I swear I have been obsessed with FNAF since the initial wave of hype last August (when all the Youtubers boosted it's popularity).
I played FNAF1 in November, 2 on the same day (on release), 3 on release also. Only 1 scared me at all. The second one now has over 16 hours racked up on Steam (Yep, 16) and the 3rd one is just boring, in my opinion. There is no strategy, it's just luck and every new feature is an inconvenience rather than an interesting mechanic. I have never been scared of animatronics, though...probably why I find them fun time-wasters rather than good for that 'horror game feel'.
Hoping for the release of plushies, I would love ones of Foxy and Mangle (Is that possible, though? Mangle is basically 90% scrap metal...).