Woah, looks like I missed some posts!
I've looked through Long Tall Sally's before, but some of their stuff is so expensive, especially shoes. It might be worth it if I can get a good pair of nice-looking boots though, I wouldn't wear them every day so I'm sure they'd last a long time.
For most casual outifts, I imagine I could probably just wear the shoes I usually wear. I like to wear pants that are wide and drap-ey enough to cover my ankles, though, because the contrast of my skinny ankles with my long feet makes them look really big, which is why I'm wary of wearing leggings with regular shoes. That said, what are some good options for non-jeans pants that are thinner and form-fitting higher up, but flare out and cover your feet a bit at the bottom?