Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Who we are

Started by Sevan, September 13, 2011, 11:27:36 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Sevan

I would love for this to be an informational sticky. We'll see how this goes.  ;D

I am an androgyn when I'm dressed in "women's clothes"

I am an androgyn when I'm dressed in "men's clothes"

I am an androgyn when I'm naked.

I am not an androgyn so I can have the "best of both worlds"

I am an androgyn who lives with both the pros, and the cons; of my gender identity and expression.

I am not an androgyn so I can confuse you, or f**k with your head.

I am an androgyn because it is my identity.

I am an androgyn because it is part of my core.

In fact...my identity has nothing to do with you....and everything to do with me.

I am an androgyn and I'm not confused about that. I'm not too scared to say I'm FtM. In fact...I'd rather it. I've TRIED to convince myself I'm fully male and it's just not the case. It's DAMN HARD to own my androgyn identity some days. The lack of understanding even within the trans community isn't easy. I'm not taking an easy road...because this *isn't easy*.

I am an androgyn and I was wired for a penis and a vagina....and it doesn't matter how much money I make, or how much I talk it over with my therapist...I will NEVER properly...have the configuration I was wired for.

As an androgyne I do suffer from GID just the same as other trans people.

I think one of the most difficult things about being androgyne is the lack of words we have available. We must use male/female gendered words to describe ourselves and this may not properly fit for some of us. We don't really have "androgyne gendered" words because...they don't exist. I'd LOVE for people to keep this in mind when interacting here on the androgyne board. While we use male words and female words...that's more because it's all we've got...and less because it fits properly.

I'd like to politly request that at least for *this thread* we refrain from describing ourselves as "I am me" because this doesn't help anyone to understand just *who "me" is* in a gendered/androgyne/third gendered/bi-gendered/null gendered/etc way.

I would love to create this thread as a place to have some "ah-ha moments". So let's tell the world...just who are we?
I'm also the spouse to the fabulous Mrs. Cynthialee.


  •  

AbraCadabra

Well thanks for this thread...

It IS tough even for us TSs to get our head around that.

Maybe, speaking for myself, I never will?

It's not for lack of trying, it's for lack of FEELING it.

Remember: "What we can not feel, we essentially do NOT understand"

I guess that also applies to all other TSs when being looked at from the binary cis-world.

I understand to be BI, 'cause I feel that's what I am, I understand TS -at least MtF- 'cause that's also WHAT I am. I can feel these things...

I just don't know or feel the Andro thing. At best to me it feels like the pain, when I was stuck between transition and my old life --- ever so painful, ... beyond me EVER wanting to go to this place EVER again. It is past, thank God.

And as I said it now, it might just explain to some others why we do not want to go to this place - EVER - again.
For us (TS) it depicted a purgatory along the road. You seem to have chosen that for your best place to stay. It is very difficult to get grip on that.

Nothing said in animosity just in trying to understand,
Axelle
Some say: "Free sex ruins everything..."
  •  

caseyy

I think that, really, it isn't that different from being TS. Take an MTF. They've been women their whole lives - an MTF is a woman in her men's clothes, in her women's clothes, she is a woman regardless of her body. She is not a woman if she likes frilly things and flowers, she's a woman because of who she is inside. She can like trucks and beer and still be a woman. Furthermore, she's a woman whether or not she can afford SRS. She's a woman if she's only on HRT. She's a woman if she's never had a drop of E in her life. All of these things (women's clothing, HRT, SRS, and other things) make her more comfortable in her body but they do NOT make her a woman; for she has always been one.

So androgynes...we may change our bodies to be more comfortable with who we are. Some androgynes may be more open with gender expression. But none of those things make us androgyne; just like a TS we have always been that way.
  •  

ativan

We can't even start a topic of Who We Are without a really wrong opinion from a MTF jumping right in, right at the start.
I give up, for the day.

Ativan
  •  

Shana A

A reminder about Rule 15

Quote15. Items under discussion shall be confined to the subject matter at hand, members shall avoid taking the other users posts personally, and/or posting anything that can reasonably be construed as a personal attack.

I believe that English isn't Axelle's primary language. In re-reading her post, I think I understand what she is trying to communicate, that she doesn't know how it FEELS to be androgyne. That isn't a judgement of being androgyne. Similarly, for any of us who don't share someone else's experience, we might empathize with them, but we can't ever know what it feels like. 

Zythyra
"Be yourself; everyone else is already taken." Oscar Wilde


  •  

ativan

#5
When I identified as genderqueer, it was a fairly fluid place to me. I saw the gender binary, but picked and chose between the traits there to better fit who I was. I wasn't putting on a performance or trying to be political. I was just using binary gendered language to describe different aspects of myself.
When I stopped doing that, I became much more comfortable identifying as androgyne. At that point, I stopped viewing different aspects of my personality or behavior as "masculine" or "feminine." They just are. I'm not some mystical blend of arbitrary gender concepts. I'm me. I have whatever gender exists outside of culture and societal prescription.
Since the terms are fairly fluid and may be applied in multiple ways, though, I don't much worry about what they might mean to other people. They're just words. Words can't encompass the reality of a human.
-Lepidoptera

We are the Gender Outlaws.  We are the free people who refuse to bow to the rigidity of historical gender rules.
-Laurry

Perhaps the most important thing we bring to another person is the silence in us, not the sort of silence that is filled with unspoken criticism or hard withdrawal. The sort of silence that is a place of refuge, of rest, of acceptance of someone as they are. We are all hungry for this other silence. It is hard to find. In its presence we can remember something beyond the moment, a strength on which to build a life. Silence is a place of great power and healing.
~Rachel Naomi Remen


Re: Shedding some light
« Reply #47
Quote
Having read the whole thread today (for the first time), I have a short answer, and a long answer.

Short version:  Androgyne is an umbrella term to describe anyone who does not identify as a male or a female. 

Long version:  There is an infinite variety of the way people perceive their gender.  Most people, if you ask them, will say "I'm a male (boy, man, guy, dude, etc.)," others "I'm a female (girl, woman, princess, goddess, etc.)".  These people are known as binary gendered people...they are one or the other.  There are some people, however, who do not feel they fit so neatly in those two categories.  They may be a mix of male and female (to varying degrees), both at the same time, neither, or their gender identities may float around all over the place.  The people who aren't male or female are androgynes.  There are as many sub-divisional categories of androgynes as there are people.


We all have a story to tell about how we came to understand that we weren't male or female.  Most are very interesting and, amazingly enough, have a lot of points in common regardless of how we identify themselves.

A certain amount of irreverence seems to be another common trait.  When one has spent a great deal of energy fighting against the societal pressure to conform to a male/female binary, a disregard of the gender rules inevitably follows.  This also tends to spill over into many other areas of our lives.  I tend to follow most of the rules of society that will keep me employed and out of jail, but generally consider the rest of them to be open to twisting, bending or breaking if the mood strikes me.

With the struggles to understand ourselves AND trying to explain why we aren't boys or girls, humor is a major coping mechanism. Given the choice to be in a constant state of rage over the injustice of being forced into a gender role that simply doesn't fit, or laughing at oneself and the incredible lengths people go to try to enforce "proper gender behavior", I'll take the laughter.

That doesn't mean there isn't still anger and frustration.  Of course there is.  But one gets so tired of fighting everyone.  It's not that they are bad people, they simply don't understand.  They can't comprehend the fact that we are happy outside the bounds of gender rules...and, truth be told, maybe just a little jealous.

Having finally cast off the roles and expectations of being a male, why in the world would I want to be subservient to the rules of being female?  We are the Gender Outlaws.  We are the free people who refuse to bow to the rigidity of historical gender rules.  We are full of sh*t, and proud of it.

And yes, one does eventually reach the point of saying "F it".  My "F it" response is usually followed by "This is who I am.  If you don't like it, tough.  You can be my friend, and accept me as I am, or you can go away and never bother me again.  I'm not changing"

.....L


Gender has no meaning or value if it is counterfeit.
Counterfeit gender is just a game, a trick, an amusement,
an act, a fraud, a deception, an imitation, artificial, bogus.

Be yourself, not a gender.
Being yourself is effortless and genuine.
Being yourself is REAL, not counterfeit.
In being yourself, in behaving in a manner which is natural to you,
whatever gender you are becomes self-evident.

-Emerald


In any case, relax.  It's not the end of the world...it's the beginning.

As you open yourself to possibilities,regardless of whether any of them happen,
you are free to actively chose your direction in life,not just be carried along with the current.

Laurry


All paths in life start in the Androgyn Forest.

The origin of collective thoughts are started by a single Androgyn idea.

The farther away you get from the Androgyn Core, the worse life will get.
-Ativan

This was someones answer when someone else was wanting to find meaning and a point for living.

"It's less of a matter of there not being a point, and more of where that point comes from.  The reason people can't find the meaning to life is because they are looking for something other than themselves to give them meaning.

But "meaning" is not an inherent property of the natural world.  Meaning is a subjective aspect of intelligence.

If I ask you what "table" means you could give me definitions of what table means, because you have studied the English language.  But "table" has no inherent meaning.  It has an agreed upon social meaning.  When I say "table" you know what it means, because you have agreed beforehand as to what it means.

Life is the same way.  It has no inherent meaning.  It means whatever you think it does."
-VeryGnawty

*deep breath*

I am an androgyn when I'm dressed in "women's clothes"
I am an androgyn when I'm dressed in "men's clothes"
I am an androgyn when I'm naked.

I don't properly fit in the women's rest room, or the men's rest room.
Part of me fits in a gaggle of women.....but part of me never will.
Part of me fits in a group of men....but part of me doesn't get them at all.

I am an androgyn when I knit, and quilt.
I am an androgyn when I work with wood, and improve my homestead.

I am not an androgyn so I can have the "best of both worlds"
I am an androgyn who lives with both the pros, and the cons; of my gender identity and expression.
I am not an androgyn so I can confuse you, or f**k with your head.

I am an androgyn because it is my identity.
I am an androgyn because it is part of my core.

In fact...my identity has nothing to do with you....and everything to do with me.

I am an androgyn and I'm not confused about that. It's DAMN HARD to own my androgyn identity some days. I'm not taking an easy road...because this *isn't easy*.

I am an androgyn and I was wired for a penis and a vagina....and it doesn't matter how much money I make, or how much I talk it over with my therapist...I will NEVER properly...have the configuration I was wired for.

I am an androgyn....and this journey to be my most core self...has left scars. But it's been worth it. Every step, every choice, every layer of this onion I've removed...it's been worth it.

I am an androgyn.

Written by Sevan 9/12/2011
Modified by Ativan, same day



Those are some of the things that I have collected since I first came to this site.
I have them on my desktop, so I can go through them every so often to try and stay centered.
I hope you find them useful, too.
-Ativan



  •  

ZaidaZadkiel

I am what i am, because i cannot be otherwise; it would not be me.

...

You know you are an androgyne when...

... you refuse to be a man the same as you refuse to be a woman.

... your mind tells you that you're different from guys in some ways and the same as guys in some other ways and that you are different from girls in some ways and the same as girls in other ways.

... you feel like a girl you try to be like a guy, and when you feel like a guy you try to be like a girl.

... your life is in a constant state of paradox.

... you can translate guy thoughts into girl speak and girl thoughts into guy speak.

... you would date an alien

... combat boots with a frilly miniskirt are awwright.

... motorcycle and engine repair is as much fun as is makeup and fashion
  •  

Pica Pica

I don't find the androgyne thing to be about pain, or confusion or wrongness, it's all about being right. About being whole and complete - why everyone else has this huge searing tear defining them as male person or female person I don't get.

A binary identity does seem like an identity with a big rip in it, don't understand it all really.
'For the circle may be squared with rising and swelling.' Kit Smart
  •  

Eva Marie

Being an androgyne is not about making a fashion statement, although many of us feel free to dress unconventionally. It is a realization that your gender is between the binaries - you do not identify strongly as a man or a woman.

Being an androgyne <> androgyny, which some members here don't yet know.

  •  

foosnark

I have a male body, and that doesn't bother me much.  Gender is a distant third, or lower, on my list of body issues.  I'm jealous of female bodies a hundred times more frequently than male bodies but I know deep down that I would be no happier living as a woman than as a man.  Neither really fits.

Before I had been exposed to the concept of non-binary gender, I felt I had a male personality and a female personality that were integrated into a whole person.  (I don't consider myself multiple.)  But I neglected the female side for quite a while, and in the last couple of years she increasingly wanted a voice. That need fed some soul-searching and research, and here I am.

I am comfortable in this middle space... even with the outside world wanting to pry me out of the cracks in the walls and make me sit in one room or the other.  It's about identity, not presentation.  My happiness does not depend on how much I look like not-a-guy.  It's almost entirely interior landscape.  Sure I interdress a little bit, but that's more because I can than because I need to. Most day I just wear "mens'" clothing and I always use male pronouns and that's just fine.  I know who I am.
  •  

Shana A

Who Am I?

I am a person who, in 1993, transitioned M2F and lived full time for over a year. During that time I lost some friends and many jobs (I am self employed). I was happier walking in the world as a woman than as a man, but ultimately that felt like a box too. I re-transitioned, not back to male, but to a non-binary sense of gender where I have lived ever since. I am not male, not female. I am not both. I am neither.

I have often used the word androgyne to describe this, and share some things in common with androgynes, however I don't actually identify as anything. Just human. Just Zythyra.

Z
"Be yourself; everyone else is already taken." Oscar Wilde


  •  

mimpi

Quote from: ZaidaZadkiel on September 13, 2011, 02:29:00 PM
I am what i am, because i cannot be otherwise; it would not be me.

...

You know you are an androgyne when...

... you refuse to be a man the same as you refuse to be a woman.

... your mind tells you that you're different from guys in some ways and the same as guys in some other ways and that you are different from girls in some ways and the same as girls in other ways.

... you feel like a girl you try to be like a guy, and when you feel like a guy you try to be like a girl.

... your life is in a constant state of paradox.

... you can translate guy thoughts into girl speak and girl thoughts into guy speak.

... you would date an alien

... combat boots with a frilly miniskirt are awwright.

... motorcycle and engine repair is as much fun as is makeup and fashion

Azzeccato!

There's a lot of truth in there, makes me consider my own position to be honest. What Zythra later said about being just human is what I've said myself on these boards, when it comes down to it that is what some of us feel and nothing more.

To be frank perhaps it's a cultural thing, perhaps northern european and anglo saxon cultures are hard on some things, who knows. I've seen more tolerance for gender variant behaviour elsewhere even though persecution is still rampant, tolerance not acceptance. In Italy Vladimir Luxuria, a non op transexual, was voted into parliament to represent Rifondazione Comunista http://notimaz.blog.kataweb.it/files/photos/uncategorized/manif_5.jpg . Ms Luxuria retained the name Vladimir out of respect for her status and out of respect to her parents who named her Wladimiro in memory of Lenin. I've no idea about the US but this most certainly could not happen here in the UK, absolutely unimaginable both politically and as regards gender.

Although I feel more female than male and have been out for most of my life it seems sometimes a betrayal of my identity to identify as such. In a utopian world things would be different of course... Sad that we cannot get there yet, we have responsibilities in this and whether we like it or not; the struggle continues.

Am no longer specifying my gender from now on here and am off to buy cigarettes due to the stress!

Big hug to you all for writing some great stuff. :)

> edited for typo
  •  

LilDoberman

I'm not a boy.  I'm not a girl.  I can play pretend and fit into those roles when I need to, but they're like a bad pair of shoes and come off as soon as possible.  I don't have the energy or patience to pretend to be a girl all the time; it's wrong for me. 

I guess my closest description is that it's a bit like traveling:  I can go to London or Paris and have a good time.  I can speak the language, eat the food and see the sights but no matter how much fun it is, I always want to go home eventually. 
--Deanne  :P
  •  

mimpi

With you too on what you said there, LilDoberman.

Why is it that gender variance and an androgynous position in particular arouse such anger in some?
  •  

ZaidaZadkiel

Quote from: mimpi on September 13, 2011, 07:26:00 PM
With you too on what you said there, LilDoberman.

Why is it that gender variance and an androgynous position in particular arouse such anger in some?

QuoteMaybe, speaking for myself, I never will?

It's not for lack of trying, it's for lack of FEELING it.

Remember: "What we can not feel, we essentially do NOT understand"
Pretty much for the same reason anybody hates anybody else.
  •  

ativan

  •  

kyle_lawrence

I tried to think of a way to reply to this thread that follows Sevan's rule to not say "I'm just me", but I can't.  I am just me, I don't fit into any rules for what is male or what is female, I'm just me.  And as Pica Pica said, I struggle to understand the feelings that make people so sure that they are a specific binary gender. 

I know some of my posts may seem contradictory to this, as I would like to take testosterone and have top surgery and change my body to appear more male, but that doesn't mean I identify as strictly male.  I am an androgyne who is most comfortable presenting with a masculine appearance.  I primarily blame this on societies expectations that you are either male or female, and my desire to have a successful career and comfortable lifestyle.
  •  

Kinkly

I am me I have always been me I tried being Male but it was always fake I never could fit in,  because everyone else could see that I was different. 
I tried to suppress that which was not acceptable but that only left me hating myself.
I am Androgyne and I no longer suppress that witch is seen as Femme or what is seen as Manly.
I was Androgyne then but only knew it as different or Weird.
or from a different Planet:- Men Mars, Women Venus, Me Pluto.
now that I accept who I am I do my best to be "Not Normal" and show both sides of who I am.
I'm not wired for the bits I have "down there" but the other option doesn't seem right either sometimes I feel like I should have both other times I want neither.  I will definitely make some change in the future.
I don't understand guy talk and girl talk can be confusing.
the Idea that I want the best of both worlds is insulting, as much as that would be great but experiencing the worst of both worlds simultaneously is more common then best of either and I fit in neither world making my world lonely

to the Ms TS who tells me I'm taking the easy path or that I need to choose.
I don't know whats so easy about not fitting in or having to fight AGAINST a world of binary insistent people just to be true to who I am.

I felt wrong supressing that which I was told not to do,
I feel right when I ignore the gendered rules and just be me.  :)
I don't want to be a man there from Mars
I'd Like to be a woman Venus looks beautiful
I'm enjoying living on Pluto, but it is a bit lonely
  •  

Taka

for many good reasons i used to think i was actually ftm. until i read a manga about a bigendered person and realized that even if i transition into a man, there's no way i'd wanna let go of my pretty dresses, occasional girly behavior, and other things that a manly man isn't supposed to have (like my vagina..)

actually i'd rather wish i knew a spell that could make me into a man when i want to be one, and a woman when i want to be one. or maybe just have very androgynous features so that people wouldn't dare trying to categorize me as any gender, and that way have them define me by who i am and not what i look like. or maybe a true hermaphrodite, because i can't imagine not having a vagina, just like not having a penis feels really weird

but how i look doesn't really matter, because in the end it will never be anything more than a poor reflection of the feeling inside. and this feeling tells me, every time i take a quiz or answer a questionary, that "male" and "female" are equally untrue about me. i'm am both and i am neither, and i really don't like the thought of representing a group that i can't identify with in statistics, or that anything should be assumed about me based on my gender assigned at birth

and as zaida wrote, i'd love to date an alien
  •  

Julian

I also tried to think of how to articulate myself without saying I'm "just me," but fell short. It seems like I can only identify myself by saying what I'm not.

I'm not a man or a woman.
Not a girl or boy.
Not femme nor butch.
I'm not both of any of the above.
I'm not even sure I'm an androgyne. That's a gender, and I don't think I have one of those.
I'm just a person. Not even sure that I'm human a lot of the time.
There's a reason it says "none of the above" under my avatar.

I'm not sure if this belongs in this thread anymore. I'm sorry. And I'm also frustrated now.
  •