Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Flying While Trans

Started by Misato, June 05, 2013, 06:02:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Misato

Quote from: laurenlg on June 06, 2013, 07:43:19 AM
I actually just experienced this two weekends ago on a trip with some friends to New Orleans where I flew from Austin to NOLA and back. I was completely presenting as a woman the entire time and no one batted an eye. Check in at the airlines went smooth and security had no issue. They just looked at my ID which has me clearly looking like a male and M in gender. They asked what my name was and I told them my legal name as of today and was sent right through. My suggestion is to bring an extra form of ID just in case (passport) and make sure when it comes to forms and tickets you list your current legal gender. It was a great experience for me and one that was rather affirming.

Considering the flight is to a job interview I love the idea of using an abundance of caution by having a second form of ID.
  •  

Lara1969

Maybe you can ask a transgender organization to issue the additional transgender ID. Here ist a link to the ID card with some text in it in English:
http://www.dgti.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=10

The site unfortunately is only available in German.

Lara
Happy girl from queer capital Berlin
  •  

Jennifer Snowskier

Hi Lara,

I love the idea of the additional or supplementary ID card. I can see so many times when this would be of great use, not just when flying. It would be a great help in explaining the difference the official document, (passport, drivers licence, etc.. and how we are presenting). I am in that situation now, I feel its like being in no mans, (no persons?) land. On a trip overseas last February/March I did receive a few strange looks at customs/immigration. It will only be more confusing next trip I guess.

I always find it interesting how an official looking document will help influence peoples attitudes. It seems to give clarity and legitimacy to their decision making.

Many thanks

Jen
I dream of a world where a chicken can cross the road without it's motives being questioned.
  •  

A

Doesn't everyone usually carry around at least 2 or 3 ID cards? I have, eh, health insurance card, driver's license and student card, and if I were travelling outside the country (and if it hadn't expired many years ago) I'd also have my passport.
A's Transition Journal
Last update: June 11th, 2012
No more updates
  •  

Tristan

I know I carry at least two forms of id
  •  

Jennifer Snowskier

Hi A and Tristan,

Yes I normally carry two or three forms of photo ID. However the type of card that Lara is talking about in Germany is for transgendered people.

http://www.dgti.org/images/Bilder/ergaus_hinten.jpg

The link is for the English translation on the card. I think its a good idea. From what I can make out from the rough translation on-line the card is for people who are in the process of transitioning and are going through the real life test. Given the volume of "official" documents that we have these days it seems to me that it is a good way to explain why there is a conflict between the information on the document and how the person is presenting. I think this waould be very handy for travelling overseas, a bit like an International Drivers Licence.

Perhaps Lara can give a bit more detail about the ID card.

Cheers

Jen
I dream of a world where a chicken can cross the road without it's motives being questioned.
  •  

Cindy

I've only done local flights around Australia and no one has blinked. I get scanned by female guards and they have not even wanted me to take my wrist bangles off. One I can't take off anyway.

Jennifer, I got my new passport and it was very simple. My gender marker was changed as well, which I thought was supposed to be blank, but the clerk just  put F on my passport.
  •  

Jennygirl

I had no issues going to Korea and I still haven't legally changed my name yet- traveling solely with passport only. TSA was a breeze, and even homeland security on the way back was more than polite. They were REALLY nice. They gave me a hard time when I used to present male. Now I guess they don't see me as a threat to our nation as a female... lol
  •  

Cindy

Quote from: Jennygirl on June 07, 2013, 04:09:35 AM
I had no issues going to Korea and I still haven't legally changed my name yet- traveling solely with passport only. TSA was a breeze, and even homeland security on the way back was more than polite. They were REALLY nice. They gave me a hard time when I used to present male. Now I guess they don't see me as a threat to our nation as a female... lol

Sorry for going off topic for a minute. I had a student who was Palestinian, a really nice guy, but he looked just like the archetypical Hollywood terrorist. As he said by the time he shaved the stubble was growing back from where he started!!
He would get bailed up in every airport. He went to Singapore for a holiday and they wouldn't let him out of the airport.

All because he looked like a character from a movie. Ahh I think security services need a reality check sometimes!!!

  •  

Jennifer Snowskier

Hi Cindy,

I wish that changing the gender marker on a birth certificate was as easy as changing one on your passport. The group I belong to in Canberra, (AGA), are concerned that the policy DFAT currently has for gender markers on passports may change after the elections in September. They are urging people to apply for or change their passports before the elections. I don't know how real the concern is but it is probably a good idea.

Cheers

Jen
I dream of a world where a chicken can cross the road without it's motives being questioned.
  •  

Sammy

Quote from: Jennifer Snowskier on June 07, 2013, 03:38:18 AM
Hi A and Tristan,

Yes I normally carry two or three forms of photo ID. However the type of card that Lara is talking about in Germany is for transgendered people.

http://www.dgti.org/images/Bilder/ergaus_hinten.jpg

The link is for the English translation on the card. I think its a good idea. From what I can make out from the rough translation on-line the card is for people who are in the process of transitioning and are going through the real life test. Given the volume of "official" documents that we have these days it seems to me that it is a good way to explain why there is a conflict between the information on the document and how the person is presenting. I think this waould be very handy for travelling overseas, a bit like an International Drivers Licence.

Perhaps Lara can give a bit more detail about the ID card.

Cheers

Jen

I am not from Germany, but I find their practice with special ID cards to be a very good example. In addition, if You would google the keywords "human rights and gender identity best practice catalogue" You will find the PDF document "Human Rights and Gender Identity. Best Practice Catalogue" which was published by the Council of Europe, which contains quite a good selection of various national, regional and international standards, as well as examples of best practices all around the world. It might be a bit out-of-date given its date of publishing, but it is very comprehensive nevertheless, given the very slow state of development in this area... It is mostly interesting for lawyers, activists and NGOs, but I am sure everyone can find something interesting there :)

And going back to our topic, on page 22 You can find the sample of the said ID card - it comes in three languages and I will just quote:
"In Germany, Deutsche Gesellschaft für Transidentität und Intersexualität e.V. (dgti), in agreement with the Ministry of Interior, issues Ersatzausweise (alternative identifi cation cards) for trans people who have not changed name and/or gender in accordance with existing legal gender recognition procedures. To qualify for such an ID card, trans people need to: (i) submit an application to dgti, and (ii) provide an initial Gender Identity Disorder diagnosis or proof of commencement of cross-hormonal treatment. The Ersatzausweis has a standard credit card size and comes in three languages (German, English and French). It contains a picture of the cardholder, and relevant personal data including the chosen name. Interestingly, since German ID cards do
not feature a gender marker, the Ersatzausweis does not make a reference to the person's gender either. The validity of the ID card is ensured through a reference to the offi cial identifi cation number and is valid for the same time period as the official card. The text of the Ersatzausweis briefl y explains the purpose and reasons for this alternative ID card."
  •  

smile_jma

Quote from: Jennygirl on June 07, 2013, 04:09:35 AM
I had no issues going to Korea and I still haven't legally changed my name yet- traveling solely with passport only. TSA was a breeze, and even homeland security on the way back was more than polite. They were REALLY nice. They gave me a hard time when I used to present male. Now I guess they don't see me as a threat to our nation as a female... lol

I've been to/from Korea many times alone and when I had shorter hair I had less questioning, but the last 2 times I got mamed to go to the next window (coming back from Korea) I got a bit more questions thrown at me... Keeping in mind when I travel I try to be male. Now I'm going back next month and in July, so we'll see how that goes.
  •  

E-Brennan

Remember what TSA screeners (and overseas screeners) are looking for - things that are a security risk only.  Don't believe any of the silly stories in the media about screeners who are feeling people up or strip searching them - I have found them always 100% professional and focused, and the contents of your underwear (from a genital perspective at least) just does not interest them at all.  Those stories are almost universally set-ups by activists who dislike "government" and think that "freedom" means they should be able to carry whatever they like on a plane, and they have gone out of their way to make a story where no story exists.  If your ID is in order, you're good to go.

Just be smart – if your ID says you're male and you're a presenting as a guy, leave the bra full of wire at home that day. Things like that obviously raise red flags, not because it's someone who looks like a guy wearing a bra and they want to gawk and giggle, but because it warrants further investigation because it could be a guy with a bomb strapped to his chest. Metal near a guy's chest is odd, but near a female's chest, it's normal. The same would apply if your ID says you're female and you're presenting as female, but you have a packer stuffed in your underwear that might be filled with gel.  If they frisk you, it will raise questions because it's something that isn't normally there.

But even if it does raise questions, they really have seen and heard it all before, and just a quick explanation that you're TG/TS would get you through that checkpoint quickly and discretely.  It's not as if they get on the PA system and announce "Supervisor to checkpoint four – we've got a ->-bleeped-<-!" before hauling you off to a room where they put on the rubber gloves and go to town.
  •  

ZoeM

I feel like we should put together some sort of community-sourced book on this stuff - flying, jobs, pitfalls, processes - something lightweight and humorous but also very useful - and publish it.

'The idiot's guide to being transgender', perhaps? With optional stealth flip cover 'the idiot's guide to sports, cars, and hunting' and 'the idiot's guide to makeup, boys, and hair' for the gents?
Don't lose who you are along the path to who you want to be.








  •  

vegie271

Quote from: ZoeM on June 10, 2013, 10:31:36 AM
I feel like we should put together some sort of community-sourced book on this stuff - flying, jobs, pitfalls, processes - something lightweight and humorous but also very useful - and publish it.

'The idiot's guide to being transgender', perhaps? With optional stealth flip cover 'the idiot's guide to sports, cars, and hunting' and 'the idiot's guide to makeup, boys, and hair' for the gents?



There would need to be multiple stealth covers, I live as a stealth woman, I am NOT carrying a book with a cover that says it is a guide to SPORTS cars and hunting that is going to be a dead giveaway, I walk around in skirts with a purse and makeup  ;D

  •  

ZoeM

Quote from: vegie271 on June 10, 2013, 10:48:47 AM


There would need to be multiple stealth covers, I live as a stealth woman, I am NOT carrying a book with a cover that says it is a guide to SPORTS cars and hunting that is going to be a dead giveaway, I walk around in skirts with a purse and makeup  ;D



Hence the flip cover. :)
Don't lose who you are along the path to who you want to be.








  •  

Misato

No problems with the TSA coming out here.
  •