Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

High Suicide Rates & Other Things Among Post-op Transsexuals

Started by noah732, August 11, 2014, 08:59:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


mrs izzy

It's sad and true.

GCS is not the fix all.

Will not make all the troubles with work,relationships or family just fall to the way side.

That's why surgery is the last process one should take after everything is settled.

A vaginal is not that magical thing. It's just genital.
Mrs. Izzy
Trans lifeline US 877-565-8860 CAD 877-330-6366 http://www.translifeline.org/
"Those who matter will never judge, this is my given path to walk in life and you have no right to judge"

I used to be grounded but now I can fly.
  •  

stephaniec

I don't think its very surprising given all the possible contributing factors such as employment , housing, family acceptance, isolation  etc. It's a rough road to tread. The only thing you can do is make sure its right for you. I mean your rearranging your genitals, it's not a root canal.
  •  

stephaniec

physicians also have a higher suicide rate compared to the general population, especially psychologists   psychitrists
  •  

mrs izzy

Electricians hold the highest amount construction workers.

2 strikes against me
Mrs. Izzy
Trans lifeline US 877-565-8860 CAD 877-330-6366 http://www.translifeline.org/
"Those who matter will never judge, this is my given path to walk in life and you have no right to judge"

I used to be grounded but now I can fly.
  •  

Carrie Liz

There is a flaw in seeing this study as absolute for all gender-reassigned people, though.

If you look further down the actual study, where it talks about the increased trans mortality rates, a dichotomy existed. Those who were sex-reassigned between 1973 and 1988 had very significantly higher rates of mortality. But those sex-reassigned between 1989 and 2003, although there was still a higher incidence rate than the controls, it was not measured to be statistically significant.

Take this how you want... maybe it's because the culture changed such that trans people were more accepted, and thus trans people endured less minority stress than before, or perhaps because of improvements in SRS techniques, or whatever, this study actually simultaneously showed that SRS has been getting more and more effective over the years at the same time as it was showing that it wasn't the be-all end-all answer for trans people being cured of all of their problems.
  •  

Susan522

Carrie.  I missed where it was noted that the mortality rate was higher from 1973-1989 as opposed to 1989-2003.  I found just the opposite.

"We compared our cohort with randomly selected population controls matched for age and gender. The most striking result was the high mortality rate in both male-to-females and female-to males, compared to the general population. This contrasts with previous reports (with one exception[8]) that did not find an increased mortality rate after sex reassignment, or only noted an increased risk in certain subgroups."

I do see where they seem to contradict that based on the Tables.

My complaint is that they failed to control for the patients' AGE at te time of surgery.
  •  

ativan

Hmmm.... It is a study done in Sweden. They do have a difference there in treatment and from society.
The study repeatedly related to how flawed some of the data was, and how it was studied.
Much of it was data mined from other studies, which I didn't look at individually, but they are available to read.
There is a long list of the related studies that they drew the conclusion from at the end of the article.
They admit in various places the lack of information which does affect the conclusion.
It is an interesting study of Swedish Transsexuals, but readily admits to it's lack of coherent information.
But it does show a trend and it also recommends further studies with better participants and controls.
The real conclusion is that there needs to be a better study done.
There isn't a finite conclusion, although they did actually make one based on the limiting information that was mined.
At best it is a indication and not much more. Much of the conclusion is extrapolated from various sources of data.
My impression is that they have found by a trend that more has to be done for transsexuals as far as further help post surgery.
Just kinda shows what is suspected and is pretty much known by the trans community in Sweden.
To pull out of it bits of information and making a conclusion based on that is an insult to the efforts they made to extract the information as a total.
There is a lot of information, and it can be viewed from various angles.
To draw a conclusion from one angle alone isn't worthy given the various ways it can and is interpreted, in drawing it's conclusion, as flawed as is admitted though out the study as published.

Does anyone have a similar study done in say the US?
One with better participants under better controls?
Worldwide and then also broken down by country or region would be helpful.
Ativan
  •  

noah732

Ativan —

A British study, though I do not have the exact link, showed that suicude rates among post-ops are 18%. And that's not even counting the ones who live with regret.

These numbers make me pretty sick to my stomach. It makes me question the possibility of my own happiness after SRS...
  •  

Rose City Rose

Quote from: noah732 on August 12, 2014, 03:37:42 PM
Ativan —

A British study, though I do not have the exact link, showed that suicude rates among post-ops are 18%. And that's not even counting the ones who live with regret.

These numbers make me pretty sick to my stomach. It makes me question the possibility of my own happiness after SRS...

I've read articles about this.  Much of the problem with the British study was that the patients interviewed felt that they were rushed into surgery and were given unrealistic expectations by their health care providers of the benefits the surgery would bring about.

At any rate, we're a high risk group for depression and other conditions because so many of us lived in secrecy, shame, and repression (by ourselves or by others) that we can't expect a surgery to fix all our problems, realistically.

I think for my part, I'm more concerned about the pain and possible medical complications that either kill me or make my genitals entirely useless then how I'd feel if I had a fully successful operation.
*Started HRT January 2013
*Name and gender marker changed September 2014
*Approved and issued letters for surgery September 2015
*Surgery Consultation November 2015
*Preop electrolysis October 2016-March 2019
*GRS April 3 2019
I DID IT!!!
[/color]
  •  

Eris

Quote from: stephaniec on August 11, 2014, 09:53:00 PM
physicians also have a higher suicide rate compared to the general population, especially psychologists   psychitrists

I'm a psychology student...
I refuse to live in fear! Come hell or high water I will not back down! I will live my life!
But you have no life.
Ha. Even that won't stop me.

I will protect even those I hate, so long as it is right.



  •  

Jenna Marie

One major flaw I see is that it didn't compare to trans people who had not had GRS but identified as wanting it. That would be a much clearer indication of whether GRS is a significant improvement in quality of life or not. I've also seen another, smaller UK study that showed that post-GRS trans women are basically reporting the same happiness and quality of life as cis women, but unfortunately I can't link to it as it's in a paid database. 

It's not totally surprising that trans people might have a higher rate of depression and suicide than the general cis population (gay people do too, and societal oppression and discrimination play a large part in it), but that's not necessarily the same thing at all as saying that GRS does not help.
  •  

Susan522

"Much of the problem with the British study was that the patients interviewed felt that they were rushed into surgery and were given unrealistic expectations by their health care providers of the benefits the surgery would bring about.
"


If this is true, then this is outrageous!
  •  

mrs izzy

Quote from: Jenna Marie on August 12, 2014, 07:00:52 PM
One major flaw I see is that it didn't compare to trans people who had not had GRS but identified as wanting it. That would be a much clearer indication of whether GRS is a significant improvement in quality of life or not. I've also seen another, smaller UK study that showed that post-GRS trans women are basically reporting the same happiness and quality of life as cis women, but unfortunately I can't link to it as it's in a paid database. 

It's not totally surprising that trans people might have a higher rate of depression and suicide than the general cis population (gay people do too, and societal oppression and discrimination play a large part in it), but that's not necessarily the same thing at all as saying that GRS does not help.

So true at some point life for all of us should get better.

There is always hope.
Mrs. Izzy
Trans lifeline US 877-565-8860 CAD 877-330-6366 http://www.translifeline.org/
"Those who matter will never judge, this is my given path to walk in life and you have no right to judge"

I used to be grounded but now I can fly.
  •  

ativan

Noah732, do you have access to more of these studies on hand?
I don't have the time to look for them myself, but it seems like such an obvious study to be doing.
It would seem that the obvious question hasn't been studied very much.
And a comparison to those who haven't had GRS but want it would be a telling sort of thing.
I'm sorry, but I don't keep up on these kinds of studies to much, kinda out of my area, but it would seem that more in-depth ones should be done.
The suicide rates are a major concern for all trans people, regardless.
Something we can all agree on...
Ativan
  •  

noah732

Ativan — They're practically everywhere. Just punch in 'sex change regret' or 'sex change suicide rates' and a flood of tragic stories will flood in.

http://waltheyer.typepad.com/blog/2012/03/sex-change-51-attempt-suicide-have-deep-regret-or-will-not-adjust.html
  •  

ativan

Thanks Noah, I think if everyone took a close look and determined which of these studies are indeed relative and have academic support, a good deal of knowledge could be gained. I prefer studies that have been published in journals more closely relevant to the subject, but that isn't a guarantee they are accurate. That is something to to look for in any studies, with so many being published, peer approval is key, but also the source of the information.
All to often, the results can be skewed, and small samples yield less accurate conclusions.
Sorting through these kinds of things can be difficult.
If reported in say blogs, it is wise to look to see if they aren't picking and choosing data.
Something that can be difficult to do.
It'd be nice to see a comprehensive list of the better studies that have been done.
Skewing data is inadvertently done, as well as intentionally.
Spectacular results with those kinds of conclusions are sometimes used to get more grant money.
Perhaps someone with a good background in these could look through them to sort them out.
My take on most studies, regardless of the content, should be peer approved as a safeguard, but not all need to be.
The Internet is full of information, to much sometimes and it does take a trained eye to spot the ones that are truly meaningful.
Like with everything, no accumulation of data defines a single truth, many of them can be contradicting, yet yield other valuable data, just the same.
Than you for you suggestion, it shows the staggering amount of information and lends to the idea that picking and choosing can be harmful in finding the truth sometimes. It is apparent though that they do show a definite direction of high suicide rates and that aftercare is as important as therapy is from the beginning. Trans is a hard thing to move through society with and we should all be careful as to how we approach it.
Ativan
  •  

Patty_M

Quote from: Ativan Prescribed on August 12, 2014, 07:54:54 PM
Noah732, do you have access to more of these studies on hand?
I don't have the time to look for them myself, but it seems like such an obvious study to be doing.
It would seem that the obvious question hasn't been studied very much.
And a comparison to those who haven't had GRS but want it would be a telling sort of thing.
I'm sorry, but I don't keep up on these kinds of studies to much, kinda out of my area, but it would seem that more in-depth ones should be done.
The suicide rates are a major concern for all trans people, regardless.
Something we can all agree on...
Ativan

What I would like to know is the why of each suicide. 

Is it gender related (i.e. suicide because the patient is unable to adapt to life as a different sex) or is it because of outside influence?  Job discrimination, rejection by friends and relatives, church teachings or other reasons are possible.  Not the trans person's gender but the way she is seen by the larger community. 

If suicide is due to the gender change then the standards of care need to be examined more closely.  If its due to external causes then some serious education of the general population is needed. 

Homophobes and transphobes would like the first to be true as it bolsters their wishes that we all go away.
  •  

Susan522

"If suicide is due to the gender change then the standards of care need to be examined more closely.  If its due to external causes then some serious education of the general population is needed. "

One might want to look into the Daniels/Penner tragedy as possibly a good case in point.  http://www.laweekly.com/2010-08-19/news/mike-penner-christine-daniels-a-tragic-love-story/
  •  

Jessica Merriman

In the story link provided I saw no mention of therapy either general or with a gender specialist. I would not question the SOCs, but informed consent. Everyone wants hormones, but many do not want to make sure they are in a good place mentally first.  :)
  •