you've got a very good point. what you're saying is basically referencing to the situationism theory in psychology:
QuoteIt refers to an approach to behavior which holds that general traits do not exist (perhaps apart from Intelligence). Behavior, then, is seen as being influenced by external, situational factors rather than internal traits or motivations.
situationism, or the situational learning theory, is a theory on identity. basically, it suggests that our behaviour and personality as human beings is regulated by our external environments, meaning that we don't actually have a fixed identity. according to the theory, our behaviour and personality, and therefore identity, changes with each situation we find ourselves in. for instance, the popular example "one acts differently at work than at a party with friends" demonstrates situationism, and is therefore used as proof by individuals supporting the situational learning theory.
so yes, to apply this theory to gender identity, it is completely possible that gender is not at all consistent, and that the nouns one uses to label oneself are "a form of prison" and that a more accurate method of defining oneself is through verbs, as they are more flexible.
even though i don't put much stock in psychology, i agree that using verbs is a better method of describing oneself than nouns.
- jackson