If you could, would you have periods?

[Elsa.G]

or if you were given the chance to have just one, would you take it?

[AbraCadabra]

Well, since not being able to have babies/get pregnant, was such a GID item with we - still is to some degree - I would OBVIOUSLY need to have periods.

So the answers is a VERY clear YES

Axélle

[GhostTown11]

Well I am not MTF but if I were I don't know why you want them they're a nuisance!

[AbraCadabra]

Well I am not MTF but if I were I don't know why you want them they're a nuisance!

Well, yes, THEY ARE a nuisance I'm sure... but no babies without periods.
Yet to have at least one baby of my VERY own, be worth the nuisance, and --- even there, were ALL different, eh?

Axélle

[Sephirah]

Yes but I doubt I'd be too enthusiastic about it during the event. To me it would be just something that comes as part of the package deal.

[pretty]

No, definitely not. I'll at least take my 1 advantage I get from being trans--I have enough disadvantages as-is.

Btw the pregnancy thing doesn't matter to me because I don't want kids.  we are like, overpopulating p badly already. And I'm too immature to be a mother. 

[Keroppi]

It's not the periods I would want, it's the ability to have children that I want.

[Adrasteia]

I'd like to have children, but I don't have strong feelings about wanting to carry them. Growing up around a lot of women and subsequenty living with women in my adult life, I think I'll pass on menstruation. :-)

[~RoadToTrista~]

Assuming I still couldn't have babies, yeah, I'd have 1 just to see what it's like, lolz

But unless they allow babies then nty

[Assoluta]

I can't count the amount of genetic women who've said to me - "You're so lucky not to have periods". Do you want to have a penis and testicles, despise your body, not feel like a woman, feel unlovable on a very deep fundamental level, and go through major surgery and be unable to have children? I didn't think so.

[Natkat]

I belive this question should be kind of put in 2 pieces.

1 "if you could have your period and become pregnent, would you?"
2"if you couldn't become pregnent but still was able to experience period, would you?"
----
to be honest I see the point in people who wanna have kids, but beside the children parts there's really nothing good about periods, and no matter how I see it I dont think any woman who wouldn't like to have kids should wish for them.

why wishing for having all that pain? cause it would prove you more of a woman..?
periods dosen't do that, only ignorants use it as a lame exuse.
just my opinion.

but something ells I wonder,
Cant mtf gets some kind of periods?.
I meaning not the same as cis-women with blood, but still felling mood changings and suchs.
some mtf I talked to had mention something like that, and some said its not posible.. I really don't know what to belive?

[Annah]

a menstrual period? Ill pass

[mementomori]

No, definitely not. I'll at least take my 1 advantage I get from being trans--I have enough disadvantages as-is.

Btw the pregnancy thing doesn't matter to me because I don't want kids.  we are like, overpopulating p badly already. And I'm too immature to be a mother. 

ditto

[Stephanie_b]

Assuming I still couldn't have babies, yeah, I'd have 1 just to see what it's like, lolz

But unless they allow babies then nty

^This

[pretty pauline]

I belive this question should be kind of put in 2 pieces.

1 "if you could have your period and become pregnent, would you?"
2"if you couldn't become pregnent but still was able to experience period, would you?"

Yes to both questions because Im a woman, its the only feminine experience Iv never had, my 2cents.
Pauline

[Adrasteia]

but something ells I wonder,
Cant mtf gets some kind of periods?.
I meaning not the same as cis-women with blood, but still felling mood changings and suchs.
some mtf I talked to had mention something like that, and some said its not posible.. I really don't know what to belive?

Hormone levels can rise and fall for both genders, it's just not very predictable or often as dramatic in cisdudes. I've seen a number of studies that tried to get more info on this, but I don't think anyone came away with very statistically significant findings (that I saw).

[Julie Wilson]

I guess I would have to think about it.  If it came with being able to be pregnant, a female skeleton, small hands and feet, narrow shoulders and chest cavity, etc. etc.  sure but if not then why bother?

why add more bad on top of bad?

[Julie Wilson]

Hormone levels can rise and fall for both genders, it's just not very predictable or often as dramatic in cisdudes. I've seen a number of studies that tried to get more info on this, but I don't think anyone came away with very statistically significant findings (that I saw).

The time hormone levels drop in transsexuals is when their last shot is wearing off or their last pill.  Beyond that there are lunar cycles.

[Julie Wilson]

I can't count the amount of genetic women who've said to me - "You're so lucky not to have periods". Do you want to have a penis and testicles, despise your body, not feel like a woman, feel unlovable on a very deep fundamental level, and go through major surgery and be unable to have children? I didn't think so.

^ Stated for Truth

[Keaira]

Err.. I get all the fun without the mess. Bloating, cramping, irritability, more emotional and feel weaker, etc. All that  but no bleeding It has me a little concerned but no limbs have fallen off yet.

Does that make it Phantom Bite week for me if the guy's call it Shark Week?

So, after almost 1 year, 3 months I can tell you this:   

IT SUCKS!

But, would I give it up? Not on your life Missy!

And to be able to give birth, I'd celebrate Shark Week with a party every month!

I seem to be a minority in my monthly experience with this though