Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Is being trans something you have to "come out about" ?

Started by Jah, June 12, 2011, 03:12:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jah

I have told a couple of close family members about my gender dysphoria but do you actually have to announce "I am transexual"? 

I just was wondering what others felt because at this point in my life (over 30) I feel like I don't really need anyones approval and I feel like I don't want negative feedback.  I have decided to go through with surgery but in the midst of the emotions on hormone therapy and feel like this is really a personal journey.

Anyway it's late night and just wanted to write some thoughts, maybe get feedback and have no one to really express these feelings to that would understand how I feel.
  •  

Cindy

It is a totally personal journey. It differes with your age, your acceptance and your life situation.

I need no ones permission to be me. Never have Never will

Hugs

Cindy
  •  

~RoadToTrista~

You don't have to and some people don't, but it can be emotionally frustrating not to. Your family would see you as a woman the rest of their lives. Aside from that, the hormones may eventually develop your body to the point where you'll no longer be able to pass as a woman. You wouldn't be able to see or talk to them again without coming out.
  •  

Muffins

I feel that there are two main ways to go about this, the verbal and the visible. The verbal is where you tell people before it's visibility apparent. I'd say this is the most common way as people generally feel they need others approval and acceptance so they know they'll be there for them in their time of need. Though sometimes they will be flat out rejected but then will know they will be going it alone, at least to begin with.. in time family can turn around and accept.

The other is visible, this is where you just start to in a sense desex yourself, move into the grey area and become androgynous. Painting over pink with blue is much harder than changing it to purple first then blue! I consider this to be less of a shock to the system for those that know you... it's a subtle change that they may not realise at first and just consider it to be who you are.. there is a quote "the art of persuasion is at best a slow process", that's no doubt misquoted but the jist of it is there.
Basically someone will not be so shocked by a seemingly natural change than a sudden change, they're more likely to point it out to you "wow you seem so much more confident these days", "you really don't take crap from anyone these days do you". Little things like that. If they say you should grow your hair out then just tell them you prefer it this way, then the day will come when someone will ask you why you seem so less feminine and you can tell them it's just who you are and that you've seen a doctor about it etc.
  •  

Espenoah

You don't have to. It's a personal choice.

I am telling my whole family though, since I am close to almost everyone and I would genuinely hurt them if I never told them. It's also better to know that I have support, and if I were to transition without telling them, I may lose support and trust that I otherwise may have had.
Besides, I want to know up front who to avoid at family get togethers rather than wonder who accepts me all the time.

But I'm younger than you and have a different view on everything. If you want to transition on your own terms without telling anyone, I don't see any reason why you can't.
"If a bullet should enter my brain, let that bullet destroy every closet door." -Harvey Milk
  •  

Jah

Thank you all for responding.  I just needed to hear different thoughts or experiences from those who have traveled this road. 

I don't really have a big family but my immediate family, I know are going to take my transitioning hard.  I had a dysphoria conversation with my aunt & tried to explain things to my sister. My friends know and some close co-workers know that I feel like I was "born in the wrong body".

I think I was misunderstood about the hormone therapy part or wrote it wrong but I am not yet on hormones. I am going through the process of getting top surgery tho.  I will tell the immediate family about my surgery when everything is set in place till then I am glad I have found this place I can come to share. :)
  •  

pebbles

Well no but you might end up in the same situation I did if you start HRT and a transition.

"Do you have the flu? You look really skinny pale and your voice is kinda strange."
"Maybe alittle... I feel fine"

*family hug*
"what are these bumps on your chest?"
"Err I've been working out abit... their pecs"

Eventually you have to explain yourself. as tough as it might be to break eventually the unbreakable masquerade will fall.
  •  

Cindy

Quote from: pebbles on June 15, 2011, 04:02:20 AM
Well no but you might end up in the same situation I did if you start HRT and a transition.

"Do you have the flu? You look really skinny pale and your voice is kinda strange."
"Maybe alittle... I feel fine"

*family hug*
"what are these bumps on your chest?"
"Err I've been working out abit... their pecs"

Eventually you have to explain yourself. as tough as it might be to break eventually the unbreakable masquerade will fall.

Love that Pebbles, Yea I've building my pecs, in an Arnold voice. :laugh: :laugh:

Hugs
Cindy
  •  

Jah

Thank you for your experiences. My aunt that I told has not responded...I feel a bit rejected. I started therapy this week..hopefully will sort some more things out.
  •  

wendy

Hi Jah,

It is personal.

I told close family because it was unfair not to tell them.  I think the rest of the world is either blind or just polite.

  •