Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Lower falsetto

Started by Valerie Elizabeth, September 05, 2009, 09:59:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Valerie Elizabeth

So, since having FFS which included a tracheal shave, my falsetto has gotten lower. My throat feels different now. It feels like I am straining to get to falsetto.

Did anyone els experince somehing similar?  Did it go away after a while?  Could I get it back with some work?  After all the swelling goes down (I'm still pretty swollen)?

Any thoughts?
"There comes a point in life when you realize everything you know about yourself, it's all just conditioning."  True Blood

"You suffer a lot more hiding something than if you face up to it."  True Blood
  •  

Myself

How long ago was the shave?
Swelling can, as anyone who ever had a strep throat knows, make your voice different and even lower until the swelling passes.
The shaving procedure can sometime hurt the vocal folds a bit, if you are less than a month after surgery I'd suggest to wait until at least a month or two passes.

Another thing, ask your surgeon, ask a doctor.
  •  

mmelny

It could be the breathing tube too.  I know my throat was hurting for a few weeks from that thing.  One voice surgeon I consulted with said that he wouldn't do surgery on someone that was going to be undergoing general anesthesia within 6 months after, because of the damaging breathing tube, so I guess that has some potential impact on vocal cords.   But this is temporary, and they heal. Not sure that would be applicable for your condition.
  •  

Renate

Apparently different surgeons vary in how aggressively they remove the excess thyroid cartilage.

Possibly some use just a scalpel if the patient is very young and the cartilage is soft. (I'm just guessing.)
Many use "rongeurs", hand-held nippers, to chunk away more hardened cartilage.
Some surgeons use a power burr to grind away the cartilage.

I've never seen a discussion of the esthetic benefits versus risk to the voice of varying degrees of aggressiveness of the surgery.

Does anyone have any references to this matter?
  •  

MMarieN

During my trach shave, the surgeon took off just a bit too much of the thyroid cartilage. This resulted in a collapse of my vocal cords. I was able to talk, but I lost most of my vocal range. I had to go through some pretty extensive voice therapy to get my voice back to a usable level. I never regained my upper registers. And my singing voice is totally shot.

I consider this a minor complication. Overall, I was very, very happy with the ffs work. And since this was the worst complication of my transition, I feel very fortunate.
  •