Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Transexual support group discussion

Started by KarlMars, April 05, 2016, 02:15:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Do you go to a support group for trans people?

Yes
3 (33.3%)
No
4 (44.4%)
I would if I had one where I live
2 (22.2%)
I used to, but now I'm done transition
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 9

KarlMars

If there's any other reason you went to one but don't any longer please state it.

This evening will be my first time going to a trans support group. My Unitarian minister invited me. I'm somewhat excited and hope it isn't too boring. I've been in many mental health groups before, but never one for transgender.

Elis

I've been to a few but I'm too socially anxious to keep going. I get too nervous to actually talk to anyone; although I found the group helpful and made me feel a lot better about myself. It seems that people that go are very binary and already have a friends group in their own lives; so I feel left out. Good for you going thougg; let us know how it goes :)
They/them pronouns preferred.



  •  

KarlMars

Quote from: Elis on April 05, 2016, 02:36:50 PM
I've been to a few but I'm too socially anxious to keep going. I get too nervous to actually talk to anyone; although I found the group helpful and made me feel a lot better about myself. It seems that people that go are very binary and already have a friends group in their own lives; so I feel left out. Good for you going thougg; let us know how it goes :)

Are you uncomfortable making friends with binary people? I consider myself binary, but I may not look binary enough yet.

Elis

Quote from: alienbodybuilder on April 05, 2016, 02:49:06 PM
Are you uncomfortable making friends with binary people? I consider myself binary, but I may not look binary enough yet.

I'm slightly uncomfortable they look and act more masculine than I do. Maybe when I've been on T for longer I'd give trans groups another go. Just wish there were groups specifically for nbs
They/them pronouns preferred.



  •  

FTMax

I've been to one, and didn't go back for a few reasons. The group as a whole was more MTF than FTM, and I didn't feel like I had a lot to talk about. It was also really depressing for me, as it seemed like everyone there was hitting roadblocks related to transitioning at some point or other, and I haven't really hit any.

I guess to be honest I really didn't need support, and there weren't enough social reasons for me to go back. I'm a part of some virtual support groups for guys getting bottom surgery, and that works well enough for me. There are a few guys from those that are local to my area, so in addition to getting surgical support from the group, I can be social with those guys if I'm so inclined.
T: 12/5/2014 | Top: 4/21/2015 | Hysto: 2/6/2016 | Meta: 3/21/2017

I don't come here anymore, so if you need to get in touch send an email: maxdoeswork AT protonmail.com
  •  

KarlMars

Quote from: Elis on April 05, 2016, 02:58:35 PM
I'm slightly uncomfortable they look and act more masculine than I do. Maybe when I've been on T for longer I'd give trans groups another go. Just wish there were groups specifically for nbs

I think my personality is more masculine than many cis men that I have come across. I am very brash and bold verbally, and it has been hard for me to make friends because of accidentally offending people.

KarlMars

Quote from: FTMax on April 05, 2016, 03:04:20 PM
I've been to one, and didn't go back for a few reasons. The group as a whole was more MTF than FTM, and I didn't feel like I had a lot to talk about. It was also really depressing for me, as it seemed like everyone there was hitting roadblocks related to transitioning at some point or other, and I haven't really hit any.

I guess to be honest I really didn't need support, and there weren't enough social reasons for me to go back. I'm a part of some virtual support groups for guys getting bottom surgery, and that works well enough for me. There are a few guys from those that are local to my area, so in addition to getting surgical support from the group, I can be social with those guys if I'm so inclined.

Yes I read that there are more M2F than F2M. I think a quarter of transexuals are transmen.

Tessa James

I have been fortunate to be able to participate in local small town groups and big city transgender groups too.  BTW I have not seen them called transexual but rather transgender support groups.  For some people the terms have important distinctions.

I really appreciate our local group as it features everyone together.  We share support with all genders, youths, allies and significant others.  Hearing from a trans man's perspective or an SOs view point is helpful for me to understanding a wider perspective.  Our local group will sometimes split up if there are enough SOs that want to share.  When I go to Portland the groups are separated into women and men and the size of the groups may make that more needed.  I have been to  groups where a couple of people were "observers".  I am Ok with nurses and other professionals but very uncomfortable with cisgender straight missionary types attending for what I believed were spurious reasons like evangelical recruitment.

The groups I know of are all "peer support" groups in that none of us claim to be facilitating as a professional therapist but as someone like yourself.  We have had family members often come along in support and gain a better understanding of the range we might represent.  We start with a preamble that assures we are pledged to confidentiality and some people use only a first name.  A facilitator is trained and vetted but we are human.  I remind attendees that we allow those with "burning issues" to start but we go around the room so all have a chance to share or not.

There is often a very nice mix of new comers and old hands, minority people and diverse folks of all kinds.  We often go out for drinks or fun after group.  Groups can lend a sense of community and caring to people in need.  Some people come just once and thats it.  Others may need a lifetime of support?  I wish there had been something like this around 20 or more years ago!  And then, there is no better time than now ;D

Join in, it is what we make it!
Open, out and evolving queer trans person forever with HRT support since March 13, 2013
  •  

Kylo

I think forums suffice just fine to get the information I need without the awkwardness of a group situation. I'm not shy, I'm just... well, I don't see that I need to see other trans people in the flesh to appreciate our issues. In the same way I don't feel like there'd be much difference conversing with my therapist on Skype and conversing in a room.

It's fortunate because there are no such support groups where I am.
"If the freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter."
  •  

KarlMars

Quote from: T.K.G.W. on April 05, 2016, 03:28:03 PM
I think forums suffice just fine to get the information I need without the awkwardness of a group situation. I'm not shy, I'm just... well, I don't see that I need to see other trans people in the flesh to appreciate our issues. In the same way I don't feel like there'd be much difference conversing with my therapist on Skype and conversing in a room.

It's fortunate because there are no such support groups where I am.

I'd like to meet some friends thought too. You never know what good friends you could be missing out on. I take it you're a hermit?

Kylo

Not really, I live with someone.

But on the whole, yeah, I'm not bothered about socializing much anymore. It's because what friends I have or have had before tend to drop off and fade away if you're not in their immediate vicinity and seeing them frequently. If I had the time to dedicate to that or if I needed to get along with work colleagues I might, but I don't anymore.
"If the freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter."
  •  

KarlMars

Quote from: T.K.G.W. on April 05, 2016, 04:12:45 PM
Not really, I live with someone.

But on the whole, yeah, I'm not bothered about socializing much anymore. It's because what friends I have or have had before tend to drop off and fade away if you're not in their immediate vicinity and seeing them frequently. If I had the time to dedicate to that or if I needed to get along with work colleagues I might, but I don't anymore.

My favorite way to keep track of friends long distance or local is on facebook. When I get more time to myself I might  go out with a friend once in awhile.

Kylo

I have lots of acquaintances on there but I wouldn't call someone a friend that I wouldn't feel comfortable just messaging randomly to talk and many of them I don't feel comfortable just talking to. I would feel like I was inconveniencing them because after all they probably only have time for the people in their lives that they actually see. In some ways this modern tech has made it harder to talk to people and people are lazier about keeping in touch, even with the tech.

I've got and had friends all over the planet with this tech, but that doesn't stop them from just fading away once they get their own families and have their own kids. Even my own family has done the same thing and grown distant because I am 300 miles away. As a result, I realize it's a waste of time me making the level of friendship I'd like unless you're going to see them or keep up with them regularly, because they'll just drop off the radar again.

Maybe I'm just that way - there needs to be a level of trust for me to call someone a friend, and for that you kind of need to be in each others' lives a certain amount.

It's not surprising not wanting to see people very much the last few yrs has coincided with wanting to experience transition to some extent first.


"If the freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter."
  •  

KarlMars

Quote from: T.K.G.W. on April 05, 2016, 04:39:24 PM
I have lots of acquaintances on there but I wouldn't call someone a friend that I wouldn't feel comfortable just messaging randomly to talk and many of them I don't feel comfortable just talking to. I would feel like I was inconveniencing them because after all they probably only have time for the people in their lives that they actually see. In some ways this modern tech has made it harder to talk to people and people are lazier about keeping in touch, even with the tech.

I've got and had friends all over the planet with this tech, but that doesn't stop them from just fading away once they get their own families and have their own kids. Even my own family has done the same thing and grown distant because I am 300 miles away. As a result, I realize it's a waste of time me making the level of friendship I'd like unless you're going to see them or keep up with them regularly, because they'll just drop off the radar again.

Maybe I'm just that way - there needs to be a level of trust for me to call someone a friend, and for that you kind of need to be in each others' lives a certain amount.

It's not surprising not wanting to see people very much the last few yrs has coincided with wanting to experience transition to some extent first.

You're a complicated man, and I mean that as a compliment. I make friends easily and don't trust anyone at all!