Hey, Maleth. I am definitely counting myself as one of the guys who focuses on the positives, especially when I first get the product (even if I use it for a while before reviewing it, it seems). It seems like you are still searching for the one that completely satisfies you too, since you keep buying different ones. Is that fair to say?
I still have yet to find the one that I am comfortable wearing daily, except for the Mr. Limpy xs (non- STP). Weight is just too important to me. I have ordered a small Sailor with nipple and I am waiting for it to come in.
I have like a crap load of pink (egad) Mr. Limpys in my drawer (8-10 years ago it was hard to find the one manufactured by Fleshlight, so I bought a bunch of them - but in pink by mistake - and they have been sitting in my drawer)
About 3 months ago I ordered all of the STP tubing options from Tranzwear in order to try them all out (after putting them into the Limpys) to decide which was best. After practicing with just the tubing, I decided on the nipple, but I am too lazy to mess with trying to put it all together, so a couple of weeks ago I just one with the tubing already inserted. I am assuming it will be just another product that won't completely satisfy me (how sad is that assumption?), but they have been around forever and since they are cheap (relatively speaking), I figure I might as well give them a go in order to rule them out.
I have some hope for the Reel Magik STP IF it is at least 2-3oz lighter than their basic pack/prosthetic (which is 9.2 oz) and if the balls are indeed smaller (especially width of the balls), as they appear to be in the pictures. I wish they would post the specs of the STP, I don't know why they are waiting on that, and they won't tell me via email.
I won't buy though, until I hear many positive reviews. I still may not buy, however, as I doubt I will like the funnel option (based on my experience with the Go Girl). I still find the Stylishflesh Endy to be the best for peeing. I wish the spoon was thinner though, so it would fold more easily and button more easily.
I look forward to your comparison, you may want to post it into the sticky packer catalogue thread instead of this one, though. More people will come across it that way (over time), and your reviews are top of the line.