Wow thanks for all the options guys

Miniar: I like the idea of the sock and some safety pins to keep the sock in place
Rob: I think that site they suggested in the thread your referring to is the one that Kilo put on here
Jay: I guess I was wrong, I have the 5.5" which is a medium on their sizing. I was afraid to get the 3.5" at the time because in the pictures it looked like it didn't bend at all.
Carson: That's an awesome idea. I'll try that if I can find a pair of boxers like that
Kilo: I took a look at the site. Thanks for the link! I'll probably consider theirs before anything else.