I'd support a move to Top Surgery. That is where most guys to go look for surgeon pics and reviews.
Andy,
I'm so sorry this happened to you. I haven't looked at your threads on ->-bleeped-<- yet to see the whole write-up, but I would hope that you're able to get a revision somehow. Your nipples look like they've healed well and the incision line looks very thin, but there still appears to be a lot of excess tissue there along with the bunching in the center. On your right side, I can't tell if that's tissue or fluid buildup. I'd watch that one if it's fluid, it looks much different than the left. How was the drain on that side?
If you're local to SF, I'd encourage you to schedule a consultation with Dr. Satterwhite and see if he'd be willing to write out what all would need to be corrected. If they won't let you see an outside doctor (I believe that's how Kaiser works, right? All in house?), they'll at least have something in writing telling them what they need to fix. It may also help any kind of appeal you need to submit to get outside coverage to have something from a doctor saying that it requires fixing.
I believe someone on the board used a Kaiser surgeon in Oregon (Dr. Jennifer Murphy) and had a good experience and great results. If they insist on making you stay with Kaiser doctors for the revision, perhaps you could request to travel to her?