This might be off topic as I can't offer advice about the original question, but I'm not sure it's worth/suitable/appropriate to start a new thread about? As it's still related to some of the things being said.
Quote from: suzifrommd on June 09, 2014, 10:31:54 AM
I'm not sure I agree that this is good advice for everyone.
Remember, some people are kinesthetically gifted. They can get their body to move how they want, do well in sports. Some people are socially gifted. They easily pick up social cues and figure out how to fit in.
The rest of us struggle. Even though we don't talk about it a lot (especially around people for whom physical and social presence is easy), that doesn't mean we don't exist.
I'm bothered by the mindset that we should just "be ourselves" and be content with a non-passing existence, or just sit and watch how other people do it and pick it up ourselves.
Isn't it possible that some of us need some extra help? Not everyone. Some people can do it on their own. But though you find it easy, can I ask you not to assume that everyone does?
People who are socially and kinesthetically challenged deserve to pass too.
Why can't you be yourself and pass? Seems like plenty of people manage it.
I know that if you don't behave in the social defined 'female' box, people may spare you a few extra moments of thought that might lead to them noticing other things that could raise their suspicions. So I can see that depending on how you look and the attitudes of the locals, it might be necessary simply to help avert suspicion.
Yet, I've encountered plenty of girls/women while growing up who were just themselves. Whether they were andro/masculine, loud, tomboys or just didn't care to sacrifice a part of who they were to 'fit in', they always passed. (yeah, they were cis, but it's possible for cis women to not pass too. I remember a thread about electrolysis and the number of cis women getting some facial hair removed because it was a bit too noticeable and causing misgendering issues)
So, where is the balance? The balance between assimilating and being yourself? If you do things to fit in, just because it's what others do or have said you 'should' do, then are you not just creating another character, another mask, another falsehood?
I'm not saying this to criticize you or anyone who wants to fit in more to pass. It's something I genuinely struggle with too. I see both aspects I just mentioned and feel stuck. The pragmatist says 'just fit in' but the girl says 'screw what they want. I want OUT'.
I'm introverted, and not really socially gifted. I've always used being somewhat outcast to allow myself to be as true to myself as possible. I didn't even try to fit in as male, just tried to redefine what being a man is, while not standing out too much. So now that I'm transitioning, I don't want to have to adopt the social female behavioral model because then I would actually be moving even further from myself than when I tried to be a man. The irony, it would be funny if it weren't so tragic.
Quote from: mandonlym on June 09, 2014, 02:41:36 PM
I'm happy to organize a Google hangout if anyone's interested in exploring this. It's something I'm interested in. I have a performance background and am naturally social / extroverted, so being able to adapt to different environments and be seen as a woman hasn't been a major problem for me. It would be good to discuss these issues with other people and also maybe I and others can provide feedback and advice.
That's a great idea. I'd definitely be interested. Experience is far more valuable than just theory-crafting.