Hi there, Runaway! I went with the CTA because I figured, why not? lol I desperately needed the trach shave anyway, and others on here who had the CTA with Haben sounded great to me. I don't sing(except in my car or during Rockband gaming) or play any instruments. From what I've read, the CTA isn't so much to raise the pitch, as to kill the ability to drop the voice down into chest voice. My understanding is that the sutures and cartilage kinda stretch over the recovery period anyway, so you lose some of the pitch increase. But you still retain that inability to drop it low. I would have an issue with my voice dropping low when I was tired or, haha, drunk! lol So, I figured I should probably go with the full monty cuz he was going in there for the trach shave anyway and it was being thrown in anyway. Haben did mention that the CTA procedure forces the larynx cartilage forward more, which makes the adam's apple jut out more. He said he would shave as much as he could so that this wouldn't be a problem. Immediately after surgery, my neck was flat! And even after much of the swelling has gone down and the skin has tightened up around my larynx, it's still damn flat. XD
I'm not sure how much the CTA contributes to this, but when I now try to "talk from my chest", I only succeed in sounding like a woman trying to imitate a man. lol VFS is frickin awesome.

I was discouraged at times during the healing process and with some of the difficulty that I had finding my new voice, but now that somet ime has passed and I've experimented and gotten to a comfortable speaking arrangement with between my diaphragm, larynx, and head, I'm so very happy with my results.