Wow, I just realized that I'm only a few days shy of 2 years post-op. For a long time, I felt like everything was simply smashed flat against my body, like the best job of tucking ever. As the swelling subsided and nerves regenerated that tucked feeling disappeared, and I can feel the tissue where it actually is.
I can't explain why it doesn't feel like an inside out penis - perhaps because my mind always felt that the penis was an inside-out vagina? Anyway, the best way to describe what I feel now is "normal".