I like makeup way too much.
My top-top-top picks are:
MAC Vanilla Pigment. This stuff lasts literally forever, and mine's almost empty at this point.
Lipstick Queen Sinner collection lipsticks. Three different shades (Coral, Pinky Nude, and Peachy Nude, in that order) have been my favorite every day shade for 6+ months at a time.
Kevyn Aucoin Sensual Skin Enhancer. These are just fun to play with. I use two shades every day and want, like, at least two more.
MAC Paint Pots. Painterly for my lid and Groundwork for my crease. Couldn't survive without them.
Laura Mercier Tightline Eye Liner. Tightlining is just really pretty. I feel like it gives you the same impact as a dramatically lined eye while still looking natural.
Hourglass Brow Sculpting Pencil. It's the one for me.
Make Up For Ever HD Powder. I've tried a lot of loose powders. Some are too matte (skin doesn't look like that!), others don't combat shine well enough. This one strikes the best balance I've come across.
Becca Nude Liner in Biscotti. I'm obsessed.
This post could be endless. I will stop it here.