Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Trans Enough?

Started by milliontoone, April 06, 2009, 09:17:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

milliontoone

An article I wrote, let me know what you think:

Why should I have to quantify how trans I am based on other peoples perceptions of how I should behave and act?
Because I am an FTM transexual does it mean I have to turn in to the ultimate stereotype of masculinity before people will accept I am "trans" enough.
Because I find men sexually attractive and not women does this mean I am not trans enough?  Should I care if I am trans enough?  Do I really want to be trans enough?

Why do I feel the need to point out
that I like to be the one to penetrate men in most sexual enounters that I have and that vaginal penetration is not a part of my sex life nor do I ever want it to be?
Why do I feel like this gives me extra ->-bleeped-<- points, validates my transness in someway?
It's just a fact of life for me, my sexual preferences, I can't change them.
Maybe I can choose them but I cannot change them.

Should it matter?  Would it make me less trans if I wanted to bottom every single night for a guy for the rest of my life?  I mean if I know I'm trans isn't that enough? 

If I identify as male then I am because that is after all what I identify with.  Otherwise I would identify as a female or as a camel or a lion. To me it is obvious, people identify for a reason the clue is in the word.  Identity.
And yet I find myself having to explain and make excuses for myself and what I am to people over and over again just so they can feel at ease with me, with who I am.

I find myself saying to people in banks who stare at me blankly when presented with a money order in a male name, my name, "It's ok, I'm transexual" excusing their ignorance at
being unable to perceive me as male purely based on how I look and speak even though there I am telling them as male, presenting as male stereotypically in terms of clothing
etc...

I find myself excusing peoples embarrassement when they call me on the phone asking to speak to Mr Robertson and when I say that's me speaking struggling not to feel distaste and hatred for them, for their ignorance as they stammmer and stutter and flounder and keep insisting that they want a Mr Robertson and then I offer them absolution with the golden line "it's allright, I'm transexual, it's ok I get it a lot" just so they don't feel stupid because of what they didn't know and put out because they feel stupid because
then they might hate me, despise me because my very being threatens their ego.

So I make it ok. I smooth things over with a shrug, an easy laugh.  But oh I despise them for their blindness because dammit why can't they see.
I know the answer to that is "it's just human nature" but that's not even totally true.
That's where the scorn I feel comes in for ignorance and for blindness because I know it doesn't have to be that way.

I mean I've met people that totally accept me as a man, who would unconditionally even if I was wearing mascara and a dress just because I say I am
and that's enough for them and I also know people who perceive gender as merely a form of social stereotyping and see people as individuals composed of many varying colours each in a different way not beings limited to black or white, male or female.

And while this doesn't exactly describe the way I feel, i mean personally I don't have a problem as identifying as male and I have no real desire to live in a completely non-gendered world where everyone was completely androgenous, I do see the reality.

That there should be more room for manouvre than there currently is, more acceptance,more tolerance.  That human beings are complex creatures made up of many shades of grey rather than the cookie cutter black and white moulds that at the moment we are all forced to endure.  I think eventually we will evolve to a point where this dogmatic way of seeing the world ceases to become relevant, stops making sense in the same way we had to revise our opinion that the world was round despite our limited beliefs.

Outmoded ways of thinking are eventually pushed out by neccessity by evolution in the same way that the story of creation according to the bible doesn't explain
why there are dinosaur bones being excavated every day by archaeologists and why black people are not bought and sold as human commodities anymore, why women now have the right to vote.

But at one time all these things were seen as shocking, against, nature, scandalous, revolutionary that that was just the way things were and so it must be right.
My personal view is that one day we will come to see gender and to a lesser degree sexuality in a less rigid interpretation than we currently do.  There is in my opinion just too much contradictory evidence for any other eventual outcome.


And of course I understand that people do tend to go only on what they see when passing judgement on what kind of person a person is, I do it myself to some degree which is obviously the main reason for my physical transition if only so I can perceive myself as more physically
male but the question is not do we tend to go only on what we see when judging what a person is it is should we?

  •  

imaz

Wonderful piece of writing milliontoone  :)

Seriously that is so good it should be published somewhere.

I'm the "other way round" from you in every way and totally identify with all you said. Hopefully one day we will look back on our struggle and feel we made a difference somewhere.

Thank you :)
  •  

Janet_Girl

Great piece, Milliontoone,

Well written and in depth.   And I agree with it entirely, well except that I am going the other way.  There are too many people that just don't agree with our definitions.

And it should be out on the web for all to see.

Thank You for the wrods of wisdom.

Janet

  •  

Mr. Fox

Quote from: Kiera on April 06, 2009, 09:41:59 AM
But isn't the whole point of you physically transitioning to make it easier for others to see "that somebody" you already know and perceive?

Personally, my point in physically transitioning is to feel comfortable in my own body rather than for social reasons, but that's just me.
  •  

Nicky

Quote from: Mr. Fox on April 06, 2009, 11:46:42 AM
Personally, my point in physically transitioning is to feel comfortable in my own body rather than for social reasons, but that's just me.

I was going to say the same. 
  •  

Ashley315

Very good.  Interesting read full of thought provoking subjects.

It is a shame how we as  a group even judge each other sometimes.
  •  

NicholeW.

Quote from: Ashley315 on April 07, 2009, 11:12:55 AM
Very good.  Interesting read full of thought provoking subjects.

It is a shame how we as  a group even judge each other sometimes.

Might I enquire as to what group of people do not judge one another in this world?

Nichole
  •  

cindybc

"Hee, hee," afraid I haven't Nichol.

I also transitioned for peace of mind as well as to bring soul and body into accord with one another. I feel that once I found myself to be confident and secure with whom I was I found it much easier to integrate with the rest of society, I came to discover I was what I projected myself to be. Also practicing a little empathy, feeling a person from the inside out.

Cindy
  •  

milliontoone

Thanks for reading guys, glad you enjoyed.  I may well submit it to a trans site seeing as some of you felt that might be relevant.  I have written some other articles on transexualism as well, I may post these some other time if they would not be unwelcome.

Once again, thanks for taking the time to read.
  •  

Ashley315

Quote from: Nichole on April 07, 2009, 04:56:43 PM
Might I enquire as to what group of people do not judge one another in this world?

Nichole

Everyone does, but it's the reasons we judge each other that is most sickening IMO. 
  •  

Miniar

Quote from: Nichole on April 07, 2009, 04:56:43 PM
Might I enquire as to what group of people do not judge one another in this world?

Nichole

There is "judge", and then there is "judgmental".
Even in these circles, where people have been even abused at the mouths if not hands of judgmental people, we can find those amongst ourselves that treat us from a judgmental position. 



"Everyone who has ever built anywhere a new heaven first found the power thereto in his own hell" - Nietzsche
  •  

cindybc

I may not understand why some do certain things or make certain choices and sometimes it's unfortunate that some will not at least try to enlighten me as to why they made certain choices. I try to be forthright about mine and why I made those choices but some treat me as though I am trying to provoke them into retaliation for infringing on their choices. I don't judges I am only here to learn so that I may be better a teacher and supporter for others who will walk the same mile in the same moccasins. I am only a student.

Cindy
  •  

Ashley315

Let me put it a little more bluntly.  I have been judged by several members of the group based solely on the fact that I am a trans lesbian.  I'm not going to name any names or anything, but some apparently believe that if you do not have any desire to be with a man, then their is no point in transitioning and somehow they think it makes them more of a woman than I am.

This is just one of the judgments we do to each other.  There are many others.  The "pass or not" judgment is probably the most common however and either way you slice it, it's the wrong kinda pie.
  •  

NicholeW.

Quote from: Miniar on April 08, 2009, 03:33:24 PM
There is "judge", and then there is "judgmental".
Even in these circles, where people have been even abused at the mouths if not hands of judgmental people, we can find those amongst ourselves that treat us from a judgmental position. 


O, it's not that i disagree with you. One might even think that those who judge or are judgemental while being judge by the judgemental would be averse to doing that. One might think.

My experience tells me "show me someone who's been treated unfairly and prejudicially and I will show you someone who in excess of 90% of the time will want to treat someone else even more prejudicially and unfairly than they were treated." It's like getting one's payback by finding someone to pay me back who I feel is weaker than I am.

I believe that the Christian founder is said, in one of those first four New Testament books, to have made a parable about exactly that. A man forgiven a debt who turns about and casts another in prison who owes him money.

My guess is the trait is fully alive in all sorts of human beings. Regardless how one might like to think it "should" be.

Nichole
  •  

Ashley315

I kinda prefer the one about "judge not least ye be judged yourself".
  •  

Janet_Girl

Or maybe he who is without sin, cast the first stone.  I have nothing against any sister that wishes to be with another woman, nor any brother who wishes to be with another man.  To each her/his own.   Just as I would expect that I should not be judge for my past statement of my operational status.

I understand the judgment and being judge by others, even within the community.  To be Trans Enough should be where we are all comfortable in our own skins.  And others should look to their own life and ask if the are Trans Enough in their own right.  And not judge another for what they  believe about themselves.

Janet

  •  

NicholeW.

My point, if I uncontrollably lurched into one, was simply that all the "shoulds" and "likes" are irrelevant.

Human activity and thought and feeling seldom follows the "shoulds" and "likes" and "ought tos" and instead goes toward basic reaction.

I mean the xtian founder was full of great sayings about how people should love and honor one another, but I don't think he was under a ton of illusions about how we "do" love and honor each other. And I would extend that to the other founders of other great religions as well.

Religion and ideals are trying to point us to where human meets divine, but they seldom "take" with the vast majority of us. We prefer low roads in general that require much less work of ourselves.

And Janet, I agree that people shouldn't judge you on your change of heart. But am too sceptical to think that no one will or already has in some way or another.

Nichole


  •