Cool topic idea! Self love is always good.
Most of my traits would probably be considered "unmanly." At first I scrambled to change them, of course- but I've come to realize that they're part of my personality and who I am, regardless of whether or not they originated from female socialization.
Let's see...
When someone says something surprising, I touch my hand to my chest or my face.
My voice is super high and I have very feminine inflections (examples: raising my voice at the end of a statement of question, slight- emphasis on slight- vocal fry).
Most guys seem to be a bit relatively stoic and laid-back. I tend to be very animated and "bouncy," which is usually associated with femininity.
I hate all things sports- watching, playing. I am one of the most hopelessly unathletic people I know.
Zero knowledge or interest when it comes to most "manly" activities- changing tires, construction, killing bugs, etc.
I like to write and draw.
Unafraid to cry during movies. Or anytime, really (within reason).
I'm attracted to guys. Some people would consider this inherently unmanly.
I second Elijah on using organic home products for a beauty regimen. I'm borderline obsessed with all that.
I'm really into men's fashion and haircare.
I'm a vegan. For some reason eating red meat is seen as "manly."
I get terrified watching, seeing or hearing anything remotely scary (as a kid I had nightmares for weeks after seeing a Scooby Doo Movie). Some might label me a huge sissy.
And I agree, musicals and disney movies are awesome