Uh oh, mentioning Dr. O can get into a heated conversation. Here's my take on it...
I, and a few of my friends, have been to Dr. O. Most (like 99.9%) of the pictures I've seen of his work are excellent and look as natural as can be achieved, even on the worst case scenarios. Yes, he is old, but god knows you wouldn't know it by how he acted. He seems like he's still a kid. His staff is amazing. His (well, two nurses at Davies) after-care is very comfortable and supportive. Yes, he suggests everything to you, but that's because he's a perfectionist. That doesn't mean you actually have to go with everything. I have only had chin work and a trachea shave with him so far, but have the rest scheduled for January. I did not go for every single procedure, just the ones that I am uncomfortable with. From personal experience of my own surgery with him, along with multiple friends of mine who look great, I would say Dr. O is a great choice.
Yes, other people will tell you he is too expensive, too old, too this, or too that. The bottom line is, go to San Francisco, get a consultation, if he doesn't fit the bill for you then consult with others (which you may want to do anyways).
As far as Dr. Alter, I have no experience so maybe others here can give you their feedback on him.
Good luck on your search!
- Sarah
