You know I'd expect to feel a lingering pain every now and then after the surgery. My opinion stems from my own experiences. 9 months ago I stepped on a shard from a broken cup and sliced through the first knuckle (underside) on my big toe. I never went for stitches, cause that's what super glues for, and just let it heal up. It took a good month to close completely, but it is healed now.
However, sometimes when I'm doing push-ups or walking barefoot on carpet, I'll sometimes get a pang of pain where the cut was. This is however the first injury i've had that I get these bursts every now and then from. I think it might have had to do with a) how deep it was b) I didn't stitch it, I really should have as it was an inch long and about half an inch deep (traumatic for a toe!) c) it's in a spot that gets a lot of strain on a daily basis anyways and c) I think I got a mild infection at one point during the healing process.
However none of my other old scars hurt so I think reoccurring pain has to do with, whether you got an infection during the healing process, how well it healed and how traumatic the injury was (ie: did it go through muscle/tissue/ligaments/bone/etc or was it just a shallow cut).
However I also expect it's very personal to the person and how sensitive you are in that area to begin with. I have 'issues' with my feet, getting a cut on my foot freaked me out because it's all just bone, muscle and ligaments. Had I gotten the same cut ANYWHERE else on my body I wouldn't have cared all that much. But bleeding profusely from my foot and knowing how deep the cut was still gives me the heeby jeeby's.
So to sum up, It's probably has a lot to do with your body and how the healing process is for you. I don't think anyone could say definitively 'yes' or 'no'.