the connection I feel when I look in the mirror. I'm afraid of the idea of losing that recognizability. Therefore, I'm waffling about the idea of doing anything whatsoever to my face above my mandible.
I also look in the mirror these days and see my mother... In a weird creepy Freudian kind of way I think that's why I like wearing purple eye shadow more than other colors... A. I think it looks better on me... And B. When I was growing up my mom had these glasses that were tinted purple along the top half of the lenses, so that when you looked at her face on it looked like she was wearing purple eye shadow... I had actually totally totally forgotten about that until right now. Weird. But, I get the familial connection. There are some features of my face which are very reminisce of my mother (eyes, mouth, ears). And some that are very reminisce of my grandfather (nose, chin, jaw). When I first started down the road to transition, and I was pondering what all I wanted to do along the way, I thought "scrap this face. Start over"... But, the more I've been looking at myself in the mirror... I dunno. I think all I would do is just slightly deemphasize my chin and brow and call it a day. My face would still be pretty manly. But, there are plenty of ciswomen with manly features. And, well, it would at least still be authentically me.