Thanks for the replies. I paid with a credit card, and I ordered several individual items, not the monthly surprise box. I have already emailed them with my order number, and they replied that they would look into it and get back to me the following day. They did not get back to me the next day. I emailed them again after a week. They replied that they "had to search through a million boxes and we were able to find bits and pieces of the order," but they were out of stock on one item. I wrote back that the one item out of stock was no big deal. Then a week later I wrote again. But they stopped responding. Their last email to me was two weeks ago. And now I see that they are out of stock on more items I ordered. So this is why I was wondering if my order was legitimately lost by innocent mistake, or if this is their standard practice.