Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

A Difficult Difference: Changing Genders and Coming Into One's Self

Started by NicholeW., December 11, 2007, 08:38:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

NicholeW.

This is a sort of answer to a question Alice asked in a different thread. I hope it isn't too inflammatory, it is toned-down from what I first thought about. But, I also hope it gives some of us time to think about what we are doing when we transition.

Quote from: Alice on December 11, 2007, 07:04:15 PM
Quote from: Nichole W. on December 11, 2007, 06:36:35 PM

A full life requires sadness and sorrow, joy and elation, peace and calm and noise and storms. It's all-of-a-piece, Kate. You deserve a full life. The alternative is to remain in so many ways right where you were before, except now with a body that is female rather than male. I have watched others do that. You don't wanna be where they went, sweetie.



Can you expand on this Nichole. For someone who is about to start the process - how do people just change their bodies but stand still? I guess you mean do no be caught up on what our old male selves enjoyed.

Alice

I can write a book about your question, but I don't think it is quite as 'beautiful and compassionate' sounding as what I wrote to Kate. And it could well lead to someone being hurt by what I might write, so i will just sit on that.

I do appreciate your kind words. Thanks.

I can say it isn't about your superficial likes and dislikes: football or horseshoes, the color blue or pink.

Its about attitude and expectation of what life is and will be like. In underworld we mostly just thought about our alienation from ourselves and from others. We didn't always notice so much the attitudes and expectations we had been raised with because we had penises.

Above-ground one HAS to be aware of those. And the learning curve is steep and vital. It is not fair or right that men and women are treated differently in culture. But, it is a fact of our lives. Some trans-women as they transition don't see the attitude change. It's not about being dominant or submissive. But it's all about power over and its prerogatives.

Its like most white people don't think about race and the ramifications of it. That is probably why so many talk, at least in private, about 'reverse-discrimination.' They don't get it because they haven't had to get it. It really doesn't affect them a whole lot. A dominant class never sees the world quite like a subject-class sees it. And the subject-class often speaks and acts with other members of the subject-class in a different voice than they do with members of the dominant class.

Thus, the book. It can probably be written, but it wouldn't be well-read or liked by many. The same way second-wave feminism was not understood, even by many women who were victims of what second-wave was trying to change. Victims often identify with their victimizers moreso than they do with other victims.

Some transitioned women become very withdrawn and alienated even in female bodies, because what they thought about being female was not what the reality turned out to be.

I spoz the answer is rather vague, kinda like that Chinese Buddhist monk who achieved enlightenment and was asked what had changed. What had he done before he was enlightened? "I chopped wood and carried water."  And what did he do now in enlightenment? "I chop wood and carry water."

Ah, but the whole perspective was different and that's where things get murky for many. They just cannot see the difference.

I hope that helps, Alice. It's the best I can do without becoming inflammatory, I think.

Hugs,

Nichole
  •  

TheBattler

Thanks Nichole,

I guess you are saying to change your expectation to meet reality. There are certain things expected of a female person and we must find them out to fit in better.

So what expectation do I have to change and do I need HRT to change my outlook? I was thinking I do not have many expectations except it will be har do be accepted as female. I am doing this to hopfully make my life better.

Alice
  •  

natalie

the internal work of transitioning. becoming comfortable with one self, being strong, being real. is where all the difficulty is for me.

the physical part of transitioning, is relatively easy in comparison.
and if i'm not comfortable and whole before i transistion. afterwards, still the same issues will haunt me...
  •  

Dennis

QuoteAbove-ground one HAS to be aware of those. And the learning curve is steep and vital. It is not fair or right that men and women are treated differently in culture. But, it is a fact of our lives. Some trans-women as they transition don't see the attitude change. It's not about being dominant or submissive. But it's all about power over and its prerogatives.

Its like most white people don't think about race and the ramifications of it. That is probably why so many talk, at least in private, about 'reverse-discrimination.' They don't get it because they haven't had to get it. It really doesn't affect them a whole lot. A dominant class never sees the world quite like a subject-class sees it. And the subject-class often speaks and acts with other members of the subject-class in a different voice than they do with members of the dominant class.

This is really well put, Nichole. I don't think anyone can understand gender dynamics quite as well as someone who's lived on both sides. Most of those who are seen as men don't have a grasp of male privilege and how it infuses every small interaction unless they've lived part of their adult lives appearing female. It was an eye-opener for me going to male privilege, even though I had experienced a lack of it. It must be equally or more surprising for people transitioning to female who suddenly lose it.

It's made me think about how, despite my best efforts, I will probably never really grasp race privilege or many of the other privileges I have through no virtues of my own.

Dennis
  •  

NicholeW.

Quote from: Alice on December 11, 2007, 09:13:52 PM
Thanks Nichole,

I guess you are saying to change your expectation to meet reality. There are certain things expected of a female person and we must find them out to fit in better.

So what expectation do I have to change and do I need HRT to change my outlook? I was thinking I do not have many expectations except it will be har do be accepted as female. I am doing this to hopfully make my life better.

Alice

No, Alice, I don't think you NEED have HRT in order that your outlook changes. O, it might help, if it can free enough of the maddening male synapses for you to grow in a different way than you have been trained to grow.

IMO, it is NEVER about the superficial: brow-bossing or scalp-advances, saline or silicone implants. That stuff is, like a lot of our concerns about body, window-dressing for the soul. No one, imo, is 'naturally' a woman after years of being conditioned as a male. She has to have paid attention during that time -- like the monk chopping wood after enlightenment. He was paying attention afterwards. He was simply chopping wood. He wasn't chopping wood and considering what clothes he wanted to purchase at Saks so he could 'look female.'

There is a deep resonance for women within relationship. No, it isn't an essential difference. Males have it as well. It's a conditioned difference though in how we approach it, live in it. Males generally don't have much consideration for relational depth and texture. They needn't. For generation after generation they have expected and gotten relationship from women while they tended to the 'important' things: umm warfare and football and lotsa beer and being strong!! *smile*

And with women its different. We have spent many years, many generations in a 'subject' state. As I said in the other post, dominants and subjects invariably see a different world from one another. When I have been trained to see the world from a dominant perspective, there is so much that is small and delicate and crucial that I don't see, because I don't have to see it. Don't have to hold it as something that matters most in the core of my heart.

So to get that learning, to be a woman, you and I must keep the eyes of our hearts open. We must see what it is that we never saw before. Then we must be open to it, incorporate that. It is all well and good to be pretty, but women get pretty to be accepted in relation, in connection. Sometimes with men and sometimes with each other. We hold what men would often ignore as being unimportant: the quality of just listening without a need to break loose like a bull in a china shop to be "honest."

Honesty, you see, is admitting to oneself that what is core is relationship. That quality of having a web that you are part of, intimately. Your understanding of your place in that web and how important that place is, to you and to all the other ten thousand things.

Buddhists and Hindus have an idea called Indra's Net. I think of it as basically universe and all we experience among ourselves, together and separate. In Indra's Net there are jewels that form the net, many-faceted jewels, and each jewel reflects each other jewel, billions and trillions of them. The reflections form the mesh of the net. And from that net, nothing ever escapes.

We are caught in Indra's Net, Alice. But, in the ways we are raised men are not called upon to see that net. They do not realize it is the core of themselves. The reason, if you will, that we even exist. We exist for relation. Without it, children 'fail to thrive' and die. Without it, adults wither and die as well, generally causing much sorrow and suffering for themselves and others along the path to death.

No. 'Passing' for women is not a superficial thing alone. It is a heart-thing, a soul-thing, Alice. When I refuse to be blatantly and brashly "honest" what I refuse is to come out of relationship, because to do so will kill me. For, you see, there is a greater and much more vital honesty than just blathering away my egocentric notions about someone or something.

That honesty is that without that I could well die, and I will probably be very hurt at the least. Honesty is admitting into myself my own need and the richness that fulfillment of that need brings me. A richness so bright and so good that when I get it, I want more of it. So rich that when I get more of it it fills me and overflows to others as well. So that there is eventually more and more relationship. Strega Nona's spaghetti pot. *smile*

In Under-world I think we all have hurt. But, if one pays attention she can thrive outside of Under-world. She can pass. No, it's not about being submissive. It's about being attentive. To oneself and to others. It is about honesty and the eyes, the heart. It is not about make-up and surgeries and how I dress or do not.

Someone, many someones, have remarked that 'men take up a lot of space.' Yep, they do seem to. But, I have come to the realization that they take that exterior space because they are never much trained to fill their interior space. Self-efficacy requires that we fill our spaces, that we very literally 'live into ourselves.' And therein lies the largest difference in being male and being female it seems to me.

Being human requires social intelligence, we are drawn to that from the moment we enter the world through the womb, even before, in the womb. Yet, social and cultural conditioning has allowed about half of us to be trained out of that relationality from the time we are very young.

Men and women aren't from Mars and Venus. They are each from Earth. We are so much alike in our natural state that we cannot live without the interactions of each other. Yet, some of us believe that we can do so. That is what we have been trained to believe. That some are valuable and that others are less so. It's a lie meant to deceive ourselves. Deceive ourselves into believing that we can live without each other. That some are born to greatness and others born to serve.

So that is where you must go, I think, Alice. You must go to that place in yourself where the true and only you resides and you must free her. So much more to 'presentation' than a walk, a voice, looks, the shape of a jaw or the lie of hair on the head. So very much more.

 

 
  •  

Ms Bev

Nichole.  If you ever do write that book, I'll buy a copy.  Please autograph it, hmm?

Beverly
1.) If you're skating on thin ice, you might as well dance. 
Bev
2.) The more I talk to my married friends, the more I
     appreciate  having a wife.
Marcy
  •  

Hypatia

You're so right, Nicole. That was very beautifully expressed.

For me, that feeling of relating to others the way women do had always been within me, suppressed but dying to blossom into full expression. So to transition to womanhood meant finally giving my natural inclinations a chance to live. What a relief!
Here's what I find about compromise--
don't do it if it hurts inside,
'cause either way you're screwed,
eventually you'll find
you may as well feel good;
you may as well have some pride

--Indigo Girls
  •  

TheBattler

Quote from: Hypatia on December 13, 2007, 04:04:53 PM
You're so right, Nicole. That was very beautifully expressed.

For me, that feeling of relating to others the way women do had always been within me, suppressed but dying to blossom into full expression. So to transition to womanhood meant finally giving my natural inclinations a chance to live. What a relief!

I am now free to express my emotions which is helping so much. I told a lot of my triathlons friends last night I was going onto HRT and again just felt relieved - they had seen me struggle and where very understanding.

Hopfully I will the same as you Hypatia.

And Nicole - thanks for what you wrote.

Alice
  •