I stayed up until 3:00 AM last night writing an all too lengthy and TL:DR reply to this question but then decided not to post it because my experiences were so different and it might be upsetting to some? Taking a fresh look at this today and having a bit of a re-think about it all I've decided to go ahead and post it anyway just to show the variety of differences we all have when it comes to this trans business. Trans kids, openly trans kids are a rarity on this site and I think it's somewhat important our side of these stories are heard because we have some place in all this too._______________________
The idea of getting caught wearing girl's clothes is an odd question for me. I couldn't say how loudly I wanted to wear nothing but girl's clothes and it became a real issue for me in the 1st and 2nd grade until my mom sat me down one day and explained the reality of the situation to me.
Damn. This is making me think of things I haven't thought about in a long time and I just noticed I'm frowning. These were hard times.I understood myself to be a girl. I didn't want to be different from other girls. I mean I knew why I wasn't a girl because of my body but I just was a girl because that's who I was. I understood logically but I really didn't understand.
I recently posted in another thread talking about getting clothes for Christmas and how after I was 15 or so that I had clothes for school and girl's clothes that were too feminine to wear to school and I didn't really think about it until just now but I had the same sort of thing going on my first couple years of grade school too.
I had accumulated a lot of my two older girl cousin's clothes and thought nothing of wearing them casually or just as an everyday sort of thing. When they'd come over I couldn't wait to swap clothes with them and rarely gave them back. It was seen as peculiar but no one really cared as I had always been different. It was just expected that I was going to do this and I did it into my tweens. After that they just gave me stuff. In my box of dress up clothes we used for playing house when my cousins came over there were a couple old housedresses you couldn't keep me out of too so when I did start school, I was very unhappy with how awkward and uncomfortable wearing real boys clothes made me feel and even more dismayed at even being thought of as a boy at all.
I had never been treated like a boy and I had never been like them and I had a very difficult time fitting into the world as one of them. This was clearly obvious. There's kind of a dark spot in my memory between the 2nd and 3rd grade because I was in a pretty dark and unhappy place, had already been in 4 different schools because I was so different and out of place and this whole thing of not being like other girls and what I could and couldn't wear came to a head and that's when my mom sat me down for a bit of reckoning.
I really don't remember the details of all the talks we had or even what I really said but we came to some kind of an understanding with compromises during that summer. In return for not wanting to wear girl's clothes all the time, my demands were met and I was allowed to grow my hair out. To me, this was a fair trade off and in the end, signaled to the world that I was a girl and made me more physically like other girls than girl's clothes ever could have anyway.
This pacified me for a bit. It was still common to wear my cousins clothes at home or my play clothes or be seen clonking around in an old pair of my mom's high heels and this was never something I had to do in secret so I made the mental adjustment that I just had to wear boy's clothes to make the rest of the world happy. It was just clothes but I still knew who I was and what I liked and wanted to wear so there was still a lot of arguing and uncomfortable feelings.
Over the next few years as my hair got longer and my problems in school only got worse, by the time I was 12 and started junior high, people that didn't know I was supposed to be a boy didn't know what I was. I had been in 14 different schools by the time I finished 6th grade because the rest of the world
wasn't happy with me and boy's clothes didn't seem to really make a difference. Adherence to the binary and gender conformity was expected but I never felt that applied to me and I didn't know how to act or be different anyway.
Regardless, I had managed to find a balance point in between being a boy or a girl and
that pacified me for a bit. At home, I was still borrowing clothes from my cousins and even had some old stuff that my mom didn't wear and as long as we weren't going anywhere, it was no big deal to wear them as just a regular thing. There was no fear of getting caught because there wasn't anything to hide or sneak around about. My folks teased me about it a bit but they teased me about everything always with humor and love. My individuality and apparent queerness was concerning and problematic but respected. We had a lot of talks about being gay especially after my 8th grade crush on a neighbor boy I went to school with ended rather dramatically and for a while, I just let them think I was gay because it made things easier and more peaceful. I mean, why else would I be acting and trying to look like a girl if I wasn't gay, right? We were all so ignorant.
At 15 in the 10th grade, unfortunate events set things in motion and I sat my folks down and had a bit of reckoning with them. I simply refused to keep living my life as a boy and my difficulty in doing so had become more than evident so there were more understandings and more compromises. I could be all the girl I was and wanted to be, that didn't matter but I had to stay in school and to do that I had to be a boy. Once again, I reconciled with myself that clothes were just clothes and not who I was and my folks compromised by letting all my clothes be girl clothes as long as they were something that boys
might wear. I also got my ears pierced, my eyebrows professionally shaped at my mom's salon, razors to shave my legs and things that smelled good.
This all happened in 1970 and unisex fashions were a thing then which made things easier but as I got older and after our "understanding", I had a lot more say in what I could wear and how I could look when I wasn't in school so by the time I was 16 people that didn't know I was supposed to be a boy always just assumed I was a girl without them having to think about it or question. My folks and family began to use she/her pronouns because things had become awkward in public and it just made things easier without having to explain I was just weird.
I had girl's clothes for school that passed as boys and I had overtly and unquestionably girl's clothes for when I wasn't in school but no matter what I wore, by the time I was 17 I couldn't have passed as a boy even if I had wanted to. That made school so much fun. I hated life. I hated not just being like other girls even though I had long blonde pretty hair more than halfway down my back some told me they wished theirs was like. I hated I couldn't wear makeup to school or my prettier clothes or different earrings. I loved Saturday nights going out to fancy restaurants for dinner with my folks when we'd dress up a little and my mom would do my hair and I could wear a little makeup and whatever I wanted to wear. I borrowed stuff from my mom all the time and I even had a couple casual tops she borrowed from me occasionally. Having girl things of my own and looking like a girl pacified me for a while.
But this was also about the time things crashed for me. Being socially a girl for all practical purposes but known as the opposite gender five days a week when I had to force myself to go to school became all too much. Bad things happened but as a result, my folks had found me yet another therapist that in a nutshell, took one look at me, put me on HRT and explained to me what transsexualism was. Say what? I guess that made sense and gave me a little more understanding about why I was the way I was so with his guidance and my parent's insistence, I managed to make it through my senior year of high school after which I never had to be known as a boy or wear things because they sort of looked like boy's clothes ever again.
The notion of getting caught cross-dressing in girl's clothes is pretty foreign to me. I was a girl so that was a normal thing to want to do. There was never any shame or embarrassment or hiding or worrying I might get caught doing something I shouldn't be doing. What bothered me more was that at most, all I could do was to wear androgynous things for school. There were some issues though. My aunt got pissed at me for me for having so many of my cousin's clothes and my mom had stuff I knew she'd kill me if I touched. There were raging battles between my mom and I about what I could wear to school because she was more concerned about me getting kicked out of another one and my ideas about what was too girly and hers differed wildly and I was a total raging beyotch about it but somehow my struggles with all this were understood and tolerated. After I graduated and didn't have to be a boy anymore, there was a grand sigh of relief from everyone that this insanity that had been my crazy life had finally come to an end. Even though my boy clothes were really girl's clothes, the ones that weren't girly enough or too androgynous for me went to Goodwill.
My mom died when I was 25. I got all of her clothes, jewelry, good china and purses except her mink stole my aunt wanted that I had no use for anyway. I kept what I wanted and gave the rest to charity. Nearly 40 years later, I still have a few things that were my moms I've kept for sentimental value and her good china still comes out of my hutch for holiday dinners.
Quote from: Susan Baum on December 14, 2018, 02:44:20 PM
7th (and later 10th) grades were torture for me. Because I was compelled to take a PE class those years, I had to revert to boy's briefs and leave my more comfortable underwear at home on weekdays.
Sounds like I wasn't so different after all and I can relate to that. Two days after I was allowed to start school when the whole legal debacle over my long hair got straightened out, I was expelled from 7th grade for fighting a gym teacher that tried to force me into the boy's locker room. I got taken to two different psychologists that were clueless about trans stuff, this was 1967 and they just thought I was super gay but I still ended up getting excused from PE and never had to worry about that sort of thing again.