Hey guys...I saw this thread while doing a search on google and just thought I'd add in my two cents. I recently purchased 2 of Reelmagik's prosthetics and I have to say I absolutely love them! I purchased the 6" with flex rod first, and oh my god it looked so real! It was so amazing, it looks just like real skin. The flex rod works pretty well too. It's not shiny, and it's nothing like the Lolajake. It is fairly large, but that's what I wanted.
I watched the video that Heath posted, and it does look shiny on video for some reason. I also noticed that you said your tab was sort of curved the wrong way so that it doesn't stick to you as well, but mine isn't like that at all...it actually conforms to me really well. I have worn it all day, and even in the shower without it coming off. I have had it come loose, but if you just push it back on and hold it for a minute, the silicone glue will stick again.
Just an FYI regarding Riccirules comment about pros-aide...that won't work. I have a friend who does some basic make-up and gave me some of that to try. It didn't work at all.
Anyway, after using the 6" one for a while, I decided to try the 8" also. Man, its huge, but I love it. My g/f loves it too! As for anal, I don't think it's hard enough for that, but I never tried it either. I would recommend the REELMAGIK if you want serving that looks and feels super realistic.
P.S. I hear they are coming out with a 4" one soon. I emailed them an asked about it and they said there new ones coming tonthe store in the next month, but they said they can't confirm what it will be. Anyhow, good luck!