MenoImagination, I think you pass more in the second pic, but I think it's a pass for both. It could be the glasses in the 1st pic, or the angle, or the different hairstyles, or a combo of all 3. It's hard to say.
Also don't worry about being overweight, in fact when you get into the "husky" range of just being a little over, sometimes it can help with passing. It did for me, anyway. You have great bone structure, and your face isn't really rounded at all, so for pre-everything you're rocking what you got. Chin up!