Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Trans Glamour Vs. Trans-Activism

Started by theadanielle, December 22, 2014, 09:20:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


PPatrice

Quote from: theadanielle on December 22, 2014, 09:20:54 PM
http://www.advocate.com/commentary/2014/12/22/op-ed-trans-glamour-versus-trans-activism
Right on.

Hhmmm....I read the linked essay/editorial, but I'm unclear as to what it means.  Can anyone  please explain? [I'm assuming the "right on" suggests that this article is quite the righteous editorial/essay?]
  •  

Lady_Oracle

yeah umm the comments in that article remind me of how much in fighting there is in our community, super sad... I have some strong opinions about that piece but its super late here and I need to go to sleep. I shall post at a later time.
  •  

theadanielle

I say "Right on" because this article crystallizes certain feelings I had in early transition.  Suddenly every other gay man I came out to began offering unsolicited  (and very patronising) makeup, clothing and hair advice and criticism as if I were their own personal Barbie doll. At the same time, there flowed into my inbox a constant stream of articles about Carmen Carrera and other TG supermodels.  No-one ever sent an article about Jenny Boylan or Diane Schroer.  I wondered: is it OK that all I want to be is an ordinary middle-aged woman on the subway who disappears (but gets to be a lady like she's always wanted to be)?  Or that I want to make my mark not by being glamorous but through my art?  I found this constant holding up of TG supermodels as examples both intimidating and discouraging.  Today I'm delighted with the way I look, but I'll never look like Carmen Carrera or Andreja Pejic.  Back then? In an already vulnerable time it just added to my insecurity.  Has anyone else experienced this?
  •  

suzifrommd

Problem is that there ISN'T much high profile global and national trans activism. We've done a dismal job of educating the public. Most people still think "trans" is just a special type of gay. I don't think we actually HAVE many activists who are worthy of a magazine cover. Unfortunately it IS the glamor girls like Janet Mock and Laverne Cox who are advancing our cause by humanizing us. Every one else? Not so much.
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

traci_k

Interesting article and suzi you make a good point. What are the rest of us doing. There really are some National Transactivists like Kate Bornstein. But many once they can, do go stealth. The gorgeous transwomen will tend to get the attention, just like gorgeous ciswomen. Just the facts of life. But all of us need to be involved, just like a little while back one of the girls here was publicizing a petition on We the People web site and we really didn't have a lot of other girls from here sign on. With Medicare and VA now covering SRS (even though you can't find too many doctors to accept assignment) 5 states now mandate that private health insurance cover SRS, what about the other 45 states, why aren't we involved in petitioning to get coverage for this life-saving procedure. I know that many of us can't come out yet but there are groups we can join like the HRC that is working for LGBT rights and doing public education. I know of a lawyer down in one of the Carolinas had her story in the newspaper. Another policewoman in I think Arizona had her story told in a magazine. We need to educate the public and legislators that just like with ciswomen, not everybody is drop dead gorgeous - there are regular transwomen who maybe have the broad shoulders, size thirteen feet, have years of the ravages of testosterone on their faces but are women none the less that were born with a birth defect.  Maybe we can't stand up every day to be counted, but we should when we can. Why can't people like Susan get recognition for the great work she has done in providing us a safe space where we can share? Janet Mock gets recognized for setting up the transgender suicide hotline, does anybody remember it getting publicized here? It did. It could be a life-saver.  And let's not forget the moderators here, who without pay help keep things running smooth. There is a lot getting done, these folks just don't get the recognition they deserve.

I know its hard when many of us still need to be in the closet due to oppression and rejection, but if each of us would make a squeak when we can, perhaps much more would get accomplished.

Hugs to All,
Traci Melissa Knight
  •  

Gothic Dandy

What counts as activism? I'm sensing a bitter "not activist enough" vibe from this article.
Just a little faerie punk floating through this strange world of humans.
  •  

Michelle-G

Quote from: suzifrommd on December 23, 2014, 07:16:03 AMUnfortunately it IS the glamor girls like Janet Mock and Laverne Cox who are advancing our cause by humanizing us. Every one else? Not so much.

I'd have to agree. The few people who are making a difference in trans activism can be counted on one hand. Most of those pretending to be activists merely add to the noise and instigate no change.

Quote from: Gothic Dandy Luca on December 23, 2014, 02:52:38 PM
What counts as activism? I'm sensing a bitter "not activist enough" vibe from this article.

Yup! My feelings exactly.
  •