Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

The Androgyne Manager

Started by no_id, July 16, 2010, 09:58:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

no_id

Hey no_id, aren't you posting this in the wrong section?...
I would have if I could have but I decided to be creative..

Righ-oh, recently I came accross some articles on a research conducted by a Dutch university on management skills with emphasis on masculine and feminine traits. They concluded that the modern manager is an Androgyne manager: one that combines skills that are traditionally deemed more masculine or feminine and has an high IQ as well as EQ.

Until here this could have been a pretty interesting thread for the Androgyne section, but then I ran into something else.

The Dutch show 'Man Bijt Hond' (Man Bites Dog) used this research for a short interview with a transwoman. Her name is Connie and she is a manager. The reason they interviewed her is because they found it odd that she wasn't asked to participate in the research based on 'apparent masculine and feminine qualities'... Not exactly the most educated motivation, but that's not what this thread is about.

What struck me is that Connie explained that before she transitioned she also held a management position and that after transitioning she has started managing somewhat differently. She noticed how more traditionally feminine qualities began to influence her 'style' and how some traditionally masculine became less. However, she also notes that there are still some strong, traditionally masculine qualities that remain (whether this is due to succesful experiences in the past or other), and all-with-all her management style has therefore become rather androgyne.

So here's my question to you...
To those who hold management positions: have you noticed a change in your style during/after transitioning?
To those who do not hold management positions: have you noticed a change in your work style during/after transitioning?
Also, if your behaviour changed then did your work and/or colleagues also behave or respond differently to you? And I don't mean that in a coming out kind of way, more as: when you presented male you worked well but was never truly compliment versus when you presented female you worked well and was often complimented (e.g.).

I thought this an interesting topic regarding behaviour changes, perception and overal atitude towards masculinity and femininity in the work place. Thanks in advance for any replies! :)


Also, I didn't post the video with the interview since it's in Dutch. If people are interested though, I can always provide a transscript.
Tara: The one time in my life I thought I was happy, I was a f**kin zombie.

True Blood S3E2
  •  

Dryad

As a Dutchie, I wouldn't mind seeing the transcript. ^_^

Now; I have little experience with managing, but I think the androgyne way has been used for a long time.
Just take a suit. A standard suit. It's about as sexless as I can imagine, along with things like monk's robes. It strips a person off their sexuality and humanity, and makes them a corporate tool.

As for managing itself: I've noticed that, when leading people, the best way to go about it is to be harsh where needed, and kind where not. Always offer positive feedback along with negative, and always express why you have the remarks you've got. Something I've seen more in women than in men, the latter often having a sense of: No; wrong. Do it like this. There is no why, and no: 'But I did appreciate the way you...' So nothing uplifting. This way of management is destructive for production, since after a while, people will feel they can't do it right, anyway.
I've lead a Live Role Play organization, a WoW guild, and managed a stable. In all these instances, using styles attributed traditionally to both genders is the best way to go about things. Acting self-assured, but first and foremost also making other people self-assured, while steering things so that it's the people who make the decisions you want them to make by themselves instead of by being forced offers the most productivity, the best results, and the most improvements.

I don't know how I would do things post transition, though.. I have a hunch that I will try to do the same. Inspire instead of rule. I'm just not entirely sure how this is linked to gender. Traditionally, there is little difference between men who ruse and women who rule, or men who inspire, and women who inspire. Little difference that I can see, anyway. As far as I've experienced, both men and women can rule and inspire equally.
  •