Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

I seem stuck in the "male" role. What do I do?

Started by suzifrommd, April 22, 2015, 08:07:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

suzifrommd

Last weekend I went out on a second date for the first time in over a year. I'm thrilled that my one-and-done streak seems to be over, and I'd really like to see her again.  :eusa_dance:

I left a message for her asking her if she wanted to do something with me next week.

And then I realized. I've done the "asking" every time. I've fallen into a MALE ROLE. It just seems so natural to do it that way since that's the way I've always done it. And I don't know how it actually works when two experienced lesbians are dating. She, of course, has been lesbian all her life, so I'm sure she's a lot more familiar with the mechanics of lesbian dating.

The good news is that she knows I'm trans and is OK with it, so I didn't out myself, only revealed myself to be incapable of transcending my masculinity.

But I don't know any other way to do it.

How have others dealt with this particular twist in their transition road?
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

stephaniec

I never had that problem ,I didn't realize it when I was dating females , but I never took the lead and it caused a lot of problems on my part with females. This was my problem dating as male. One of my girls friends came out and told me I should of been a girl. Sorry I can't offer help because I was never psychologically male, so I really don't know how one would change other than thinking the opposite way.
  •  

Mermaid

Quote from: stephaniec on April 22, 2015, 08:21:42 PMI never took the lead and it caused a lot of problems on my part with females. This was my problem dating as male. One of my girls friends came out and told me I should of been a girl.

I'm sorry that you had to go through that, I went through similar experiences in high school. Noone should feel "forced" to "take the lead" just because their gender is male, it's really dehumanizing. There's no shame in being shy or introverted... it's really cruel to force people into gender roles and not accept them as they are. Sometimes it really feels like the majority of straight women out there aren't really attracted to men for who they are as people, but rather to their ideal of what those men should be.

I think if I wasn't attracted to men, I'd actually force myself to like men; I've had so many putrid experiences when interacting with women as a male, that I've developed some sort of aversion to certain aspects of "femininity"... which isn't really femininity as much as it is self-entitlement, lack of compassion and narcissism. When I hear women say they like "being catered to" openly, I wonder if they even realize that feeling cared for and special is a human need, not a "female" need. It'd be nice to see more reciprocity in dates between heterosexual people, but sadly their exchanges seem to work with different currencies for each gender... Don't want to get too specific, but "access to your sex" isn't a way to give anything back, it can't be treated as a mere commodity (unless someone wants to be treated like one, then whine about how they can't find a guy to settle down with and call them all pigs), it should be a mutual consensual activity that's meaningful for both parties, not a reward.

I strive to be the opposite of that, I find gender roles to be abhorrent and fuel for gender dysphoria in transfolk. Society refuses to see people as people, it always sees in black and white, fitting them into "man" and "woman" boxes. It's biased and just promotes inequality. I outright refuse letting anyone pay for me on dates... with my boyfriend I occasionally let him if he insists, but it's more tied into the fact that I'm younger and don't have a job, whereas he does and understands my financial limitations, so offers to help; has nothing to do with gender.

Prior to him, when I started going on dates with guys, it was astonishing how all of them offered and insisted to pay for me... whereas in high school, women never extended the same courtesy (and they were still the ones inviting me, so there wasn't really a "whoever invites should have the initiative to pay" excuse in these scenarios). It's just unfair societal pressures on men, which sadly noone has time to talk about or acknowledge because everyone's too busy listening to whiney people, infected by the feminism virus, talk about how unfair it is that they have to shave their armpits... :-\

OP: I think that if the role you're playing while interacting with that person makes you uncomfortable/dysphoric, then you shouldn't play it... No person in the world is worth going against our desires and beliefs for, much less made to feel like they're compromising their identity. If you need to feel like you play the more "feminine" part in a relationship, then you shouldn't settle for less... at least I wouldn't. I believe transpeople are way more analytical about this sort of thing, maybe the person you're with doesn't even see behaviours and categorize them as masculine or feminine, but I think transsexuals have a hard time distancing themselves from that kind of critical thought, and are more likely to have special needs when it comes to feeling "feminine" or "masculine"... and geez, they deserve to; after all, transpeople are mostly the ones who had to walk along a harsh road to conquer the right to be themselves, didn't just have their identity self-attributed like other folk... so it's only fair to be a bit more needy! =)
  •  

Jayne

Hi Suzi

Surely it's not about gender roles but about someone in the relationship taking the lead? I've not known many lesbians to get to know the roles but surely one person needs to ask "can I see you again?" otherwise a relationship would be doomed to fail.
I can't think of any couple i've ever known where one of them didn't take charge to a certain extent & it's often the women who truly take charge of a hetero relationship so is there really a case for saying that whoever takes the lead is taking the male role?
I see courtship as a back & forward dance at some point each of the couple take a dominant role until they both find a comfortable middle ground.
  •  

greezypizza

I'd say don't worry about it. When I told everyone that I was mtf they were like omggggg you are gonna be a whole another person blah blah blah. I told them no, I'm going to be completely the same, but just step into more comfortable shoes, maybe dress a little more differently. Just be whats most natural to you. I on the other hand, seem the be shifting into the female role. Not really my choice since I'm 5'5. People are just treating me like a girl more. Theres this bi girl were I work, and the more I become feminine, the more she seems to hit on me, ask me to places. She never treated me like this before. Thing is shes slightly taller than me, but I am much much smaller. So I have a feeling it has something largely to do with physical appearance, if your wondering.
  •  

Dread_Faery

Asking someone on a date is not taking the male role, it's asking someone on a date.
  •  

Miharu Barbie

Hi Suzi,

If I were in your shoes, I would simply not over think it.  Be yourself above all else and do what comes naturally.  If you think too deeply about this and work too hard to squeeze your every move into what you believe to be the "right way" of being a woman, you run the risk coming across as "fake".  If you can relax and just do what comes naturally, you're more likely to come across as a woman trying to find her way in this crazy world (i.e., human.)

Be yourself, flaws and all, and in time you will find "the one" who's how-the-heck-do-you-do-this "fits" perfectly with your how-the-heck-do-you-do-this.  And that is where the magic happens.
FEAR IS NOT THE BOSS OF ME!!!


HRT:                         June 1998
Full Time For Good:     November 1998
Never Looking Back:  Now!
  •  

JLT1

Hey, 

Just be yourself.   You determine the rules.   If you like her then you did well.

Did she say yes?

Jen
To move forward is to leave behind that which has become dear. It is a call into the wild, into becoming someone currently unknown to us. For most, it is a call too frightening and too challenging to heed. For some, it is a call to be more than we were capable of being, both now and in the future.
  •  

Emily E

Don't worry about it... in every relationship someone is in the dominate role and someone is in the submissive role (the asker and the askee) and contrary to popular belief the male role isn't always the dominate role (women let the men think they are making the decisions) I'm sure everyone here including you can think of at least one relationship where a woman/wife/sister/coworker is in a dominate role over a man.  It's all based on personalities... with some women you will be dominate and with some you will be submissive and with some you will change between the two roles so what kind of long term relationship you end up in is sort of up to you but don't stop asking for a date if you like them or you may just end up alone when you should be with them
I'll struggle hard today to live the life I want tomorrow !

Step One - Lose the weight!



  •  

JoanneB

The way I see it, You can either play games of sit back and hope, or take action. So you are not a "game player". You just let her know you'll like to her again
.          (Pile Driver)  
                    |
                    |
                    ^
(ROCK) ---> ME <--- (HARD PLACE)
  •  

Hikari

Generally speaking, acting coy and vulnerable have always been my normal way of interacting with someone I like, letting her take the lead. This means there are lots of times I am practically inventing reasons to talk to or see someone I like, because I want her to take the lead but I have my own thoughts and desires about hoe things need to go.

Occasionally I will need to actually be straightforward and take the lead because the people I am Into aren't always very assertive either and ultimately someone needs to drive things forward, I would rather it not be me, but occasionally it simply has to be me.

I am not sure how typical my expierenced are in this area, but it seems that the leadership role being a bit dynamic works out okay for me, but I certainly wouldn't frame it as the "male" role.
私は女の子 です!My Blog - Hikari's Transition Log http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/board,377.0.html
  •  

CrysC

remember that type A or type B has nothing to do with gender.   
Don't think of the confidence to ask a girl out as a male thing.  It just means you are interested and have enough confidence to ask her. 
it's a good thing.   :D
  •  

Evelyn K

I think between two equals if one is finding they're always taking the initiative then that should tell you enough to gauge their romantic interest level in you.

Pull back and don't be so available. It will look desperate. It's a mating dance after-all.
  •  

Zoetrope

Yup, gender and relationship roles don't necessarily line up.

There are plenty of sumbissive men out there, who are certainly male-gendered, they just don't ''wear the pants''.

So to speak.

That was my old life. I was a sumbissive guy, and dated dominant girls.

Now I'm still submissive, but I am into (being pursued by) dominant men.

:~D

  •  

katrinaw

Hi Suzi, someone has to take the lead... Not a sign of Masculinity or Femininity, I have known many CIS women who are not afraid to be forward... and they are not always the boardroom exec's  :laugh:

L Katy  :-*
Long term MTF in transition... HRT since ~ 2003...
Journey recommenced Sept 2015  :eusa_clap:... planning FT 2016  :eusa_pray:

Randomly changing 'Katy PIC's'

Live life, embrace life and love life xxx
  •  

femmebutt

*Edit: everyone above beat me to the point:  Directness should not be considered a "male" trait. Plenty of people of any gender will appreciate such an approach. Even us non binary trans women.

So what are you doing this weekend?  Let's punch our healthy eating habits in the face by sharing a bottle of wine and see what trouble we can make...

Seriously we need a suzifrommd dating manual with an extra section for the chronically shy and socially awkward.  I mean, this is just dangerous.  I'm looking at another weekend, freshly singled,, no-one to lose and nothing to do (other way around, more like!)  Help. Helllllllp
hybrid
  •  

femmebutt

hybrid
  •  

suzifrommd

Quote from: Mermaid on April 22, 2015, 09:59:31 PM
OP: I think that if the role you're playing while interacting with that person makes you uncomfortable/dysphoric, then you shouldn't play it.

It doesn't make me dysphoric. It feels kind of comfortable, since it's what I've done all my life, even though I prefer it the other way round. I don't know how things work when two women date. She's hinted that she's attracted to femininity, so don't know if she's uncomfortable with my seizing the male role.

Quote from: greezypizza on April 23, 2015, 10:25:47 AM
Just be whats most natural to you.
Quote from: Miharu Barbie on April 23, 2015, 02:41:19 PMBe yourself above all else and do what comes naturally.
Quote from: JLT1 on April 23, 2015, 04:12:58 PMJust be yourself.

Thing is, this *isn't* what comes naturally. I'm far more comfortable letting other people take the lead. But I learned quickly that dating as a straight guy, you need to take the lead or you spend a lot of time alone. I internalized this and now I'm not sure how to do it any other way.

Quote from: Jayne on April 22, 2015, 10:26:00 PM
Surely it's not about gender roles but about someone in the relationship taking the lead?
Quote from: Dread_Faery on April 23, 2015, 02:03:49 PMAsking someone on a date is not taking the male role, it's asking someone on a date.
Quote from: Emily E on April 23, 2015, 05:41:01 PM
I'm sure everyone here including you can think of at least one relationship where a woman/wife/sister/coworker is in a dominate role over a man.
Quote from: Hikari on April 23, 2015, 10:23:28 PMI am not sure how typical my expierenced are in this area, but it seems that the leadership role being a bit dynamic works out okay for me, but I certainly wouldn't frame it as the "male" role.
Quote from: CrysC on April 23, 2015, 10:41:57 PMremember that type A or type B has nothing to do with gender.
Quote from: katrinaw on April 24, 2015, 02:03:54 AMHi Suzi, someone has to take the lead... Not a sign of Masculinity or Femininity, I have known many CIS women who are not afraid to be forward.
Quote from: femmebutt on April 24, 2015, 02:17:38 AMDirectness should not be considered a "male" trait.

I totally get how some women take the lead, and there is nothing inherently male about it.

But it IS a role that males play in traditional dating. Nearly all the women I dated expected it, even if they didn't believe in traditional gender roles. I can count on the fingers of no hands the number of times I was asked out by a woman, vs. the dozens of times they seemed happy to be asked out by me.

But I'm sure that doesn't apply to lesbian dating. I'm a "when in Rome" type person, and now I don't know how to take any other role.

Interestingly, when I've been with dominant men, it feels a whole lot more comfortable, but I can't wave a wand and make the women I date dominant.

Quote from: Evelyn K on April 24, 2015, 12:23:58 AM
Pull back and don't be so available. It will look desperate. It's a mating dance after-all.

I envy you, Evelyn. I do not have the social savvy to pull this off. I'm a terrible dancer, both literally and figuratively. I'm pretty tone-deaf to the nuances of attraction and come-ons vs. put-offs. I'm far more comfortable letting someone know how I feel and letting them decide whether I'm right for them too.

Maybe this is why I've never been able to keep it going with anyone. I'm dooming myself to being alone.

:icon_sadblinky:

Quote from: femmebutt on April 24, 2015, 02:17:38 AM
Seriously we need a suzifrommd dating manual with an extra section for the chronically shy and socially awkward.  I mean, this is just dangerous.  I'm looking at another weekend, freshly singled,, no-one to lose and nothing to do (other way around, more like!)  Help. Helllllllp
Quote from: CrysC on April 23, 2015, 10:41:57 PM
Don't think of the confidence to ask a girl out as a male thing.  It just means you are interested and have enough confidence to ask her. 
it's a good thing.   :D

Thank you. This does sort of make me feel better.

Quote from: JLT1 on April 23, 2015, 04:12:58 PM
Did she say yes?

She sent email this morning saying she was interested and she'd call me this weekend.  :icon_biggrin:
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

Jayne

If she's calling this weekend then you're definately doing something right.

My ex grew up with 3 brothers & definately took the "male" role, I made the move to start chatting to her but from then on she took the lead. I don't know how typical this is having only dated two women in my whole life but she was certainly more masculine than me.
Maybe the situation you're in is similar to how mine was, maybe now that you've shown your interest you'll be able to take a more passive role in the courtship dance & let her take the lead.
If a relationship is healthy then I believe early on both people will sit down & discuss what they want/expect from a relationship, when you sit down for that chat you could possibly tell her that you don't feel comfortable taking the percieved "male" role, who knows she may not even think that you showing interest in her is playing a male role.

I wish you all the luck in the world for this weekend

p.s. I can't believe I keep using the word "courtship" it makes me sound sooo old fashioned
  •  

stephaniec

well, good luck , maybe once you have a few dates behind you can navigate the waters better. There are female navigators aren't there?
  •