Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

My recent bereavement and how it affects my transition (CN: Family member death)

Started by Willowicious, August 16, 2015, 08:41:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Willowicious

My father died whilst he, my mother and I were on holiday abroad a couple of weeks ago, and without trying to sound cold/ selfish, I feel his passing has affected my transition a great deal. In a way, he was my greatest obstacle to becoming my true self, as I feel he was sexist and kinda' homophobic (on said vacation he made at least 3 'gay' remarks a day criticizing me for things like my hair, the fact I came home from uni with painted nails, my fashion sense, movement (I'm practicing my 'girl walk' love of Disney, and the fact that my close friends are female but I have not pursued them romantically or sexually). As a result of this I feel that he probably wouldn't have accepted my trans status. As such, I feel his passing has taken away the burden of not being accepted by my most-likely main-opposing family member, and as such, I have a clearer and less fraught path for my transition. However, I feel awful for the fact that I would benefit from his death in such a way, and that I'd be becoming a person he would not have approved of.

I also feel guilty about causing my mother pain. I lost my grandmother/ her mother last October, and seeing as two of her closest family members died within a year of each other, I feel that if I revealed my trans status and transitioned to female, she would feel like her son had died as well, and it could ruin her completely, and I wouldn't want to be so selfish about myself to do that to her. (I came out to her and my sister as gay (a term I regret using as it implies I'm male) and they were okay with it, but my mother said that she didn't want me to become a really feminine gay guy. Plus, when I was experimenting with preferred names and accidentally addressed my Boots membership card to 'Sadie', she saw this and said "You've already told me one thing, but that's something else", and I managed to blag it off. Furthermore, whenever my father made mocking remarks about me wearing womens clothes, my mother would say something along the lines of 'He wouldn't do that').

As a result of this I'm really unsure of whether I should transition at all, as I wouldn't want to afflict my mother like that after everything she's been through as a result of my own personal gain. Does anybody have any advice on the matter? [P.S. Sorry if this post seemed attention/ pity-seeking]



  •  

stephaniec

  •  

suzifrommd

Quote from: Grell4SpiritAnimal on August 16, 2015, 08:41:13 PM
As a result of this I'm really unsure of whether I should transition at all, as I wouldn't want to afflict my mother like that after everything she's been through as a result of my own personal gain. Does anybody have any advice on the matter?

Yes. My advice is be yourself. Nobody, nobody has the right to ask someone else to live a lie. It destroys the soul. Anyone who loves you would never want you to pretend to be someone else for their sake.
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

Pony

Quote from: Grell4SpiritAnimal on August 16, 2015, 08:41:13 PM
As a result of this I'm really unsure of whether I should transition at all, as I wouldn't want to afflict my mother like that after everything she's been through as a result of my own personal gain. Does anybody have any advice on the matter? [P.S. Sorry if this post seemed attention/ pity-seeking]

This sounds like a terrific opportunity to really get to know your mother and be there for her. This is important because of the advice I recently gave to someone about coming out to their parents and how to do it to ensure a high degree of success, as seen here: https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,193743.msg1730305.html#msg1730305

So yeah, the way I see it, you have this great opportunity for yourself and for her. It could lead to some serious bonding between you and getting to know each other like never before. Which as it turns out, will help with you coming out to her later, but building that foundation now... priceless.

You'd effectively be there for her time of need. When you need her to be there for yours, she'd probably remember what you did for her. Be her rock and ear.  :)
It's just a harmless nickname. Relax.
  •  

Sharon Anne McC

*

You are caring more for your mother and family than you are caring for your self - that is how I read your post.  I do not see anything in your post as being selfish to the harm of your mother.  In some ways, you are commendable to be so loyal to her yet in other ways so detrimental to your own well-being as you decide how to move your life forward.  When you address your own health needs, that does not follow that there is some kind of balance sheet that you are abandoning your family's needs; you can manage your own needs while they manage theirs.

Perhaps your father held to his father-son issue - he always would have seen you as his son no matter had you transitioned to female.

I have read so many others - here and elsewhere - describe the absence of the 'before' person as a 'death'.  That occurred within my family.  My father characterised my male predecessor's absence as a 'death' - not to me, but to his neighbours.  When I went to manage my dad's home and estate after he died (1989), I learned that he told his neighbours that my male predecessor died.  Apparently the way he knew them, my dad decided it was better to explain my male predecessor's absence to his neighbours as my male predecessor being dead than telling them I am changed.  I played along with his neighbours and became the grieving daughter / sister and they acted none the wiser.

If your mom now alone is one who can support you and your transition, then your decision is easy - your transition will not negatively affect her.  Please accept my comment in good effort and I apologise if this resonates harshly.  If your mom can't accept you as you - can't accept your transition - then there is little point delaying yourself for someone who can't reciprocate.

Despite my life-time of feminine protesting beginning in childhood at age three, my father did not accept me post-transition.  Meanwhile, I accepted my father's position; he was the one who perceived me as his son, not I, and he would have that difficulty changing his perception of me as his daughter.  He refused to talk details with me; he had no idea I went all the way.  On the other hand, I had a real suspicion that he would have literally died of a broken heart if I did tell him all my details, so it made no point telling him about this process that he would not understand.  Our unspoken truce was that he begrudgingly acknowledged my presence as female - though he held fast to his belief that it was still merely a passing fad till the day he died; the Will he made just days before his death identified me as my male predecessor, not Sharon, though he knew that my legal identification is Sharon and female.

I attended a few group counselling sessions for people who recently lost a family member within the prior year.  Some of that seemed irrelevant.  Yes, I was grieving hard at the permanent absence of my father; I regret not spending more time with him, but realised that he was the one who placed that barrier between us.  I so cherish that I devoted nearly every hour of his final three weeks with him when he returned from the hospital and into home hospice care upon his terminal diagnosis.  Still, my father died holding little concern for me.

I came to my conclusion at my 1983 post-op recovery.  My emotions were busy.  I had a transitory thought of suicide - I'll teach a lesson to my family when they collect my corpse to find it female, not male.  As I worked through these thoughts, I realised that my family would not care one wit and it was up to me to live my life as best and responsibly as I knew.  My living well is its own reward.

About family.  I sure hope yours is much better than mine was.  My immediate family rejected me; only my sister and I survive and the last time she wrote to me (September 2014) was in an e-mail telling me that she wants nothing more to do with me.  Nearly all extended family reject me.  The few who apparently claimed they did not reject me merely cut off all contact between us.

One 'out' homosexual uncle who once lived in our home as I was growing up also rejected me. Am I so bad that he excludes my 'T' from the 'LGBT' construct?  I seriously suspect that both my parents could not comprehend the differences of 'L', 'G', 'B', and 'T' during their time.  Perhaps they were confused that I was a male homosexual.  After all, there was a time during the 1950s and 1960s when the medical community perspective was that M-F transsexuals were male homosexuals who wanted the operation to appear as socially acceptable, 'normal' female heterosexuals to their male homosexual partner. That was a failed concept considering that no male homosexual wants his anatomy re-assigned; a M-F true transsexual requires her anatomy to be re-assigned.

I lost most all my friends when I told them of my change.  Likewise as with family, those who did not otherwise express rejection merely disconnected communication between us.  Apparently, none were 'friends' by any valid definition.

Pony wrote volumes of good perception here and at her link.  I offer my best wishes to you, and your mother, and the remainder of all your family and friends.

*
*

1956:  Birth (AMAB)
1974-1985:  Transition (core transition:  1977-1985)
1977:  Enrolled in Stanford University Medical Center's 'Gender Dysphoria Program'
1978:  First transition medical appointment
1978:  Corresponded with Janus Information Facility (Galveston)
1978:  Changed my SSA file to Sharon / female
1979:  First psychological evaluation - passed
1979:  Began ERT (Norinyl, DES, Premarin, estradiol, progesterone)
1980:  Arizona affirmed me legally as Sharon / female
1980:  MVD changed my licence to Sharon / female
1980:  First bank account as Sharon / female
1982:  Inter-sex exploratory:  diagnosed Inter-sex (genetically female)
1983:  Inter-sex corrective surgery
1984:  Full-blown 'male fail' phase
1985:  Transition complete to female full-time forever
2015:  Awakening from self-imposed deep stealth and isolation
2015 - 2016:  Chettawut Clinic - patient companion and revision
Today:  Happy!
Future:  I wanna return to Bangkok with other Thai experience friends

*
  •  

Qrachel

Hi -

The comments above mostly ring true for me too. 

The idea of a 'death' occurring when a family member transitions is not uncommon.  However, that kind of internalization is not about you but about the person who cannot see love and grace awaiting them in huge proportions if they will only embrace the beautiful gift before them.

I relate to your concerns, BTDT in spades!  It didn't help anyone and I suffered a great deal unnecessarily.  It's OK to experience those feelings for a while, but making them manifest in your life for long is harmful to you and many around you, as they have to deal with your guilt however you express it - and you will express it.

This gender-bent life is many things and one of them is it's journey day-by-day. The key is to keep moving along the path and not letting any of the existential guilt or morose stuff stick for very long.  Truly, you are beautiful and deserve a full and wonderful life.  Consider not making it more difficult by being a noble (?) person and carry all their . . . , ahhh, S___ . . . oh, I mean stuff too!

Take good care my dear,

Rachel
Rachel

"Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the little voice at the end of the day that says I'll try again tomorrow."
  •  

Rejennyrated

Firstly I'm sorry for your loss, and your reaction is both normal and does you credit.

Secondly, to put it slightly crudely - ->-bleeped-<- happens in life, and we have to learn to hold to our true course otherwise we end up as one of the many resentful and depressed old people that I see as a medic, who all hate the fact they never took their chances in life.

A vital part of growing up is the separation process from ones parents. The realisation that they gave us the gift of life, and nurture, but that does not mean they own us. We have to be ourselves. We can still honour their values - but we must not be slaves to them.

I started to express my gender at the age of around 4 and at 5 and a half my father died. I've often wondered what effect that had on my transition and whether he might have put his foot down if he had been there. Perhaps my mother would also have been less accomodating. Who knows... but I believe things happen for a reason in life. Sometimes they present us with additional challenges to overcome, other times we benefit and gain advantage, but it is a false belief that tells you that you must not take the advantages. Do what you have to do, because otherwise you will almost certainly end up with regret.
  •  

Joelene9

Willowicious,

  My mother's death is an opposite from what your father's was. She may have died from the guilt she may have from possibly taking DES while pregnant with me and she did not tell us of the daughter she had given up for adoption. She died of cervical cancer that relapsed after 4 years of remission. She failed to get her annual examinations for that. I had the guilt also of not being a full son to her as I came out to her in 1977. That guilt disappeared over time as the information about my mother's life I didn't know started to come in.
  My father did not know about my condition as he was not around. We had him for his last 18 months as he died from Alzheimer's. I didn't get anything from him.
  Be strong!

Joelene
  •  

brianna1016

Quote from: Willowicious on August 16, 2015, 08:41:13 PM
However, I feel awful for the fact that I would benefit from his death in such a way, and that I'd be becoming a person he would not have approved of.
Don't feel bad, many people benefit in some way from the passing of a family member. It's not like you wanted him to go! Silver lining?
Quote from: Willowicious on August 16, 2015, 08:41:13 PM
I also feel guilty about causing my mother pain. I lost my grandmother/ her mother last October, and seeing as two of her closest family members died within a year of each other, I feel that if I revealed my trans status and transitioned to female, she would feel like her son had died as well, and it could ruin her completely, and I wouldn't want to be so selfish about myself to do that to her.
It's actually more selfish to continue lying to her. You're preventing her from seeing the real you. And I'm assuming you're much more happy as a woman, right? Wouldn't you want her to know the happy version of you? Parents take the longest to accept us, but when / if they do it is sooo nice! I hope you do what is in your heart. You have to take care of yourself, and that means following your dreams.  :)
  •