Quote from: rejennyrated on April 05, 2010, 04:10:13 AM
All I know is that I personally had no doubts probably mainly because I was so young and therefore gripped by the confident certainty of youth.
I won't share my full story in this post yet, but I will admit that when I was seventeen I had the courage to tell my high school class that I felt I should've been born a girl and that I deeply wished myself to be in an all-girls school for a feeling of belonging there. Yet I didn't have the knowledge, courage or support to move on with transition until ten years later. So far it has been an amazing ride and I've went through an enormous personal and social development in the process, which by the way ended up getting me into an all-girls study program recently

Quote from: rejennyrated on April 05, 2010, 04:10:13 AM
I also think perhaps we should ALL let this thread die quietly again, because whatever you may believe in private, there really is nothing much to be gained, by way of self respect, from bolstering your own ego by effectively attacking other people, who have done you no harm, and whose only "crime" was to live their lives in a different way from you.
I found it very interesting to read your individual stories with quite different perspectives and to hear from people who underwent surgery as well as those who haven't done so. I certainly don't want to judge anyone. I just want to listen to other peoples experiences and learn from them as I might, whether they are simmilar to mine or not.
Quote from: kimberrrly on April 05, 2010, 05:36:14 AM
You want to ask yourself difficult questions, but when you do some therapists sometimes get confused.
Do they get confused, do they just want to give us more time figuring out ourselves or are we just too afraid to tell them that we see both positive and negative consequences of transition?
In my country only 2-3 people are allowed to have SRS each year, which provokes a hell of a lot of fear of rejection and anger among the transsexuals. From my point of view this is not helping anyone not the ones hiding sincere doubts, nor the ones rejected by the system without feeling personally involved in the decision. The latter eventually finds another threatment route, which means some people who might not benefit from HRT etc. continues on that path regardless of the professional opinion.
Quote from: interalia on April 05, 2010, 12:51:28 AM
I have a blog linked in my signature if you'd like to see more of how I've dealt with my own issues.
That was a very interesting blog read. You certainly have not had an easy ride. The blog reminded me of a question I saw on a reality program some years ago: "What, as a man, have you learned from being a woman?"
Although people decidedly claiming androgynous identities - see for instance norrie mAy-wellby (
http://www.thescavenger.net/glbsgdq/my-journey-to-getting-a-sex-not-specified-document-86598.html) and some people even get surgeries to make their body congruent with an androgynous identity (
http://www.whatisgender.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=144&t=1091&start=0) - something did strike me in your blogs. I hope you won't mind me asking a couple of questions?
1. You write in your entry about Transition that you discovered that you were really a gay too afraid of admitting that rather than a transsexual, yet in your recent entries you write about being married with children? How do that piece together?
2. In your entry about transition you wrote about an encounter with a bisexual woman. I understand the circumstances surrounding that encounter was very unfortunate. Given that you are apparently together with a woman now how would you imagine life had been if you had found another transpositive woman?
3. Why do you think of GID as a disorder? Isn't it rather the society, which sanctionizes a certain behaviour in one person and not another solely on the basis of their genitalia, which is disordered?
4. I get you perfectly, when you write about a need to express yourself regardless of your genital sex. I too believe a greater freedom of expression would to some extent relieve some body disphoria, however it seems to me that while the two persons I referred to beforehand decidedly expressed an androgynous identity as the identity, which fit them best you are suffering from depression and maybe OCD to contain yourself within oppressive societal norms, which do not fit you well?
5. I get you too, when you write that identity is coupled with a need to or a feeling of belonging. In fact identity is said to always develop in relation to others, the very word actually means 'same as'. I would say my gender identity is strongly coupled with the third level in Maslow's pyramid: loving and belonging. I've found female friends outside the LGBT community to be very important to me and my college activities have helped me integrate well in this regard.
I wonder which role your female friendships outside church and LGBT communities played in your life while you lived as a woman and while you decided to de-transition?
I hope I am not being too direct? Otherwise feel free to skip some of the questions. I am just eager to hear from you to get different perspectives on how people deals with gender incongruencies.
Thanks
--
Tippe