Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Boys don't cry?

Started by Alex201, July 20, 2011, 09:38:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

tekla

Just remember, Hollywood never let the facts get in the way of the movie they were making.

"The Brandon Teena Story" is a much closer and more authentic telling of the story.
FIGHT APATHY!, or don't...
  •  

Silas

Quote from: Nygeel on July 21, 2011, 08:19:02 AM
This kind of sounds like "The Last Time I Wrore A Dress" which is a book.

Nah, that's not it. Looking it up, it sounds like a frightening experience, though.
Makes me wonder why people were ever committed to hospitals like that for GID or simple butchness/effeminacy. So weird and sexist.
  •  

Squirrel698

I did see it once all the way through.  That was before I decided to transition and it had a major affect on me. 

I've seen it a few times since than about halfway through.  Right before it goes south for Brandon I stop watching.

:'(
"It matters not how strait the gate, How charged with punishments the scroll, I am the master of my fate: I am the captain of my soul"
Invictus - William Ernest Henley
  •  

Darrin Scott

I have not seen this movie, but have read about it. It's stories like these that make me terrified to transition.





  •  

tekla

And how many stories like that are there?  Exactly one.  Avoid tying to pull that off in rural Nebraska in the early 90's with a bunch of two-time felons as running buddies and meth everywhere and you should be OK.
FIGHT APATHY!, or don't...
  •  

Darrin Scott

Quote from: tekla on July 21, 2011, 08:30:04 PM
And how many stories like that are there?  Exactly one.  Avoid tying to pull that off in rural Nebraska in the early 90's with a bunch of two-time felons as running buddies and meth everywhere and you should be OK.

Thanks......





  •  

tekla

It's the only FtM murder on the books anyone can find.  I would not make too much of it.  It's not likely to be repeated.
FIGHT APATHY!, or don't...
  •  

Darrin Scott






  •  

hwytoaster

I saw that movie long before I had a clue what it was really about. I thought it was awesome in that that's what I wanted to do was be seen as a guy. Weird how I didn't think I had that choice or option though.
  •  

Darth_Taco

I watched it on Netflix a few months ago. Pissed me off that they listed it under "Lesbian Romance" I haven't bothered to check to see if they changed it. Lemme check...Oh holy crap. I can't even find it on "Gay & Lesbian" anymore. Nice to see they changed it around. By the way, it's on instant stream. Anyway, bawled my eyes out. I'm gonna see if my boyfriend wants to watch it. He's really scared to because it immediately makes him think of me and whatever possible murder I'm facing. The poor bastard, he'd need cuddles before, during, and after.
  •  

rexyrex

I seen it and cryed too :( but it sad about the grave they put on she instead of he on the gravestone not sure if u know about that.

Also i think the reason he got killed as he was hanging around the wrong crowed and should have been more careful, it is a sad story and is happy that his gf accepted him.
Started Testosterone: 2013
Top surgery: 2014
Bottom surgery: 2016
  •  

bojangles

QuoteIt's the only FtM murder on the books anyone can find.

What about Emmon Bodfish?

http://gender-org.armadillodesigngroup.com/remember/people/emmonbodfish.html
  •  

Jav

watched the two thirds of the movie in manila, philippines back in early 2000, cried my eyes out... then again tried to watch it in 2001 or 2002, i think, again, cried my eyes out. but of course, that was waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay before T. am finding that i'm less easier to shed tears these days, post-T. i did cry this week to my therapist though, about something that's going on with my personal life that was really painful.
"I have nothing new to teach the world. Truth and Non-violence are as old as the hills. All I have done is to try experiments in both on as vast a scale as I could." Mahatma Gandhi
  •  

LordKAT

Crying makes no sense. Anger I could understand. I felt neither.
  •  

Jav

crying because one may have experienced a much similar incident that brandon did, @LordKAT, with the only difference that one was left alive.
"I have nothing new to teach the world. Truth and Non-violence are as old as the hills. All I have done is to try experiments in both on as vast a scale as I could." Mahatma Gandhi
  •  

James42

I watched it a couple times, I didn't cry but it left me with a sad feeling for Brandon. But at the same time, the movie (although its based on the Brandon Teena story) doesn't really highlight the fact that he was transgender and not just a girl dressing as a boy to hook up with other girls as the movie kind of makes him look like and what people who don't understand ->-bleeped-<- probably see it as, so I was kinda disappointed at that.
  •  

Adio

Watched it last night out of curiosity.  I was prepared to stop the movie and call if a friend if I had to.

But to be honest...I didn't cry or feel much of anything toward the movie.  Except for extreme boredom for the first hour.  I was a little upset at the end during the murder scene.  But the rape scene..nothing.  It probably didn't help that the one guy was jumping up and down, yelling excitedly. 

I didn't care for the movie itself either.  Hilary Swank is great, but I just wasn't that impressed otherwise.  I actually didn't find Brandon's character likable at all.  No one deserves to be raped or murdered.  But Brandon just wasn't genuine and I couldn't relate to the situation.   
  •  

Cowboi

Quote from: tekla on July 21, 2011, 10:11:21 PM
It's the only FtM murder on the books anyone can find.  I would not make too much of it.  It's not likely to be repeated.


I have to call BS on that one, but due to personal experience. I grew up in Nebraska, I have been to both Falls City and Humboldt. I have been chased out of Humboldt by people who wanted to kill me soooooo, I disagree. It is likely to be repeated. And honestly the entire situation was absolutely crazy and made no sense when it happened to me. I flat out knew NOBODY and had done NOTHING.

My two best friends and I were going camping at a lake to the west of Humboldt called Kirkman's Cove right after graduation our senior year of high school. I had been taken there many times in the past by a friend who lived in Auburn, Nebraska (which is about 20 minutes away, and where I spent pretty much every weekend of two years and both summers with my friend and her family) but I had never actually been in Humboldt itself, always just drove by to the lake. It got dark while we were out driving around and we couldn't find the turn back to the lake so we stopped at a bar right off the highway to ask directions since it was about 11 pm and nothing else was open (I ->-bleeped-<- you not there is not so much as a gas station open that late within like 50 freaking miles or more).

I walk in looking like nothing more than either a small lesbian or a 13 year old boy behind my two friends (seriously how they got away with being different and not almost getting killed in comparison to how looked I do not know). One of my friends is a very obviously female girl with a very obviously butch lesbian appearance (we are talking DD cups with a hair cut that looked like one of the lollipop guild ;p) and my gay male friend all gothed out in Hot Topic attire, glitter, and painted nails. I was literally wearing jeans and a white tshirt and was binding at the time... so I may never understand WHY I was picked out of that group lol. I only describe what we looked like because it makes it all so much ->-bleeped-<-ing crazier what happened.

They walked in a few feet ahead of me and went straight up to the bar to ask directions. The second I walked about 4 feet through the door an older woman sitting at a table with a few guys pointed right at me and simple said, "We should take that one out and shoot it." I just walked by, got to my friends and told them we needed to leave. They basically told me to stop acting weird until they turned around and saw the entire freaking bar just staring at me. So we all kind of just shuffled our way to the door and hopped in the car and took off down the high way to the lake.

A bit after closing time for bars they did come to the lake looking for us, shot guns in hand and everything. A whole freaking posse of rednecks came to hunt me. It was ->-bleeped-<-ing great. Thank God for 4 wheel drive, off road driving, creative driving (made our own exit through a pasture since there is only ONE road in and out) and enough gas to not stop till we made it back to Omaha. If all of those things did not exist I would not be alive today.
  •  

Cowboi

Welcome to Nebraska lol.
  •  

Lee

Quote from: Cowboi on July 23, 2011, 02:19:16 AM
Welcome to Nebraska lol.
Holy cow... Yeah, I'm going to stay in my 25 square miles surrounded by reality.  Here's hoping you don't have to deal with people like that in Omaha.
Oh I'm a lucky man to count on both hands the ones I love

A blah blog
http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/board,365.0.html
  •