Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Thoughts on the Danger of Passing, and Armor (long post warning)

Started by Robin Mack, December 27, 2013, 10:57:59 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Robin Mack

The most insidious thing, I think, about being transsexual is that it isolates us from ourselves and teaches us from the time we are kids that we are alone, that we don't fit in and we believe, as kids, that we never will. We fashion that into a kind of armor made of pain and fury. We learn to separate the real core of us, the "me", from the outside world.

We become child soldiers, training daily. Watching the world like an enemy, we learn its behavior, its differences. We learn how to fit in, camoflauged, as invisible as possible. We punish ourselves for showing our difference, for any time we don't fit in, anything that might give us away. Doing this, we strengthen and maintain our armor until we can bear to function in the outside world. We act "normal". We fit in. We pass. Soon, this armor, this training is a part of us, so perfect that it becomes a part of ourselves. Our own parents don't have a clue that inside this laughing, happy, well-adjusted child is a hurting, wounded creature desperate for love and acceptance.

As we grow up and become "adults", but we tend to hold on to the idea, like it is some kind of universal law that we aren't worthy and we don't fit in and never will. The armor has become a part of us... it has done a good job, keeping us safe through childhood. We've done our part, too, training so perfectly that we have fooled everyone, including ourselves. But there is a cost. That armor that helped us make it through childhood is too small to fit the adult world. So it hurts us. A lot. And keeps us from being able to appreciate or even see the people who are there, ready to accept us. We often fail to notice this because we're accustomed to the pain. Even gentle hugs hurt when your armor is pinching raw nerves.

Some of us realize this, at last, and begin to cut away the armor. It is a dangerous process; we have grown up in it, relied on its strength. It has become a part of us. Lifting the pieces off of our raw, weak skin can sends waves of wicked pain sapping our very souls. Often we have waited until we have no choice, we must remove the armor or die. And, in many cases, it is literally too late, the wounds caused in attempting to remove the armor are mortal. Those of us who remain are often deeply wounded by the process and may take years to recover. Some exchange their armor, piecemeal, for a larger size, because that is all they have known, presenting something closer to their true selves to the world, but remaining isolated, learning to "pass" all over again as something closer to their true selves. Others work hard to remove that armor completely, slowly becoming accustomed to the incredible sensation of a passing gust of kindness or acceptance, and learning how to deal with the pain of rejection or hostility. What emerges then is something beautiful to behold, that rarest of things, a human being true to themselves; open, honest, and prepared to show themselves, weaknesses and all, to the world.

As a final note, while transexual people are perhaps the most obvious example of people transitioning in life, there are others, too, who have to learn how to remove their armor, or, better yet, encouraged so they don't even have to put it on in their childhood. There are so many things that parents try to discourage in their kids, and kids listen all too well. Celebrate their differences and help make the world more welcoming instead of working to make them conform. Armor is a lovely thing for battle, but then children shouldn't have to fight battles, should they?
  •  

suzifrommd

Wow. I love this description of your inner life. I supposed I experienced something similar, knowing I was different but not knowing why.

I'm really lucky. I accepted myself as - whatever I was - and actually learned to love and cherish my "female" elements. I often wonder what I would have been like if I had been raised in a family or a community that had a more rigid and punitive view of how a man should be.
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

Robin Mack

*heh*  Thank you, Suzi... I guess I should have prefaced this with that information.  I know everyone's experience varies; this is my view of the damage that trying to fit in can cause.  I'm thinking about sending it to my mom to help her understand the world better from my eyes.

I'm glad you had a better experience. :)
  •  

peky

Your well composed post so resonates with me...I agree whole hardly with it...

If you may allow me to add.... the constant beatings and berating thought me extreme situational awareness... kind that always have a plan B, and always evaluate every situation and every person... it is energy consuming... never allowing us to fully relax,,,,

In addition to the fury, the stealth, and the armor... there is this "fire in our belly"...a drive to excel, indeed, an urge  to proof them just how much better than them we are.... I often think "fools I'll destroy them" in a hyperbolic way

While I do not think that GID has been a blessing on my life -more of a curse if anything- it has shaped me in no minor way, and much of my professional and personal success is due to the powers of observance, intuition, self reliance, ingenuity, sensitive, awareness, discipline, etc., instilled in me by the GID.

yet, in a way I remain a wounded child inside... abandon, neglected, unwanted...
  •  

insideontheoutside

Good metaphor with the armor. I had a pretty happy childhood up to a certain point because I was allowed to be myself as much as possible. But looking back, that made my mom pulling the rug out from under me during the pre-teen years that much more horrible. She tried to force me to be something I obviously wasn't on top of giving me lecture after lecture of how a "female" is supposed to look and act in society. By age 12 I'd already developed my natural mannerisms and personality and that was definitely male. So it was confusing and felt like an invalidation of who I really was. But instead of conforming, that just made me rebel even harder against "the system" and a society who wanted to put me in a box I didn't fit in. My mom continued to pass me off to friends and relatives and the rest of society as a, "tom boy" and kept telling me I would, "grow out of it". The only "act" I had to put on was to be "female" in the sense that I had a female name and there was an "F" on my birth certificate. So I went through life with people addressing me that way (except for people who didn't know me, who more often than not, thought I was male because of how I looked). So my armor was very light, and I grew into it no problem. When I started to add to it, was when others wanted to get physically close to me. I got a full metal suit when it comes to that!
"Let's conspire to ignite all the souls that would die just to feel alive."
  •  

Ms. OBrien CVT


  
It does not take courage or bravery to change your gender.  It takes fear of living one more day in the wrong one.~me
  •  

Jamie D

Your "armor" I called my "shell."  A safe place.  I was not so much the "warrior" as the "watchman."  Ever vigilant.  Ever guarded.
  •  

Tessa James

Thank you Robin and friends for that perfect prose and metaphors for our journey.  Thank you too for acknowledging the many other transitions that kids especially need our support to negotiate.

Those other transitions and challenges can be every bit as important as our usual trans elephant in the living room.  We can be better parents and listen to the voices of children allowed to be themselves.

Amour is great as a dusty museum piece but too heavy and inflexible for most children ;)

What a huge relief then to put those shields down?
Open, out and evolving queer trans person forever with HRT support since March 13, 2013
  •  

Robin Mack

Quote from: peky on December 27, 2013, 01:18:41 PM
In addition to the fury, the stealth, and the armor... there is this "fire in our belly"...a drive to excel, indeed, an urge  to proof them just how much better than them we are.... I often think "fools I'll destroy them" in a hyperbolic way

There was for me, for a while, but it didn't last... I guess I got tired and depressed and decided to retire from the battlefield.  Oddly, as I transition, I'm finding embers of that fire... I'm hoping as I progress I can fan the flames to excel again, this time as the woman I was meant to be.  Success seemed hollow when I wasn't myself.

Quote from: peky on December 27, 2013, 01:18:41 PM
yet, in a way I remain a wounded child inside... abandon, neglected, unwanted...

I think many of us do... I know I do.  One night I cried myself to sleep in a melancholy way, because inside myself I visualized adult me reaching out to and comforting the child me before she had to learn how to hide.  It might sound odd, but it granted me some peace to know that, despite my failings, I wouldn't leave a child to suffer that way.

Quote from: insideontheoutside on December 27, 2013, 01:19:26 PM
Good metaphor with the armor. I had a pretty happy childhood up to a certain point because I was allowed to be myself as much as possible. But looking back, that made my mom pulling the rug out from under me during the pre-teen years that much more horrible. She tried to force me to be something I obviously wasn't on top of giving me lecture after lecture of how a "female" is supposed to look and act in society. By age 12 I'd already developed my natural mannerisms and personality and that was definitely male. So it was confusing and felt like an invalidation of who I really was. But instead of conforming, that just made me rebel even harder against "the system" and a society who wanted to put me in a box I didn't fit in. My mom continued to pass me off to friends and relatives and the rest of society as a, "tom boy" and kept telling me I would, "grow out of it". The only "act" I had to put on was to be "female" in the sense that I had a female name and there was an "F" on my birth certificate. So I went through life with people addressing me that way (except for people who didn't know me, who more often than not, thought I was male because of how I looked). So my armor was very light, and I grew into it no problem. When I started to add to it, was when others wanted to get physically close to me. I got a full metal suit when it comes to that!

I wonder if this is a societal difference (generality warning) in the upbringing of FTM and MTF people.  I know the consequences of showing emotions or being at all effeminate growing up were pretty dire for me, but my older two daughters were pretty much tomboys from the time they could choose their own activities and dress themselves, and for them it was no big deal socially, at least until high school. 

Quote from: Ms. OBrien CVT on December 27, 2013, 01:35:23 PM
Absolutely a fabulous view of being transsexual.

*blush*  Thank you. :)

Quote from: Jamie D on December 27, 2013, 01:44:49 PM
Your "armor" I called my "shell."  A safe place.  I was not so much the "warrior" as the "watchman."  Ever vigilant.  Ever guarded.

That's an excellent metaphor, too... thank you.
Quote from: Tessa James on December 27, 2013, 01:50:08 PM
Those other transitions and challenges can be every bit as important as our usual trans elephant in the living room.  We can be better parents and listen to the voices of children allowed to be themselves.

Amour is great as a dusty museum piece but too heavy and inflexible for most children ;)

What a huge relief then to put those shields down?

Hallelujah!  :)  If only it didn't hurt so much...

  •  

JulieBlair

Yes I learned to defend myself, to build walls, to weld armor, to focus on achievement. To never ever let anyone see that I was scared, a fake, and a fraud.  And so I wasted more years than I care to admit.  The last couple of weeks I keep having the song "Somewhere" from West Side Story running amok in my brain.  It gives me comfort although I wish I could turn down the volume sometimes.  Regardless, I know for sure that there is a place and time for all of us if we choose, and have the courage to take the necessary risks. 

If I continue to stay safe, I will not grow, not become the woman, friend, person that I so much crave to be.  It is still scary though, and I am grateful you are all here when I need a shoulder to lean or to cry on.  Sometimes I make a complete mess of things, and sometimes I can only laugh at my blunders.  So it goes....
Peace
I am my own best friend and my own worst enemy.  :D
Full Time 18 June 2014
Esprit can be found at http://espritconf.com/
  •  

Miss_Bungle1991

#10
Quote from: Robin Mack on December 27, 2013, 10:57:59 AM
There are so many things that parents try to discourage in their kids, and kids listen all too well. Celebrate their differences and help make the world more welcoming instead of working to make them conform. Armor is a lovely thing for battle, but then children shouldn't have to fight battles, should they?

I loved your entire post, but I wanted to give my take on this point, in particular.

I NEVER listened to my parents when they discouraged me from doing most things (the only exception was the cross-dressing because I had no choice) but I think, as a result of that it made me fight that much harder for other things that I wanted to do and be in to. It created some pretty intense conflicts between my parents and myself but there was no way in hell I was backing down on anything else. No matter if it was the music I was listening to, my refusal to play sports (because my dad wanted me to his little jock to 'toughen me up'), or discouraging me from reading up on the darker elements of human nature because they found it to be 'odd'.
  •  

insideontheoutside

Quote from: Robin Mack on December 27, 2013, 02:00:35 PM
I wonder if this is a societal difference (generality warning) in the upbringing of FTM and MTF people.  I know the consequences of showing emotions or being at all effeminate growing up were pretty dire for me, but my older two daughters were pretty much tomboys from the time they could choose their own activities and dress themselves, and for them it was no big deal socially, at least until high school. 

Oh I think you're right that, in general, it's more socially accepted for female bodied people to be "tom boys" as kids, than it is for male bodied people to have any sort of feminine traits as kids. And that's still something that's going on to this day. However, there seems to be a slight amount of shift at least to "gender neutral" or even some cross over. It just requires people to take a stand as well as make a statement. And by people, I mostly mean parents. If a little boy shows an interest in dressing up, or asking for a barbie doll or something, the adults shouldn't auto-label that boy "gay" or "effeminate" or having some form of gender issue. Kids are influenced by both adults and other children but that's not to say they don't start formulating their own personality very early on. The whole reason why so many of us have that suit of armor is because adults were telling us something was "bad", or we would experience "dire consequences" if we expressed ourselves certain ways.

It's not the children that need taught to be themselves, it's the adults that need taught to not imprint their bias and prejudices and stereotypes on their children.
"Let's conspire to ignite all the souls that would die just to feel alive."
  •  

Nero

This is such a beautiful post Robin. And I think it could resonate with people going dealing with all kinds of childhood issues - trans children, abused children, etc.

Quote from: Robin Mack on December 27, 2013, 02:00:35 PM

I wonder if this is a societal difference (generality warning) in the upbringing of FTM and MTF people.  I know the consequences of showing emotions or being at all effeminate growing up were pretty dire for me, but my older two daughters were pretty much tomboys from the time they could choose their own activities and dress themselves, and for them it was no big deal socially, at least until high school. 


Well, there are definitely differences. A young trans girl's experience may be more brutal and literal with expression and such literally beat out of her. Society is just a lot less lenient where 'male' children expressing any shred of femininity are concerned.

Even so, I identified very much with your words. I've often said transition was like shedding my armour. And I'm still dealing with that. I feel much more vulnerable than I did before. Maybe even more protective. I'm possibly in even more of a shell than before transition. Maybe it's a reflex action of finding myself 'naked' where I wasn't before. I never felt vulnerable as a female. But for some reason I feel that way now. Like the mask and shell is gone and everyone can see everything. Sometimes I just want to crawl back under the mask.
Nero was the Forum Admin here at Susan's Place for several years up to the time of his death.
  •  

Ms Grace

Beautiful, thanks Robin. In addition, in my experience, every time I wasn't allowed to be with and/or play along with the girls during my childhood a little bit of my soul was cut out.
Grace
----------------------------------------------
Transition 1.0 (Julie): HRT 1989-91
Self-denial: 1991-2013
Transition 2.0 (Grace): HRT June 24 2013
Full-time: March 24, 2014 :D
  •  

Rachel

Bookmarked!

Well done, I have a wall and darkness but no armor.
HRT  5-28-2013
FT   11-13-2015
FFS   9-16-2016 -Spiegel
GCS 11-15-2016 - McGinn
Hair Grafts 3-20-2017 - Cooley
Voice therapy start 3-2017 - Reene Blaker
Labiaplasty 5-15-2017 - McGinn
BA 7-12-2017 - McGinn
Hair grafts 9-25-2017 Dr.Cooley
Sataloff Cricothyroid subluxation and trachea shave12-11-2017
Dr. McGinn labiaplasty, hood repair, scar removal, graph repair and bottom of  vagina finished. urethra repositioned. 4-4-2018
Dr. Sataloff Glottoplasty 5-14-2018
Dr. McGinn vaginal in office procedure 10-22-2018
Dr. McGinn vaginal revision 2 4-3-2019 Bottom of vagina closed off, fat injected into the labia and urethra repositioned.
Dr. Thomas in 2020 FEMLAR
  • skype:Rachel?call
  •