Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Would you do it?

Started by suzifrommd, July 28, 2013, 06:54:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Would you accept a cure that changes your brain to make you cisgender in the body you were born with?

No
Yes

suzifrommd

Suppose someone came up with a cure for transgender that changes your brain to make you cisgendered in the body you were born with. I.e. MtFs become cisgendered males. FtMs become cisgendered females. No more gender dysphoria. Assume that it's painless, risk-free, has no side effects, and keeps all your other skills, faculties and thoughts intact.

Do you do it?
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

MadeleineG

No. Most of my life's accomplishments emerge from the context of negotiating my trans feelings: in music, in school, in work, and even in my marriage.

Maddy
  •  

Misato

Me neither.  Not that I wouldn't be tempted.

In the end, I don't need to change because there's nothing wrong with me or any of us.  I am a trans woman, we're trans people, not a big deal.  It's entities like my employer who are the problem, those who actively make life more difficult for us because they choose to.  But at this point I don't want them to magically change either.  I'd like them to learn their lesson.  Only by learning that you don't discriminate can there be hope that the idea will be knocked out.
  •  

King Malachite

I would do it.  That would save me SO much money in the long run and I wouldn't have to spend it on hormones, doctors, surgery, etc. 
Feel the need to ask me something or just want to check out my blog?  Then click below:

http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,135882.0.html


"Sometimes you have to go through outer hell to get to inner heaven."

"Anomalies can make the best revolutionaries."
  •  

StellaB

No because my life is determined by what lies inside me, not by my body. I'm just as comfortable being transgendered as other people are being cisgendered.
"The truth within me is more than the reality which surrounds me."
Constantin Stanislavski

Mistakes not only provide opportunities for learning but also make good stories.
  •  

Adam (birkin)

A while ago I think I may have said no, but the further along I get...the more the answer is yes. Being trans is horrible. If I could be happy as a woman, I would be.
  •  

Miss Jill Thorn

noway! I'm Female no changing that! sure I have male body but I'm very happy knowing the inner me and accepting me as I am
:-* :-*
  •  

BunnyBee

My mind, which is female, is me.  Replace it with a male mind and you've just murdered me.  I'll fix my body instead, thanks.
  •  

Sara Thomas

Yes.

I'm amazed that many folks believe that being transgendered is a choice... if I could choose, I would choose the path of least resistance.
I ain't scared... I just don't want to mess up my hair.
  •  

Dreams2014

Farewell to my friends, farewell to the life I knew. I burn what once was, and in the ashes I am born anew.
  •  

kelly_aus

Quote from: Jen on July 29, 2013, 12:09:23 AM
My mind, which is female, is me.  Replace it with a male mind and you've just murdered me.  I'll fix my body instead, thanks.

This +1..

Being trans has helped form who I am and I like who I am, as do others.. I'll stick with who and what I am, thanks all the same.


  •  

Sammy

Aww crap, not this question again... Before the HRT, I would say yes, just make me a man and let me forget it all and not bother.
Now, with E in my system a lot of subtle, amazing and wonderful changes have happened, setting me free of mental and emotional shackles which I considered to be some sort of blessing. I was so blind...  No way, I am not going back into that robot mode anymore!
  •  

Dreams2014

Quote from: -Emily- on July 29, 2013, 07:06:37 AM
Aww crap, not this question again... Before the HRT, I would say yes, just make me a man and let me forget it all and not bother.
Now, with E in my system a lot of subtle, amazing and wonderful changes have happened, setting me free of mental and emotional shackles which I considered to be some sort of blessing. I was so blind...  No way, I am not going back into that robot mode anymore!

I wouldn't mind being a robot, just a female one ;)
Farewell to my friends, farewell to the life I knew. I burn what once was, and in the ashes I am born anew.
  •  

~RoadToTrista~

I guess, that solve many many problems.

I don't like the thought of it though. At all.
  •  

Dreams2014

It's dysphoria that plays a large part in who we are. A "cure" sounds to me a lot like a lobotomy.
Farewell to my friends, farewell to the life I knew. I burn what once was, and in the ashes I am born anew.
  •  

Nero

When this question was asked pre-transition I said hell no. When it was asked during transition, same answer. When it was asked a couple years ago, same. Now, I'm not sure. Sometimes I really do wish I could have just been a woman and had the happy ending with a spouse and kids. Now in my mid 30s, the fact I'll never have children (biological at least unless I somehow can do the egg freeze thing) is starting to get to me. That's something dysphoria prevented. There are other things too. I see kids I went to high school with and I'm jealous. That they have a family. A normal life. Obviously this doesn't apply to every trans person as some do have what I'm talking about. But it wasn't possible for me because of the dysphoria. If I were a cis woman, I'd have what I always wanted - normalcy. I never wanted to be a guy or even cared about being masculine - I just was. I never envied men, I envied women. What I really wanted was to be like everyone else. When I was in my teens and early 20s there was nothing I wanted more than to be a normal girl. I think I might have swallowed the pill. 

Not speaking to anyone in particular, but I think there's a tendency in early transition to get swept up in the romance of the whole thing. You're focused on a goal, a physical result and that's all you can see. Meanwhile, while you're doing all this, making all these sacrifices, spending all this money, in some cases enduring physical pain, justifying your life to everyone and the courts - you've got to believe this is all worth it. It's all for some noble cause of being true to yourself. And if you've still got something left to do - the big finish like a surgery or something,  it's all important. Now that that's all behind me, I sometimes really wish I could have just been a cis woman. Sure, I've been true to myself. I'm a dude and now the world knows it. I'm not sure what that's worth anymore.
Nero was the Forum Admin here at Susan's Place for several years up to the time of his death.
  •  

KaylaP

No way, being trans is a part of me, without that part I would cease to be the person I am.
  •  

Renee

In my twenties or even thirties, I'd have said yes, but I don't think so now. I'm happier now than I've ever been, even if I'm broke most of the time and will be alone, except for my doggy, for the rest of my life. So currently, I'd say no thanks.
  •  

Misato

Quote from: Fitter Admin on July 29, 2013, 07:59:10 AM
Not speaking to anyone in particular, but I think there's a tendency in early transition to get swept up in the romance of the whole thing. You're focused on a goal, a physical result and that's all you can see. Meanwhile, while you're doing all this, making all these sacrifices, spending all this money, in some cases enduring physical pain, justifying your life to everyone and the courts - you've got to believe this is all worth it. It's all for some noble cause of being true to yourself. And if you've still got something left to do - the big finish like a surgery or something,  it's all important. Now that that's all behind me, I sometimes really wish I could have just been a cis woman. Sure, I've been true to myself. I'm a dude and now the world knows it. I'm not sure what that's worth anymore.

First, I don't know when it happened but congratulations on the Fitter!

Second I feel the sentiment.  Back round cut over to full time life was so full of promise and hope.  Now that I gotta deal with real discrimination... Yeah, it's hard.  Realizing I'm likely sterile now... Not that I wanted kids but still...  It gets to me as a pretty big deal thing that happened.

I just want a more prevalent live and let live attitude.  I'm sick of, "my religion or politics or morality is right and/or better than yours!" nonsense.  Transition wouldn't be half as bad if more people would just have some compassion.
  •  

Edge

While it would be nice not to have dysphoria, not have to have surgery or take hormones, and to not have to deal with discrimination, I am extremely wary of pills (and other things) that affect my brain.
Also, according to research, gender is related more to the structure of the brain. I am currently unsure of what treatment could change brain structure and think it sounds risky even if it did work.
Edit: Oops I forgot there were things other than pills. Sorry.
  •