I was just really looking at my face (I am losing weight), and when I pull my hair off my face I kind of look like Madonna from 1983 except with smaller eyes and she has thicker eyebrows. But everything below her eyes (because they are much bigger) looks almost the same.

But do you think her face is kind of masculine for a typical woman?  Our noses and mouth and the jaw area are really proportionally to each other like the same distances.

http://www.madonnashots.com/island1.jpg

Especially in that photo.

Actually, she has a very feminine roundish face. 

Ok, I couldn't really tell, it's like it's an angular jaw, and she has thinner lips and a larger nose.

OMG! You're right she has a square jaw here and an bigger nose and thinner lips.

It's like besides: A) She's not wearing as much makeup, B) Eyebrows can change up a whole face, C) Hair color can do the same

If Madonna was a guy he would have even bigger arms.

Doesn't strike me as particularly masculine: the face is short. The jaw's a little angular but no big deal.