Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

it hurts...

Started by jossef-ftm, July 24, 2014, 06:35:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

jossef-ftm

I have a sister she is almost 16 she dont know about me being a trans she dont even know what a trans mean,she think its just my style that i look like a guy...i didn't comeout cause i tried before and people start think i'm a fool and have mentale issues, anyway i can remember a day she was talking to her friends and they were asking her about me and make fun of the way i look then i heard her telling them that ''he is my brother he is a boy '' and they know the truth but she said that and they were like (oh yea right and keep laughing) this happened when she was 14 ..before 3 weeks she keep telling me '' i wish if i have a brother'' and she was telling me the same everyday and that kinda hurt my feelings too bad idk why she keep saying that..i was feeling bad it hurt my feelings too much... i mean a big part of me want to scream and tell her i'm ur brother but its not that easy and shes too young to understand just want to share it with you guys..maybe someone of u had that before from a family member idk..and sorry for my bad english...
Sometimes, it's hard to find words to tell you how much you mean to me. A lot of times, I don't say anything at all. But I hope someday, you'll understand, having you is what I live for...(I Love you my Queen )
  •  

jossef-ftm

yea and i always get that..from family members all the time they be like oh i wish if u were born a boy we wouldn't face all this crap from people and stuffs they say...and from a girl that i liked in the past she was like u r good looking oh how i wish if u were a boy...
Sometimes, it's hard to find words to tell you how much you mean to me. A lot of times, I don't say anything at all. But I hope someday, you'll understand, having you is what I live for...(I Love you my Queen )
  •  

Brandon

I know how you feel man accept my mom doesn't want a son well when she was prego with me she was hoping I wasn't bcause she needed a man in her life because she couldn't raise a man even though she is. But my sister always says she wishes she had a brother and there are times were I wanna tell her I am your brother. But don't think that just because she's 14 that ahe won't understand I told a girl like that I was trans when she was 14 going on 15 and she understood and I'm telling you she's a 100% straight so don't think everyone is gonna judge you for it you'll find a girl I am still working on the girl I love but for other reasons. And if you haven't come out to your fam do it, I didn't have luck but maybe you will.
keep working hard and you can get anything you want.    -Aaliyah
  •  

Skyler

  I have an older brother (19) not as young as your sister but fairly close in age. By a slip of the tong my dad told my bro that I was trans* and identified as male. My brother identifies as a cis straight male and well his reaction was more then perfect. He said along the lines of that : he thought something was wrong for awhile and was bothering me, "if my brother feels that way then i fully support him."

  I don't know fully about your situation however 16 isn't that young but ofc we don't know her standing on LGBT issues and rights..but if she seems to be supportive of them..why not tell her? Or maybe wait a couple of years. Its really your decision. Could try and send her some reading material :o


Be brave be strong  \o/
~Sky

  •  

invisiblemonsters

i told my brother when he was 12, he is now 14 and he never uses the wrong pronouns, etc. he is very supportive! your sister isn't too far off from my brothers age and will probably understand. she might not know what trans is but honestly, if she already feels that way then she might just be understanding. she won't be weirded out by it if she is already wishing you were that kind of figure in her life. your dynamic won't change for the worse (hopefully) and because you feel more comfortable and she is seeing you how you truly are and starts treating you like her brother i guess, your relationship might just even be stronger. that is my opinion though.
  •  

Edge

Your sister sounds pretty supportive of you. Out of curiosity, why does it hurt you that she calls you her brother? Aren't you? Why do you think she is too young to understand?
  •  

Brandon

Quote from: Edge on July 24, 2014, 08:30:10 PM
Your sister sounds pretty supportive of you. Out of curiosity, why does it hurt you that she calls you her brother? Aren't you? Why do you think she is too young to understand?

Because he can't come out to his family, And  they say they wish they had a brother or son.
keep working hard and you can get anything you want.    -Aaliyah
  •  

makipu

Wow, I envy your brother's response Skyler...
I am male because I say so and nothing more.
I don't have to look or act like one therefore.
  •  

aross1015

Quote from: Edge on July 24, 2014, 08:30:10 PM
Your sister sounds pretty supportive of you. Out of curiosity, why does it hurt you that she calls you her brother? Aren't you? Why do you think she is too young to understand?

I'm pretty sure it's her saying she wishes she had a brother, because he views himself as her brother.  He even goes on to say ".i was feeling bad it hurt my feelings too much... i mean a big part of me want to scream and tell her i'm ur brother"
  •  

AquaWhatever

Well, it sounds to me like she may already suspect you are her bro already.
Which is why she's saying things like she wishes you were her brother.
Maybe she knows a lot more then you think.
(I could be wrong, but just a thought)
  •  

Natkat

I think that what your sister is saying this is a sign they do get the feeling but won't admit or don't understand it fully.
When I was in school and had not came out yet I got people talking on me. some start bulling me saying.
"so who is the new boy" or "should we call you martin"
I did not mind this, as this was how I wanted to be seen even if I was not taking seriously.
Now thinking back I belive alot of the people who have said these things have deep down seen it comming.
it wasnt really that huge of a surprice when I changed again. some where surprized but I also reach reactions from some of them who wasnt surprised of this at all. even for those who had seen the signs early there had not been much to do, I wish there had been more suport but thinking back my life was diffrent. there was not knowlegde and suport about these things as being trans like today and I did not have as much change to go seach for the suport myself as I do now.

today if someone is threading me badly I can find words, aguments and suport which I did not had back then where I did not even thought I had a word which was good enough to be taken seriously.
-
I hope this helps alittle.
p.s. I dont think 16 is too young to understand
I been talking with all kind of age group of being trans kids from 8 and adults, I also do education for the moment on schools and I diffrently belive a 16 year old can get the thing of being trans.
The issue is often the parrent and the sociaty around, Even if you talk to a child who is 8 who get it, it may come home to its parrent and been told it wrong and being scolled. for me this is the biggest challenge. kids and teens are in my opinion more easy than adults but also more limited in there own freedom.


  •  

YinYanga


I know it's frustrating that you're not there yet, her brother yet. But give it time, you're both young and it seems she has already taken a few steps herself which is great
  •  

Ephemeral

Quite frankly, you should tell her. It's better to tell her than feel bad that she's implicitly hurting you because you didn't. She's not too young at all, far from. Even 3-year-olds understand. The problem has nothing to do with ability to understand but sorely with social stigma society attaches on trans people which is very different.
Come watch with me as our world burns.
  •  

conformer

You should have more faith in her, regardless of age she sounds rather supportive. Especially if she had the guts to stand up for you in front of her friends. That can take a lot!

Reminds me of my brother. He and I are 4 years apart and he was only 10 when I came out . . he's been on the of the most supportive people in my life since day one.

GnomeKid

In the context to me it kind of sounds like she may sort of know... Maybe she was just making it up at first to get her friends off her back, but I think in her telling you that she wished she had a brother she might be trying to tell you she accepts you as a boy.  Family can sometimes tell a lot more about us than we think, or even want. 

If anything I would take it as a good sign.  She is open to the idea of you becoming her brother.  She will even find relief in it.  Your sister is, in an odd way, directly dealing with the same pain you have to deal with.  She may not understand it or feel it in the exact same way, but she seems to be bothered by the world not being accepting of you. If she really didn't love you for who you are she would just tell them "oh yea... shes a freak... whatever."
I solemnly swear I am up to no good.

"Oh what a cute little girl, or boy if you grow up and feel thats whats inside you" - Liz Lemon

Happy to be queer!    ;)
  •