Since this is the longest and most detailed thread I think I'll add my posts to this until I get mine in the mail.
1) I was originally hoping that someone would post a review of just the 2 in 1. Surely someone has bought that. That would give more insight and help compare for folks that really just want to pack and pee and will use something else for play. Especially since the silicone is totally different. Surely that has some impact on the compressability while in shorts and heck could be more helpful when adjusting for peeing.
Perhaps the owners should do more detailed videos.
2) I hope any future reviewers can give more information on their body type, and strategy used for peeing and whether or not they purchased this for primarily using it at the urinal vs wanting to be able to stand in the toilet stall (which is what I want. I have less interest in the urinal). I would always hate to put up a rating or outright say something isn't good when this is such a personal item. What works for my large body will not likely work for someone significantly smaller, and then how everyone's junk is situated is also important and the size of that (like the flesh around the penis) is important in using an STP. I myself, have quite a bit of flesh and fat down there where someone else may virtually have nothing significant other than their penis. We would use the device differently.
3) Since I haven't found reviews of the 2 in 1 and most of the 4 in 1 reviews are from folks that seem much smaller bodied than myself (as evidenced by folks saying the cup of the pee portion is too big or saying that they are a smaller bodied guy), I figure that the cup may actually work for me.
I'm 5'9" and 250# so, a firm silicone penis doesn't usually look like a boner on me and the STPs with the small spoons just do not work.
I've always wanted to try something with a larger receptacle and would like to see how much any body issue stuff would be reduced if I really had 1 prosthetic that could be used all of the time (but wasn't as exp as RM!!!).
So, I've been scouring their clearance section and today bought the 4 in 1 Rogue 5.5 (I'm chocolate colored and so this wait was much longer than I was happy with!!!). It was $139 today and was made for taking pictures so should have 0 issues.
While, I am not happy that their price keeps changing...I'm glad I'm not spending tooooo much for it. Like my other STP was like 50-60$, is not as large and I wouldn't use it for sex at all. So, 139$ for something that has more functionality if my body type works for it, is okay. But I would not buy it at the $189 price point or the $200 for the 6.5 (which is the size I really wanted but a sale is a sale!).
Once I get it I will give my review. I do have another 3 in one and 2 simple packers to compare things to.