I took Theatrical Makeup in college years ago. About a month ago, I paid for a session with a professional makeup artist ($50) and got a 'starter set' list out of it.
Last night I was trying to follow her chart, but decided to just do the bare minimum -- like you were saying, Julie. A few dabs of concealer on the really noticeable blemishes, and very little foundation, well blended. I worked a bit on the eyes and lips. But again, I went for just-noticeable.
Besides, I was running late, and didn't have a lot of time.
Later, at the restaurant, I went to 'powder my nose.' (Side note, it's disconcerting when one whole wall of the stall is glass brick and an exterior wall onto the sidewalk, to boot!) As I was washing up, I glanced at the image in the mirror...
...and was brought up short! The woman in the long black dress staring back at me looked good -- really good...
I was pleased with the effect. I'm glad I didn't over-do it. And I felt my self confidence boosted the rest of the night.

Karen