Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Blindsided

Started by Jacquelyn, January 09, 2011, 09:54:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jacquelyn

Quote from: sonopoly on January 15, 2011, 11:17:39 AM
I've had an SO for 19 years now and had a previous boyfriend die suddenly at 25.

I am sorry to hear that. I wouldn't wish a loss like that upon my worst enemy.

However, I do not believe that gives you the right to spew untrue or hateful things at me when I have done nothing to harm you.
Quote from: sonopoly on January 15, 2011, 11:19:36 AM
Okay, Jackie, I wasn't trying to be cruel to you, but when I heard you say that you wouldn't be with him if he became a woman because you want children and think that a child should have a woman for a mother and a man for a father, that REALLY pissed me the F*** Off.  That's all I was trying to get across, okay???

I think that you mistook my feelings. I am working through many emotions, I am trying to work things out with my SO, and I am trying to be supportive of whatever he must do.

However, if I want to raise my children with a male father and a female mother it is entirely my prerogative to do so. To suggest I am wrong in wanting that is no less unintelligent than for someone to claim that every family ought to be alternative. It is a personal choice that I believe every person ought to be allowed to make.
"Love is in fact so unnatural a phenomenon that it can scarcely repeat itself, the soul being unable to become virgin again and not having energy enough to cast itself out again into the ocean of another."

~James Joyce
  •  

sonopoly

Jackie, I don't think you are unintelligent at all -- the opposite actually.

I totally agree that it is your prerogative to have a child with both a male father and a female mother -- I just don't understand why you are pursuing this any further unless you want to stop his desires to transition (and therefore, HIS happiness) for your own happiness.

I've been trying to think why this bothers me so much.  I think (but I'm not quite sure) it's because I see the anti-gay marriage people and see how they're so opposed to it, yet they are not even remotely affected by it.  They just say "Marriage should be between a man and a woman, because the bible says so".  Whenever people talk about the bible and say it's the word of god, I always say, No way - men wrote the bible to get what they want, just like that mormon guy said that god says that I should be able to marry a million women so we all go to heaven (and I can ->-bleeped-<- a million children -- and you know how many of his followers believed him!?!?!?) or that hitler said that he's killing the jews for a better cause.  I just don't buy into any of it, because I can think for myself and I can decide what's right and wrong for myself, and it certainly isn't that a child needs a man to be a father and that a woman should be a mother, otherwise if I'd been in Nazi germany I'd be murdering all Jews.
  •  

Jacquelyn

Quote from: sonopoly on January 15, 2011, 11:19:36 AM
Okay, Jackie, I wasn't trying to be cruel to you, but when I heard you say that you wouldn't be with him if he became a woman because you want children and think that a child should have a woman for a mother and a man for a father, that REALLY pissed me the F*** Off.  That's all I was trying to get across, okay???

NIMBY means NOT in my backyard, which I saw that you accepted your aunt, but, you know, as long is it's NOT IN MY BACKYARD!!! It just reminded me of "some of my best friends are gay!!!!"

Jackie, if you respond or anyone else does, I just want to know why it is okay for a person to feel that they don't want to have children with someone of the same sex.  Okay, it is okay, I guess, but is it really?  Of course it is. You can feel how you want to.  It is everyone's right.  I just don't think that much of people who feel that way, though I accept that people do feel that way, I just wouldn't want to be associated with them.  Maybe Dan feels the same way I do.  From your posts, IT IS he who is rejecting you, am I right? Which is why I added the NIMBY thing -- Yeah, I think it's okay, but not for me and my children.  Please explain this to me.  I know I might be attacked for my posts, but I want to get some intelligent and informed opinions as to why I'm getting attacked.

I guess what doesn't really ring true about your love for him is that you are going through all this (and he is going through this tenfold) and you are already thinking about children when it's not even close to being in the equation at this point.  He is going through SERIOUS issues RIGHT NOW.  You need to address them if you really care about him.  I don't get why you're talking about children at this point for Christ sake.  There is so much going on in him and you are already thinking about things that are way in the future.  I mean, when I fell in love I really thought in the moment or just the very near future.  Maybe that's just me, but I think he is really going through the most major confusion in his life and you are worried about things that are really so far in the future that I question your feelings for him.  He needs your help and support for crucial things that are going on now for him -- perhaps life or death things and you're wondering about children.  Just strange to me.

Sonopoly,

I know what NIMBY stands for, I'm not an idiot. And honestly, people can be accepting of homosexuality, transsexuality, anything really and not BE homosexual or transsexual. You are looking to pick a fight, and I am not going to honor you with one. Do not try to discredit myself or anyone else on this site based upon your insinuations.

Actually, Dan's biggest fear is that I am going to reject him. He was scared when he came out, and he is still scared because he is uncertain. However, I love him, and I am not going to walk out on him. If things end, his GID is going to be the furthest thing from what brings us down (again READ ALL OF THE POSTS IN A THREAD BEFORE POSTING PLEASE. Save the rest of us the headache since we follow the flow of the thread).

And again, your NIMBY thing with the kids. Stupid and irrelevant. You can raise your children to be circus performers, just because I don't doesn't mean that I am an awful person or that I hate circuses, does it? No. You are drawing conclusions that are haphazard and offensive at best. I realize that this is  public forum, and that you have every right to voice your opinion, but that doesn't mean that they are correct. Each and every person has the right to raise their family in the manner that they want, and to surround themselves with the people of their choosing.

Also, we are addressing Dan's problems RIGHT NOW. I am the one who encouraged him to seek counseling. I am the one that has been bending over backwards to make him feel comfortable expressing himself because he never has been able to. I find it ESPECIALLY insulting that you try to play out the life or death scenario at me. Dan is an adult. Dan is actually the one who brought up the subject of children. When you are in a relationship with someone and you want to spend the rest of your life with them it is not at all uncommon to discuss the goals that you have, and for us one of those things was a family. Don't you dare for a second doubt my feelings for him. That is perhaps the most insulting thing that you have said. By far. I love him, I am trying to help him, I am trying to make things work WITH him. If I can't do that, then I will let him live his life as he needs to. Will that crush me? Absolutely.

Until this point I had not encountered such a mean spirited person on this site. Though you pointed out that you have not had the best track record with your lovers I am unable to feel empathy towards your poisonous and hurtful accusations. Though you mask them with a seemingly intelligent request for clarification I see what you are doing for what it really is.

I really can't fathom the kind of person that is so unabashedly negative and critical.

Finally, I am not trying to quell Dan's happiness. If I was I would never have suggested him seeking out a gender therapist. I would not go to counseling with him. I would not consider for a second his need to transition. However, things are complex, and we are working together to get through it. Partnership is really something strange, as I went through your posts and see that you are not transgendered nor the SO of a transgendered person I do applaud you for seeking out the community with the intent (questionably) to support us. However, as some other individuals here (trans and cis) will point out, transitioning is equally difficult for the partner. Before I was in this position I would not so vehemently have anything to say one way or another about how it feels, however, living it is alltogether different and until you are in that position I would like to kindly disregard your mostly insufferable comments.
"Love is in fact so unnatural a phenomenon that it can scarcely repeat itself, the soul being unable to become virgin again and not having energy enough to cast itself out again into the ocean of another."

~James Joyce
  •  

cynthialee

Sonopoly;
back off the lady. She has enough on her plate as it is.
So it is said that if you know your enemies and know yourself, you can win a hundred battles without a single loss.
If you only know yourself, but not your opponent, you may win or may lose.
If you know neither yourself nor your enemy, you will always endanger yourself.
Sun Tsu 'The art of War'
  •  

sonopoly

Okay, so the one question that I've asked and have asked since my first post of this issue is:

Why are you pursuing this relationship if you said that you absolutely don't want to be with a person who is female because you want children with someone who is male?  That is my problem.  If you hadn't made this simple and absolute statement, I wouldn't have thought anything of it.  I don't get why you are pursuing this, when you are the one who is being so inflexible.
  •  

sonopoly

Okay, I admit I went too far.  Thank you for pointing this out, Cynthia.  I'm sorry, Jackie.  I just had some issues.  Don't be so mad at me. I really do think you are a wonderful person and are going through a very difficult situation.  I'm looking from afar.  I'm sorry if I seemed cruel and heartless.  I will delete all my posts, if you wish.

I wasn't trying to pick a fight with you, Jackie.  I was just trying to understand you.  Thank you for the negative reputation mark.
  •  

Cindy

 :police:
I'm moderating this thread and I'm disappointed in comments being made that are uncalled for. Be very aware of TOS rule 2 and rule 10. I will enforce them.

Cindy James
Global Moderator
  •  

sonopoly

Jackie,

I am so sorry that I attacked you about this.  The issue at hand is important to me, but you have a right to your own feelings and are going through a lot right now.  I think I was really mean and unfair to you.  I am sorry about that, because obviously you are a very caring, compassionate, and kind person.  I think I was thinking about the people who don't think that same sex people should bring up children, which I'm sure you aren't a part of that group.  You have your own personal experiences and know what you can't handle and what you want.  I think it's better to know this, than to pretend.

I am heterosexual, and I full-heartedly support gay people, but I don't think I'd have a gay relationship.  It doesn't mean that I am not in support of them.  I guess I could be attacked for that as unfairly as I attacked you.

I am so sorry.  You are such a nice person, and I feel really bad about hurting you.  I hope you can accept my apology.

Sono
  •  

PrincessCL

Where have you gotten to Jacquelyn?

Shoot us an update with what's new!
  •  

Lee

Hey Jackie, sorry for joining the thread so late in the game.  I don't really have much to contribute, but I wanted to say that I hope Dan knows how lucky he is to have someone so loving and supportive beside him.  I can only hope he realizes that you are more than worth the effort.  It's been quite a while since you updated, so here's hoping that things are going well.
Oh I'm a lucky man to count on both hands the ones I love

A blah blog
http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/board,365.0.html
  •  

Melody Maia

I will let Jackie speak for herself and what is going on in her life if she chooses to share it with us. I do talk to her quite frequently though and rest assured she is ok, if facing life challenges right now (as we all are of course.) I'm sure she will return to Susan's and be her ray-of-sushine self soon enough. Until then, you will have to make do with me, the poor-man's Jackie. LOL!
and i know that i'm never alone
and i know that my heart is my home
Every missing piece of me
I can find in a melody



O
  •  

Lee

Thank you for the update Melody.  It's good to know that other people are watching out for her.  I hope that she manages to get things settled and can rejoin us soon.  Until then, this poor man would happily hang out with you.  Of course, given the option, I'd go ahead and be greedy by asking for both of you to be around. :laugh:
Oh I'm a lucky man to count on both hands the ones I love

A blah blog
http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/board,365.0.html
  •  

Melody Maia

Thanks Lee  :) Jackie and I, along with Sara (Miss_Anthropic) have been in one place before when they came down to visit. The state of Florida forced us to go to Disney as only the Happiest Place on Earth was able to contain that much happiness! Otherwise we are legally obligated not to be in the same place at the same time as that might rip the very fabric of reality.  :D :D :D
and i know that i'm never alone
and i know that my heart is my home
Every missing piece of me
I can find in a melody



O
  •  

Lee

When you consider that Minnie Mouse was there too, it's amazing that even Disney World could handle the combined cuteness.
Oh I'm a lucky man to count on both hands the ones I love

A blah blog
http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/board,365.0.html
  •