Appy, my long lost daughter I am sooooo happy for you. #2 - Biff, I think would be purely physical attraction. As a goddess I know these things and Biff sounds like my brother Adonis so be careful.
#3 Mystery man, hummmmm. You need to let us all know about who works at this coffee shop.
#1 Baseball Player - hummmm
Just be careful and safe. Read somewhere recently how our hormones override logic.