Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Identity issues...

Started by EmilyJorgensen, July 01, 2016, 11:57:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

EmilyJorgensen

My feelings differ greatly about what my gender identity is/ will end up being...
I have put together a list of reasons I feel as if I am MtF transgender, reasons I feel I may bot be transgender, and reasons I feel I may be non-binary in some way. I am wondering if anyone can relate here...
If this is an inappropriate place to post this, I apologise, and please move this thread to it's appropriate location.

Reasons I feel I am MtF:
1. When cis girls/ women talk about their puberty and development during adolescence, I find that I wish that were my experience, too, that I would have developed as a female.
2. I am self conscious about my deep voice at times.
3. When dressing in female clothing, doing my hair, and applying makeup, I love when I get to the point where I actually look like a female. It brings me joy. Likewise, I get very uncomfortable if I end up looking like a man in drag.
4. When I'm around m sister and female cousin, who are much shorter than me (5-8 inches shorter) I feel slightly uncomfortable for being so masculine in stature. Tying in to the first reason, I wish that I could've developed as a female.
5. I hate the fact that I have such high levels of testosterone in my body, causing body odour, body hair growth, muscle growth, and skeletal masculinisation. I wish that it were oestrogen.
6. I feel uncomfortable regarding my sex organs and when I get aroused. It's something of a chore to me.
7. In *ahem* the bedroom, I feel very uncomfortable with my body, and my male body is gross, even slightly nauseating to me, but the other male I am in bed with, I am not repulsed by him or his body, only my own.
8. I have had some discomfort, although, not very strong, regarding male pronouns being used with me.
9. I hate my legal name, and I wish it were something at least gender neutral, but of course, my parents had to name me something biblical :P
10. I dream of one day being able to openly shop in the women's section of a department store, pick out a dress I like, and wear it... Generally, to present as female.
11. In these thoughts and dreams of being a woman, the realisation that I am physically a male makes me feel uncomfortable, and I envision male- bodied, non-transitioned me in a dress, and it's not a pleasant thought.
12. I didn't feel comfortable around other boys in primary school, and I found that the girls were a better fit for me to hang out with and talk to/ play with. I would play with the girls more often during recess. Boys were too aggressive and rambunctious and I had no interest with associating with them. In the 5th grade when the boys were forced to sit separately from the girls at lunch due to the boys' behaviour, I could no longer sit with the girls and it was very upsetting to me.
13. In my childhood, something didn't feel... right... But I cannot confirm what that something was.
14. I really can't say I have ever felt like 'one of the guys' in any social respect. I mean, I could associate with them and have fun doing so, but myself as one is another story.
15. I look up to/ strive to be like my older sister as opposed to my father.
16. I worry constantly about being accepted by cis women as a woman.
17. I have been wanting to transition for months.

Reasons I may not be trans:
1. These feelings subside for as much as a week at a time
2. I have the thought that "It couldn't happen to me, being trans"
3. These feelings of wanting to be female arose at the age of 19, or at least, I had realised them then
4. I still enjoy dressing up in fancy male clothes.
5. I'd one day like to know what it's like to have a beard, although this thought is not a strong one, and grows weaker as time goes on.
6. I wanted to rush my male puberty when I was 14-16 since I was a very late bloomer and I was tired of being treated and seen as a young child, being given the kid's menu at restaurants, etc...
7. I wasn't a hyper feminine kid like so many trans girls were, and I enjoyed airsoft and BB guns as an adolescent.
8. I constantly doubt myself.
9. When I call myself a trans woman or a woman in any respect, at times, I'll look at my body and think "you? A woman? pppffft!"
10. I feel uncomfortable or even ashamed calling myself transgender.
11. There are less than 1% of the population who are transgender, how likely is it that I am one of them?

Reasons I may be non binary:
1. My feelings fluctuate.. Some days, more masculine or even male than others.
2. My discomfort fluctuates, some says, not as strong as others.
3. I can enjoy both 'male', 'female', and androgynous clothing
  •  

Asche

Quote from: EmilyJorgensen on July 01, 2016, 11:57:20 PM
My feelings differ greatly about what my gender identity is/ will end up being...
I have put together a list of reasons I feel as if I am MtF transgender, reasons I feel I may bot be transgender, and reasons I feel I may be non-binary in some way. I am wondering if anyone can relate here...

Not to be snarky (well, maybe just a little....), but IMHO, gender identities are quite overrated.  I've been getting along just fine without one.  There's no real need to "prove" to anyone, including yourself,  that you are or are not trans, non-binary, cis, etc.  (Exception: gate-keeping medical professionals.  But then, you can always lie.)

IMHO it's far more important to figure out what kind of life would make you feel comfortable or, to put it another way, what would allow you to live as the real You.  It doesn't have to fit into anyone else's idea of what your life should be.  Then figure out what you have to do to get there, and in the process, what compromises you have to make.  BTW, these aren't separate steps.  As you take steps towards how you think you want to live, you will learn better what works and feels right.  It may be that some version of medical and/or social transition will make your life better, or it may not.

I've been seeing myself as trans for almost 3 years, and I'm constantly assailed by doubts.  What I hold onto is that each step toward and within transition has made me feel more alive and more myself, and that's why I continue to put myself through it.

Also keep in mind that there are as many ways to be male (cis or trans), female (cis or trans), or non-binary as there are people.

Finally: this is exactly the sort of thing a good gender counsellor will help you with.
"...  I think I'm great just the way I am, and so are you." -- Jazz Jennings



CPTSD
  •  

Satinjoy

Yup.  I agree with Asche.

And you can go anywhere in transition and still be nonbinary.  Its who we are.  Being different.
Morpheus: This is your last chance. After this, there is no turning back. You take the red pill - the story ends, you wake up in your bed and believe whatever you want to believe. You take the little blue pills - you stay in Wonderland and I show you how deep the rabbit-hole goes

Sh'e took the little blue ones.
  •  

V

I struggle a great deal with gender indentity issues. Just see my slightly flame-baity post in the hobbies section.
You'd think that as a 13 yrs post-op m2f, I'd have figured things out by now, but no, it's just not that clear cut.
I seem to be a "bit of both", even my mother said as much, and she seemed very jealous that I possessed traits of both genders and used both to advantage. She's adamant that I can't be both, and need to pick a side.
I sometimes feel like part of me is a guy stuck in a transexual woman's body, not sure if that makes sense.
I spent so long suppressing my female identity, and when I transitioned, I was happy to lose/drop much of my male baggage. But, and here's the thing, in order to gain acceptance and to pass in society as a woman, I found myself suppressing the male parts of me that I was comfortable with. I went from one binary to the other, when the truth is I probably lie somewhere in between. I know that in some ways we all do, but as someone who fought so hard to be taken seriously and accepted as female, I'm torn apart by paranoia that allowing the male side of me to "get some air", will ruin all my hard work.
I wish I had the strength of character to confidently show both sides, like some folk on this non-binary section do. I admire you very much.
It's all very confusing and unsettling for me to admit this, let alone know what to do.
  •  

Ayla

EJ

The only person that can decide if you are trans, if you are NB etc, is you.  Your questions, concerns and fears are quite normal and I think that most of us have been in a similar place.  But there is a way forward.  I found that ignoring these questions and this discomfort solved absolutely nothing.  The only thing that really worked for me was working through these issues, and any others that inevitably arise, with a competent gender therapist.  Over time I think that your self, your situation and your options become clear.  If you take care, nothing is irreversible.  Take a step at a time and use your therapist and a support group to help you find your way and discover your self. There is nothing wrong in taking your time - on this journey the only schedule, the only destination and the only gender identity that matters is yours.

Safe travels

Aisla
  •