I really want to buy a reelmagik prosthetic, but like many of you im looking for something that is in the size range for an everyday pack AND play.
I know im not the only one that thinks 4.5" long by 4" around is great for packing but too small for playing, and 6.2" long by 6" around is way too big to wear everyday, not to mention the girth seems a little scary.

So I figured id ask you guys what your ideal size would be, and see if maybe we can like ask them to make one for us so that it wouldnt be a custom order cost of an arm and a leg. Get me?

I would say that the length should be between 5" and 5.5" and the girth should be between 4.5" and 5".
I also prefer it to have 3D balls.

Or if the 6" was available with a smaller girth, id definitely be interested in that.

My ideal size for a prosthetic would be 4 inches.  "Small" but I want something that is a good size flaccid.  To me, 4 inches isn't that bad erect.  Would I prefer something larger?  Of course, but I think (for myself) packing anything more than 4.5" would be ridiculous.  I just have too small a frame for it, and I'm already slightly paranoid about my bulge anyway.  3D balls would be a must for me.

something around 5 length and 5 girth is probly that happy medium (a little on the girthy side but 5 and 5 sounds good). 3D balls and some kind of STP/flex rod that work and make it as realistic as reelmagik and I'd say that would be the ideal prosthetic.

i'm not mad at 4.5 and 4 tho, but I'm a cismale and I "top" my partner who is getting the 4.5" prosthetic so the need for size here is different. We just need a good dick not necessarily a big one 

I have read that the average vagina length is only about 4inches and that women only "feel" the first few inches anyway? I don't know not my area of expertise, I suppose talking to your partner is the best way to figure out what she needs to be satisfied here.

Yeah, I prefer a small one too because im a small guy but idk why I have it in my head that size in important I guess im thinking more about the sex part, something that can grow or change size like the tyron would be nice.

I agree with you Finn, 5 and 5 sound about right for something in the middle.
Or at least a nice small 3.5-4" realistic stp pack id be happy with.

I think im leaning more towards the 4" if what you said has any fact to it lol.
My partner and I agree that the 6 is way too thick, but we feel the 4 is too thin, too bad there isnt one in the middle.