Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Period symptoms

Started by MelissaAnn, May 27, 2017, 11:21:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


Georgette

I assume you saying have symptoms similar to a AFAB menstrual monthly cycle while on HRT.

Can't say I had those prior to SRS, but after my OB/GYN had me on a monthly cycle of estrogen and progesterone I did have some of those symptoms.

I think the urgency to pee can vary on many factors.
AMAB - NOV 13 1950
HRT - Start 1975 / End 1985
Moved in with SO ( Also a MtF ) - 1976 / She didn't believe in same sex marriage
Name Change - NOV 30 1976
FT - Formal letter from work - APR 12 1977
SRS - SEP 13 1977
SO died - OCT 03 2014  38 years not a bad run

  •  

sarah1972

It is a highly discussed topic. There are quite a few MTF who have mentioned having at least partial symptoms. Since periods in cis women are controlled by hormones cycles, a MTF cycling at least one of the two hormones is undergoing the same changes in hormone level, so in my opinion it does make sense.

I am also cycling progesterone and I do notice changes in food cravings along the with the changes in hormone levels. Shortly after my 2 weeks of progesterone ends, I am usually constipated and bloated with some light cramps. Also get a bit more irritated. Usually all symptoms go away after a few days. Not sure that is full evidence, but to me it does make sense and talking to some of my cis girlfriends about it, they pretty much confirmed the symptoms.

  •  

link5019

Well  I get everything from the cramps, blood, bloating, headaches, cravings, etc. It....sucks.






  •  

rus

not sure why you got blood tho thats an interesting one.. anyone seen this before?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk




steps done so far to become the new happy me!
---------------------------------------------------------
Orchidectomy                  - Mar 13th 2017  (COMPLETE)
HRT Therapy begins Yay!  - Aug 21st  2017 (COMPLETE)
First Hair Removal            - Aug 29th 2017  (COMPLETE)
Second Hair Removal        - Sept 26th 2017 (COMPLETE)
More to Come...... sooooo much more :)
  •  

Quote from: link5019 on May 28, 2017, 07:52:06 AM
Well  I get everything from the cramps, blood, bloating, headaches, cravings, etc. It....sucks.

The entirety of this is ridiculous at worst, questionable at best, but, look:

Blood?

Blood?!?

Blood?!?

A trans-girl... getting a period... and... blood.

I hope this was either a typo, you're a true hermaprhodite, or you're just trollin but I'd bet money you're not either of those three things.

So let's think about this for a second... seriously contemplate this claim... I'll give you some time.


  •  

Cimara

Unless as someone suggested that you are a hermaphrodite it is not possible for you to bleed. You have no uterus.  The only place you could be bleeding if from your rectum. If that is the case run don't walk to a hospital.
Born 1989
Transitioned 2001
Began hrt 2001
  •  

warlockmaker

There is no responsible medical evidence of this being possible. Sometimes, when you want something so much your mind can create these needs to give you what you want. Medically, mtf on fulll hrt and or post srs are basically menopausal women. We can get mood swings from a HRT regime that is not well monitored by an endo.
When we first start our journey the perception and moral values all dramatically change in wonderment. As we evolve further it all becomes normal again but the journey has changed us forever.

SRS January 21st,  2558 (Buddhist calander), 2015
  •  

LiliFee

#8
Quote from: link5019 on May 28, 2017, 07:52:06 AM
Well  I get everything from the cramps, blood, bloating, headaches, cravings, etc. It....sucks.

We have discussed this before. There is NO medical evidence that transwomen can have cramps or bleeding due to menstruation. The reason is simple: we have no uterus. The blood comes from the uterus, and the cramps are uterine contractions.

As for the rest: HRT cycles can induce bloating, cravings and moodswings. These are all wellknown effects of progesterone.

And then there's the placebo effect. I get it you're really a girl, but you're not cis. Your mind can bend many perceptions to suit the need of feeling female, but it still doesn't make you a cis-girl.

On another note: I find these kind of comments VERY disrespectful to cis-women who do get their periods. They had to grow up in a world that belittles them, fills them with shame and sometimes ostracizes them for bleeding. It teaches girls they're the children of lesser gods, and in the developing world, even puts them in physical harm. Furthermore, they have had to deal with a non-stop stream of sexism from the moment they started bleeding, growing their breasts and being looked at by horny men when they weren't even 14.

None of us had those experiences at such a vulnerable age. We still grew up with the world thinking we were men, being endowed with the privilege which comes with that. Sure we had own troubles, which were harsh and put us in our own shameful places. But: we didn't have to experience those unrelenting forms of sexism when we didn't even know what the word meant.
–  γνῶθι σεαυτόν  –

"Know then thyself, presume not God to scan, The proper study of mankind is Man"
  •  

Dani

Ladies, please be kind.

Gender dysphoria manifests itself in many ways. There are psychological components to our situation.

If link5019 says she has those symptoms, then maybe those symptoms are real for her. Maybe she does have a uterus or something similar. I do not know her.

Many of you are correct in saying that without a uterus bleeding and cramping are physically not possible.
  •  

Cimara

Quote from: MelissaAnn on May 27, 2017, 11:21:27 PM
Does anyone else experience period symptoms of HER? Secondly have you experienced urgency to pee while on your period?

Perhaps there is another explanation. In the first post MelissaAnn mentions "period symptoms" from hrt. Then she asks if anyone has the increased urge to pee while on their "period". We know she meant "on your period" to mean while you are having hormonal symptoms from hrt and obviously not from menstruation.  But suppose Link did not know that. What if she is expecting to get actual period symptoms from hrt? She read the initial post and though obviously she can't have an actual period perhaps  she didn't know that and said she did to feel like she belonged more.

How could someone think that?  It is possible. I have had a cis friend who knew I was trans actually ask me when I first started menstruation.  After I explained that i had no uterus and had never and would never menstruate she said she thought the estrogen gave you a period. No joke!  People in general tend to be ignorant about the effects of estrogen. The know it feminizes but some people tend to think it has the power to cause impossible changes. Like making you shorter,  making your hands smaller, etc.

This possible explanation is almost as far fetched as her claim I know but I have been trying to figure out why she would say this. None of us would make such a claim in a public forum UNLESS we didnt know any better. She is only 20 years old according to her profile. I prefer this explanation to thinking she is just some troll observing the forum and messing around.
Born 1989
Transitioned 2001
Began hrt 2001
  •  

josie76

Ok well as far as cramps, that can be from constipation in the bowls which can be caused by the drop off of hormones.

Blood would require a girl to have been intersexed and have partial uterine tissues. It's extremely rare but looking through alot of medical information it has been seen before. The one condition I remember reading was due to unformed tissues the uterine partial organ was connected to the anal area of the large intestine. Who knows strange things happen.

Give link5019 some leeway. She has been a member of this forum for a while. Don't just jump on people and start calling them trolls!  >:( That's way not nice to do.

Link5019, unless you're Intersex and your doctor has explored this, I really think you should visit your doctor to discuss any bleeding. If you are not Intersex and you have blood associated with cycling hormones you need to get it checked out right away.
04/26/2018 bi-lateral orchiectomy

A lifetime of depression and repressed emotions is nothing more than existence. I for one want to live now not just exist!

  •  

Cimara

I did not call her a troll. Someone else said that. I was just saying I hope she is just confused rather than thinking she is a troll.
Born 1989
Transitioned 2001
Began hrt 2001
  •  

josie76

Yes I know you didn't. I was aiming my thoughts more at the tone the discussion had taken.

Not intending to be pointed to any one person.  :)
04/26/2018 bi-lateral orchiectomy

A lifetime of depression and repressed emotions is nothing more than existence. I for one want to live now not just exist!

  •  

Charlie Nicki

Put down your torches girls :), let her explain.
Latina :) I speak Spanish, English and a bit of Portuguese.
  •  

DawnOday

Quote from: MelissaAnn on May 27, 2017, 11:21:27 PM
Does anyone else experience period symptoms of HER? Secondly have you experienced urgency to pee while on your period?
Are you on Spiro? It's main medical use is for controlling edema of Congestive Heart Failure; As a diuretic it's function is to make you pee. Can't say in my 9 1/2 months on estradiol  that I have even remotely had symptoms of bleeding or mood swings for that matter. So far it's all been good.
Dawn Oday

It just feels right   :icon_hug: :icon_hug: :icon_kiss: :icon_kiss: :icon_kiss:

If you have a a business or service that supports our community please submit for our Links Page.

First indication I was different- 1956 kindergarten
First crossdress - Asked mother to dress me in sisters costumes  Age 7
First revelation - 1982 to my present wife
First time telling the truth in therapy June 15, 2016
Start HRT Aug 2016
First public appearance 5/15/17



  •  

Devlyn

Beets, rhubarb, blackberries, etc, can all cause red urine. If red stains showed up in my panties I'd be sweating bullets.
  •  

Cimara

I have had UTIs before and taken AZO which makes you pee orange. I did have a very bad UTI once and had bloody urine. But it was just that. Not "bleeding".  I thought at least one plus about being stuck with boy parts was UTIs are uncommon but my Dr told me constant tucking can increase the chance of a UTI. 😧 Spironolactone makes me pee a LOT.  My moods are usually consistent. ( my boyfriend would probably say I am consistently a bitch Lol)  I LOVE pickles and anything pickled, herring, eggs, etc, but I have loved pickles since I was a small child so it has nothing to do with hrt.
Born 1989
Transitioned 2001
Began hrt 2001
  •  

Aurorasky

Period symptoms are possible with HRT, especially combined with P. No blood is possible because there's no uterus or ovaries to relase an egg, unless I'm missing something here.

LiliFee, I agree to an extent BUT, remember not all trans girls had male privilegie growing up, especially if they transitioned really young. Before HRT I was already small, light, with a high voice and femme face. Nobody knew what I was and I got harassed everywhere. I don't think you can call that privilege.
Love,

Aurora Beatriz da Fonseca
  •  

Cimara

I never had any male privilege.  I transitioned when I was 12. But I hardly consider it would be a privilege to be male. No thank you.
Born 1989
Transitioned 2001
Began hrt 2001
  •