When I first read this post, I had nothing to contribute. Then I reread it when it reappeared in "unread since last visit".
Sarah I couldn't agree more. You always gain and lose something by upgrading an operating system.
At the risk of going off topic, I proceed cautiously.
I perceive The need for upgrading everything in our lives is a systemic problem in consumerist culture. Yesterday I attended the annual advisory board meeting for the art and music department at a local college, especially focusing on the what level of technological savvy (i.e. digital technology) students should have be they more creative or technological in focus. While discussing the importance of keeping up with new products and technology and the differences between using a piece of gear (or an operating system) and understanding what a piece of gear (or operating system) does and why you would use it over another, one participant mentioned with some futility, that Apple recently announced that it was going to attempt a 14 week life cycle on all its new products.
In other words, every 14 weeks, they are going to attempt to make obsolete, or at least create a perception of obsolete, for their products. You just bought an iPod, and in 14 weeks, they will recently a new iPod that will attempt to make you feel as though your old iPod is no longer good enough. It is a bad enough already to feel compelled to upgrade our operating systems every year or so, but any less seems to me a form of cultural madness.
Yes, anything can be advanced or improved, but as you mentioned Sarah, you always gain and lose something. In this technological arms race, I see less actual improvement and more opportunity for increased corporate profit at our expense, an expense I believe is generally unwarranted, unnecessary, and a form of legalized extortion through emotional manipulation.
While it may not have been your intention Stephanie, beyond the practical reasons for an online service to know what kind of browser and operating system their patrons are using, in my mind you have also inspired potentially intriguing dialogues. Apart from the broader cultural context I have mentioned already, I would also be extremely interested in reading about various attitudes towards technology, capitalism, and modern culture from the point of view of various genders. How do views on these topics vary depending on gender identity? Do you believe your decisions on technology, operating systems, how often to upgrade, etc.. are affected by stereotypical notions of masculine and feminine attitudes? If so, how?
What Operating System indeed! What OS and why?
I currently use Windows XP pro, and have always used Windows, primarily due to financial considerations. However, my personal style and preference would have me choose Apple. Yet rationally I know that choosing between one or the other is little more than an aesthetic issue. In my case one might attribute it to an image or fashion issue, which could be stereotypically considered a more feminine attribute. However, looking beyond the obvious corporate options I also consider switching to open source solutions such as Linux. This for me is an issue of philosophy and progressive economics. I perceive open source solutions as a form of freedom, liberation from corporate consumerist culture. At this point I ponder whether that stems from a more male or female attitude. On one hand I see my vague gender dysphoria and a quest for understanding and acceptance to be a journey to freedom and liberation. Is that male, female, or simply being human?
In regards to ever shrinking product cycles, do you feel compelled to purchase the newest latest thing? For the girls: do you upgrade technology like you might keep up on fashion? For the guys: do you actually feel driven to have the latest gizmo as form of status, even if you recognize that the product life cycle is artificially shortened? For the ambiguous: Do you think your ambigious gender identification affects your decisions on keeping up with the latest and greatest? There are already clues to some of these answers in this topic.
While this may be a stretch, but Stephanie implied that the entire topic might be a stretch, how much do you think your gender identification plays into your decisions about technology (e.g. what Operating System or other software/devices you would use) and how?
While this may seem a bit off topic, I believe various interesting discussions could be born from such a simple question. if this is too far off topic or nebulous, feel free to smite me, and I will pretend that I never had these thoughts.