Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Do you think this is offensive?

Started by Ryuu, February 07, 2010, 12:14:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ryuu

WikiHow article: "How to Determine the Gender Of Your Date".
http://www.wikihow.com/Determine-the-Gender-of-Your-Date
It's just more of the stupid stereotypes about transpeople, and purporting them to be deceptive.
  •  

spacial

Kinda funny really.

Why anyone would want to go out with a guy who is so weird and self obscessed that he would bother to read and memorise such garbage?

But this tip from lower down is worth remembeing

QuoteIf you're having difficulty determining the gender of your date in the first place, you might want to ask someone else out instead.
  •  

Silver

QuoteYour feet do not shrink during transgendering. Look for larger, wider feet.

Transgendering. That made me laugh.
  •  

LynnER

You know... its not really THAT offensive. Its more sad... I facepalmed at half of this stuff...

Does the writer realize that he described Uma Thurman and atleast a half dozen other models and actresses (and tens of thousands of women in america alone)
  •  

Ryuu

Quote from: LynnER on February 07, 2010, 12:35:24 PM
You know... its not really THAT offensive. Its more sad... I facepalmed at half of this stuff...

Does the writer realize that he described Uma Thurman and atleast a half dozen other models and actresses (and tens of thousands of women in america alone)

I know.... it's pretty horrible. Whoever wrote this is probably very insecure and is never going to get laid due to being too worried about whether his date is transsexual.
And I also laughed at "transgendering". xD
  •  

Silver

If it's really just a homophobic/transphobic straight guy, wouldn't he just avoid overtly masculine women in the first place? I mean, wouldn't they just be unattractive to him? Any other, more feminine transsexuals likely wouldn't be "caught" with these tips. As Lynn says, there are also plenty of masculine XX women.

Whatever, lots of "how to spot the ->-bleeped-<-" guides on the internet.
  •  

gennee

Doesn't bother me really. Seen a lot worse.

Gennee
Be who you are.
Make a difference by being a difference.   :)

Blog: www.difecta.blogspot.com
  •  

Jay

QuoteCompare the length of your date's fourth and second fingers. Most men have ring fingers that are conspicuously longer than their index fingers, whereas most women have ring fingers that are close to the same length. Testosterone levels likely account for the greater length
This actually made me laugh!!! Mine is longer w00t!

QuoteLook for at least three of these characteristics before you draw conclusions about your date's gender, then make your plans accordingly.
Make plans accordingly genius!!!!!!!

Quote* Voice is not always a good indicator of gender -— a low voice may simply be the result of hard living.
    * If you're having difficulty determining the gender of your date in the first place, you might want to ask someone else out instead.
Absolute brilliance!!!!!

Jay


  •  

Luna!

I don't really see what the 'watch which washroom they use' tip is getting at; it goes on to say that they'll use the restroom appropriate to the image they're presenting, i.e. 'this tells you absolutely nothing'.

I was actually glad to see the last one (#9); it's about how keeping it secret is about self-preservation instead of deception, and you shouldn't judge without knowing the facts.

'Transgendering' is indeed a funny word. ^_^
  •  

Alyssa M.

Number 9 seems like the only one that matters.

Maybe someone should add a wikihow page for the ladies, titled, "Is your date a ->-bleeped-<- hating bigoted freak?"

Quote
   1. Let your hands rest on the table. Is he checking out your finger length ratios? Most ->-bleeped-<--haters are obsessed with minute developmental differences caused by intrauterine hormone levels that may or may not have anything to do with anything else. Also check out his big hairy knucles. Maybe it will freak him out.

   2. Is he looking at your feet? Bad sign. He's either a foot fetishist or a ->-bleeped-<- hater. Either way, ditch him.

   3. Be suspicious of any overly-large interest in your clothing. This indicates that he's either a ->-bleeped-<- hater, a ->-bleeped-<- ->-bleeped-<-, or just a closted ->-bleeped-<- himself, which is all fine and good, but probably not a good match for you.

   4. I assume you've had a tracheal shave if you need it, so the Adam's apple thing won't be an issue. Nevertheless, if he's spending too much time looking at your neck rather than your boobs, he's either a ->-bleeped-<- hater or a gay closet case.

   5. Again, he might check out your shoulders and hips, rather than your boobs. This is a sign of either transphobia or latent homosexuality. Bon't be fooled by guys who pretend to be "leg-men." They don't exist. All true men like boobies above all.

   6. If he makes a show of letting you go first through a door or up a flight of stairs, or makes any attempt to pretend to check out your butt, this is a clear sign he's not focusing on the one thing that should matter to him, i.e., your boobs. He's either gay or transphobic. Stay away.

   7. Going to the bathroom: If he tells you, "The men's room is over there, to the left," leave.

   8. Is he checking out your makeup? Suggest some tips for him. Maybe he could use some concealer. Perhaps he needs a better cleanser -- if he's a guy, it's almost certain that he does. He's just beginning to come to terms with his variant gender identity. Perhaps you can help him along the way!

   9. Be courteous and have a good time, but stay the hell away from bigoted freaks. Leave if anything seems amiss. There's literally nothing worse than finding yourself on the wrong end of a drunk bigot who doesn't see you as a human being.

Um ... yes, I find it offensive.
All changes, even the most longed for, have their melancholy; for what we leave behind us is a part of ourselves; we must die to one life before we can enter another.

   - Anatole France
  •  

Ryuu

Quote1. Let your hands rest on the table. Is he checking out your finger length ratios? Most ->-bleeped-<--haters are obsessed with minute developmental differences caused by intrauterine hormone levels that may or may not have anything to do with anything else. Also check out his big hairy knucles. Maybe it will freak him out.

   2. Is he looking at your feet? Bad sign. He's either a foot fetishist or a ->-bleeped-<- hater. Either way, ditch him.

   3. Be suspicious of any overly-large interest in your clothing. This indicates that he's either a ->-bleeped-<- hater, a ->-bleeped-<- ->-bleeped-<-, or just a closted ->-bleeped-<- himself, which is all fine and good, but probably not a good match for you.

   4. I assume you've had a tracheal shave if you need it, so the Adam's apple thing won't be an issue. Nevertheless, if he's spending too much time looking at your neck rather than your boobs, he's either a ->-bleeped-<- hater or a gay closet case.

   5. Again, he might check out your shoulders and hips, rather than your boobs. This is a sign of either transphobia or latent homosexuality. Bon't be fooled by guys who pretend to be "leg-men." They don't exist. All true men like boobies above all.

   6. If he makes a show of letting you go first through a door or up a flight of stairs, or makes any attempt to pretend to check out your butt, this is a clear sign he's not focusing on the one thing that should matter to him, i.e., your boobs. He's either gay or transphobic. Stay away.

   7. Going to the bathroom: If he tells you, "The men's room is over there, to the left," leave.

   8. Is he checking out your makeup? Suggest some tips for him. Maybe he could use some concealer. Perhaps he needs a better cleanser -- if he's a guy, it's almost certain that he does. He's just beginning to come to terms with his variant gender identity. Perhaps you can help him along the way!

   9. Be courteous and have a good time, but stay the hell away from bigoted freaks. Leave if anything seems amiss. There's literally nothing worse than finding yourself on the wrong end of a drunk bigot who doesn't see you as a human being.
You are awesome.  :laugh:
  •  

Miniar

@Alyssa...

nr. 6 but.. but... but... I'm an ass man.. I can't help it... boobs don't do that much for me. And it's polite, unless I'm showing the way, to let her go first. Especially in precarious stairs! Then I can catch you if you fall. ;)

Also, the list could be made way shorter by just having rule nr. 1;
If he spends more time looking at your shoulders, neck, hands and feet than your eyes and cleavage, then there's definitely something wrong with him.
_

Also, it's Wikihow, you can all go there and correct the errors if you like.



"Everyone who has ever built anywhere a new heaven first found the power thereto in his own hell" - Nietzsche
  •  

Ranktwo

  •  

Jeannette

Ignorant yes.  Offensive I don't know.  The poor thing that wrote that is making a lot of assumptions & stereotyping.  There are many transsexual women that don't have masculine voices, a tall stature, prominent brow ridges, big hands, super-size feet, an Adam's apple, wide shoulders, body-builder bodies, facial hair.  In fact there are many transsexual women who could stand in front of him & he wouldn't know the damn difference because there isn't any. ;)
  •  

spacial

In all honesty, I really don't think the sort of people who would need this sort of information will have many friends anyway.

Think about it. What he's worried about is, will this persona be any good in bed. In other words, he's taking someone out for sex. He's treating women like prostitutes, he pays them with dinner and expects his reward. But he want to be sure he's going to get the right reward.

There are a lot of men who think this way. But how many women want to be treated in this way?

Imagine a genetic female. She has her flaws and like every woman since the dawn of time, she know what they are and does her best to work past them. Then her date is examining her for any flaws. Like he's buying a dog, or a horse, or a second hand car.

I recall, when I was still at school. Every boy, (12 years old onwards), claimed to have bedded dozens of women. Information was exchanged on how to spot the best ones. If she's too friendly, that means she's desperate. You can alwasy tell a virgin because they walk with their knees apart. If a woman blows cigarette smoke in your face, that means she's interested in you.

The first time I got near any chance with a girl I was 17. After 5 years of the usual school boy nonsense. She lay down on the grass with her feet about 12 inches apart, fully clothed. I flopped down onto her, put my knees outside of hers and pulled her legs together. I really thought that was how I was suppose to act.

Someone once gave me a maxim about relationship that sums it up nicely.

It's to be experienced rather than discussed.
  •  

PanoramaIsland

Take a '50s screed by the John Birch Society about Communists infiltrating high places, replace "Red" with "->-bleeped-<-," and you get this. I laffed.
  •  

juliekins

I once had a therapist who claimed to have had TG patients, but kept referring to transition as "transgendering". Sure, you're experienced! :D I believe we educate more doctors and casual therapists about gender incongruence than all the schools and DSM (dummy shrink manuals)combined!
"I don't need your acceptance, just your love"
  •  

Janet_Girl

It seemed like every one, they would say something and then back step two steps.  Offensive? No.  Funny?  Not really.  Somewhat humorous, is about all I could muster.
  •  

umop ap!sdn

Oh that was very offensive!

Was. :angel:

Post Merge: February 20, 2010, 08:33:46 PM

Quote from: Janet Lynn on February 20, 2010, 06:25:05 PMIt seemed like every one, they would say something and then back step two steps.
The page has been pretty heavily edited. I took a look at the edit history and it has many many pages; the original article was very terse and only made generalizations. I suspect that since then a great number of reasonable people have had a hand in making the page what it is today.
  •  

Alex_I_Think

Not really... its just stupid. Why would you have to examine each date that closely to see if they're trans. The writer just seems paranoid to me.
  •