Hi there, Cami.
I know EXACLY where you're coming from. This is my tweezing experience:
I could not stand to have upper lip hair mostly, but could not afford standard removal procedures. One morning, I spent quality time under a good light with a good, fine-point tweezers (being the ex-biologist, I had good surgical micro dissection tweezers), and had been on hrt long enough that it softened my facial hair. Before my shave, I pulled out every single hair. After the first dozen, I self-hypnotized to stand the pain. In about an hour and a half, I had no hair left on my upper lip. It was baby smooth, and remained so for days. Then when they reared their ugly little heads, I pulled them all again, and noticed that it was easier to pull them out. Again, several days later, the same.
On the next round of pulling, there seemed to be fewer hairs, and on each new time, fewer still. Then, after about half a year into tweezing, I was down to about 50 hairs to pull. After another year, I had about 24 persistent hairs, and still do several years later, but now I pluck when I see them about once each 2 weeks, and it is painless.
The more times I pulled them out, the easier it became. They were not as tightly embedded, and became finer. I also started on my chin at this time. There are finer hairs left that I cannot see, and so, yes, I still shave lightly, but my entire face is baby smooth for about 36 hrs.
VERY important.......if you do this, pull slowly in the direction of growth, don't yank! In the past 4 years, I have had one in-grow, and excized it with the same needle-fine forceps, gently squeezed the area, and forgot about it. it made a small pink spot, which was gone in one day.
Okay.....long winded, but that's my experience.
Good luck!
Bev