Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Necessary to tell extended family?

Started by fae_reborn, June 24, 2008, 11:33:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

fae_reborn

I'm not sure if I should tell my extended family about being trans or not.  As a little background, I've been on HRT for a little over a year; been living full-time for 9 months, and live with some friends in an apartment at school, away from home.  My folks are divorced.  Both parents (and dad's girlfriend), my two younger brothers, and two aunts know (one on mom's side, the other on dad's side).  Mom, and her sister (who lives across the country) are having a really hard time with it.  Dad is managing ok, his girlfriend is a big help (she's really supportive of me and helps him see me as his daughter, he's slowly coming around).  Brothers are still in denial.  My other aunt, who's married to my dad's brother, knows and is ok with it, though I didn't tell her directly (Dad did because he needed someone to talk to, I think she knew already because I always acted like another woman around her at family get together's and she accepted that).  Also, my one cousin who I've been friends with since we were really little and playing in the sandbox knows, and is totally ok with it (he's awesome).  His dad, sister, and mother also know and are ok with it but they're concerned.

That leave Mom's brother (who had a stroke last year) and his wife, who live in another state.  Mom's side of the family is small; it's just her, her sister and her sister's husband, her brother and his wife.  That's it.  Everyone else has passed on.

Dad's side of the family, is another story.  He has one brother, who's married to the aunt who knows and they have two young children, age 4 and 8.  Two sisters, who are both married and each have kids (four cousins in total, ranging from 10 to 20 yrs old), and my grandfather (who is our last surviving grandparent).  That's the immediate extended family.  Then there's the extended, extended family.  My dad has countless aunts, uncles, and cousins whom I only see at extended family functions (haven't seen any of them in 5+ years, I get Christmas gifts from one distant aunt and uncle though).  One of dad's cousin's is openly gay and lives with his partner, and one of my cousins also lives with them (she also knows and is ok with it).

It gets really complicated...I think there's somewhere in the range of 50-100 people on dad's side of the family, and some can also be considered to be on mom's side of the family, it's really complicated and I can never figure it out.  Now here's my problem:

1.) I don't want to tell my mom's brother, because his health isn't great, he's getting better since the stroke but I'm afraid if I come out to him he'll relapse from shock.  Same with my grandfather, he's ok health wise, but I'm also afraid the shock would damage his health.

2.) I asked Dad once if he told anyone else (aside from my aunt) in the extended family.  He said he didn't and that it was my responsibility to do so.  But is it??  Am I really under any obligation to tell any of these people, whom I haven't spoken to in a few years and see very rarely?  The last time I've seen most of my immediate extended family was 2 or 3 years ago, but all know I'm going to college.

3.) Once I graduate, I'll be moving to a different state, and it's very unlikely I'll have anything to do with any of my extended family.  I don't know what the social norms are, but frankly I don't believe in huge extended families; they're too complicated.  I want to live my own life and I'm afraid that they'll just shun me if I do come out to them (most are religious; I was partially raised Catholic and now I'm spiritual/pagan  ::)), so why risk that emotional pain?  My friend said that blood is thicker than water, and she also said that you love family no matter what. 

But should I put myself out there for 50-100 people, whom I don't even know that well and don't plan on having as part of my life?  I doubt once my parents pass away (MANY years from now, but still) that I'll have any contact with them.

What should I do?
  •  

Sarah Louise

Its your life.  Tell or not tell.  If your most likely never going to see them what is the purpose.  If they are not part of your life, don't waste time worrying about it.

If you have a family reunion and everyone comes, guess what, it will be obvious, until then live your life.


Sarah L.
Nameless here for evermore!;  Merely this, and nothing more;
Tis the wind and nothing more!;  Quoth the Raven, "Nevermore!!"
  •  

fae_reborn

Quote from: Sarah Louise on June 24, 2008, 11:40:38 AM
If you have a family reunion and everyone comes, guess what, it will be obvious

But in the event of such a reunion (even if it's just my immediate extended family (i.e. my dad's sisters and brother and their families), should I tell them before the reunion?
  •  

Kate

I've told people on an "as needed" basis: neighbors I run into every day, friends, business contacts and relatives whom I routinely see.

The extended family though? Nah, I mean it'd be kinda weird to suddenly call up someone I haven't spoken with in years just to tell them this. Besides, word spreads on it's own anyway. I photographed my niece's wedding last year, and knew I'd be seeing a lot of extended family who I hadn't told... and wondered what was going to happen. But apparently the news had spread to them, as when they saw me, they called me "Kate" and "her" as if it'd always been that way.

The way I figure it, anyone you'd normally call up to tell you got a new job or moved... something like that... probably should know. Otherwise, I'll handle it as it comes up ;)

~Kate~
  •  

fae_reborn

Quote from: Kate on June 24, 2008, 12:24:03 PM
The way I figure it, anyone you'd normally call up to tell you got a new job or moved... something like that... probably should know. Otherwise, I'll handle it as it comes up ;)

Word tends to spread in my family too...last time we all got together, I had been going to college for a semester or two and a lot of my relatives wanted to know how well I was doing in classes and such, what my plans were after school, etc.  I usually don't share most details of my life with my extended family (new job, moving, etc.); it tends to spread around a few months after the fact.  Hopefully this will do the same, and be like your experience Kate.  Hopefully at the next reunion (if I go), people will refer to me as "Jennifer" and "her."  That is my hope...
  •  

Mnemosyne

Extended family found out about me when I attended a funeral. I did not go into detail and hated to be called by the old name but I dressed nicely and made sure my makeup was perfect. No one really knew how to deal with me so I was basically left alone during the services and then at the wake (which I left early). For the record, I do not recommend this method.
  •  

fae_reborn

My aunt (mom's sister) called me tonight and proceeded to "lecture" me, said she was concerned about the choices I've made, and said she wasn't willing to call me Jennifer.  She said I was still her nephew/niece and thinks I'm living somewhere in-between male and female.  She even went so far to say I was "such a good little man" while reminiscing about the past.  That hurt the most.  :'( :'(

I know she doesn't understand (she even said so), but I don't want to educate her.  She says she wants me in her life and wants me to open up to her, but I just don't want to.  She lives across the country and I haven't seen her in 10+ years.  Yeah, she's my aunt, but...I just don't know.  :(
  •  

sneakersjay

I probably won't come out to extended family either, as I'm sure the grapevine will spread like wildfire.  J*******, always the smart, level-headed, quiet one has done WHAT??!??!??!??!??!?

Jay


  •  

tekla

As every teacher knows, you can only 'educate' people who are open to education.  All else is just a waste of time.
FIGHT APATHY!, or don't...
  •  

Dennis

I waited a couple of years then told relatives I was close to (emotionally, not physically - they're in the UK). I told them to use their judgment and feel free to tell any other relatives. Got lots of positive response and no negative response.

Main reason I chose that time to tell them was I kept getting Christmas present cheques in my old name and it was getting a bit awkward at the bank because so much time had passed since I'd used that name.

I didn't tell them earlier because I was concerned that it might be difficult for them to think of me, so far away, having a hard time. By the time I did tell them everything was fine in my life and most of the difficult bits relating to transitioning were behind me.

Dennis
  •  

fae_reborn

Quote from: Dennis on June 25, 2008, 09:13:00 AM
I waited a couple of years then told relatives I was close to (emotionally, not physically - they're in the UK). I told them to use their judgment and feel free to tell any other relatives. Got lots of positive response and no negative response.

Main reason I chose that time to tell them was I kept getting Christmas present cheques in my old name and it was getting a bit awkward at the bank because so much time had passed since I'd used that name.

I didn't tell them earlier because I was concerned that it might be difficult for them to think of me, so far away, having a hard time. By the time I did tell them everything was fine in my life and most of the difficult bits relating to transitioning were behind me.

Dennis

I will probably do the same, thanks Dennis.  I think the reason she's concerned is because she hasn't seen me in so long.  She said she was worried someone would "beat the crap out of me" but I don't think she realizes that I've blossomed into a young, successful woman.  I don't plan on being as open as I used to, and therefore my odds of facing violence are no different than any other woman.  I think if she saw some photos of me she'd understand, but I'll wait until I talk to her some more before sending those.
  •  

jenny_

Quote from: fae_reborn on June 25, 2008, 10:13:08 AM
I will probably do the same, thanks Dennis.  I think the reason she's concerned is because she hasn't seen me in so long.  She said she was worried someone would "beat the crap out of me" but I don't think she realizes that I've blossomed into a young, successful woman.  I don't plan on being as open as I used to, and therefore my odds of facing violence are no different than any other woman.  I think if she saw some photos of me she'd understand, but I'll wait until I talk to her some more before sending those.

My mum said all the same stuff as your aunt, that she thought it'd make life "difficult", and said that I shouldn't expect to be called Jennifer for a long time.  But when she realised that her fears were misguided, she came round and used my name like really soon after.  So you never know, she might come round sooner than you think.

I talked to my mum a lot about telling relatives, which is really useful since she knows all the extended family's ins and outs, and allowing relatives to tell others makes it a lot easier and then you don't have to ring them up out of the blue to come out to them.

And I love your choice of name!  ;)

jenny
x x
  •  

fae_reborn

Quote from: jenny_ on June 25, 2008, 01:28:31 PM
My mum said all the same stuff as your aunt, that she thought it'd make life "difficult", and said that I shouldn't expect to be called Jennifer for a long time.  But when she realised that her fears were misguided, she came round and used my name like really soon after.  So you never know, she might come round sooner than you think.

I talked to my mum a lot about telling relatives, which is really useful since she knows all the extended family's ins and outs, and allowing relatives to tell others makes it a lot easier and then you don't have to ring them up out of the blue to come out to them.

And I love your choice of name!  ;)

jenny
x x

I hope she comes around, thanks Jenny!  ;)
  •